Magnolia churches granted new trial regarding water rates following Travis County ruling

Litigation between the city of Magnolia and three Magnolia churches regarding water rates is still ongoing following an Aug. 16 ruling in a Travis County district court.

Litigation between the city of Magnolia and three Magnolia churches regarding water rates is still ongoing following an Aug. 16 ruling in a Travis County district court.

After several petitions filed by First Liberty Institute—a legal organization representing Magnolia Bible Church, First Baptist Church of Magnolia and Believers Fellowship—and the city of Magnolia, the city will face a new trial regarding the institutional water user category implemented by Magnolia City Council in spring 2018 following a Travis County district court ruling Aug. 16.

Previously, institutions—tax-exempt, nonprofit or government entities such as churches and schools—were grouped in the same category as businesses and charged the same rate, Community Impact Newspaper previously reported.

Magnolia City Administrator Paul Mendes previously told Community Impact Newspaper that 24% of the city’s water and wastewater usage comes from residents and businesses, while the other 76% comes from those in the institutional user category. Water bills are issued in a tiered fee schedule; the more water used, the more it costs, he said.

“Our homeowners—less than 2,000 people—are subsidizing the institutions who service a much larger area,” Mendes said. “The whole purpose of this rate was to make it fair across the board, not target the churches.”

Originally, the city, represented by law firm Lloyd Gosselink, filed a petition Nov. 14 in a Travis County district court seeking legality and validity on the city's tiered fee schedule, including the institutional rates, said James Parker, the city's counsel at Lloyd Gosselink.

The court ruled Feb. 7 that the city's institutional user category was legal and valid and issued a permanent injunction—a judicial order restraining an entity from pursuing a specific action that threatens the legal right of another—against any entity that contests the court’s ruling, Community Impact Newspaper previously reported.

Jeremy Dys, the deputy general counsel for First Liberty Institute, said no one had informed the churches or First Liberty about the Feb. 7 ruling.

“The city has intentionally tried to avoid the accountability that the law provides by going hundreds of miles away from any voter in the city of Magnolia and trying to get a judge down there to relieve them from this liability that they knew was coming,” Dys said.

First Liberty filed a petition June 13 in a Travis County district court requesting a new trial, claiming the city violated the due process clause of the 14th Amendment.

The Aug. 16 ruling granted the churches' request for a new trial, according to the court documents. A new trial date has not been announced as of publication Aug. 19, Dys said.

"I’m grateful that the court has allowed these churches to evaluate this issue in an open court and allow their voice to be heard," Dys said. "The city has not allowed them to do so this entire time."

Mendes said the decision is up to the lawyers.

"We're leaving it to the lawyers to find the best course of action. It's all up to [them] now," Mendes said.

Read the Aug. 16 ruling below.

SHARE THIS STORY
By Kara McIntyre

Kara started with Community Impact Newspaper as the summer intern for the south Houston office in June 2018 after graduating with a bachelor's degree in mass communication from Midwestern State University in Wichita Falls, Texas. She became the Tomball/Magnolia reporter in September 2018. Prior to CI, Kara served as the editor-in-chief of The Wichitan—Midwestern State University's student-run campus newspaper—and interned with both the Wichita Adult Literacy Council and VeepWorks.


MOST RECENT

See a few lane closures scheduled this weekend in Tomball and Magnolia. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
3 lane closures to know in Tomball, Magnolia this weekend, Feb. 21-23

See a few lane closures scheduled this weekend in Tomball and Magnolia.

Garden Accents opened on FM 2978 in February. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Garden Accents now open after relocating to FM 2978

Garden Accents opened Feb. 10 after relocating from 15131 FM 2920 to 25252 FM 2978, Tomball. Garden Accents …

The storefront will open Feb. 24. (Courtesy Natural Ways CBD and More)
Natural Ways CBD and More to open Pinehurst storefront

Natural Ways CBD and More also has a location in Tomball.

Jordan Brooks, market specialist at ALN Apartment Data, speaks at the Houston Apartment Association’s Montgomery County State of the Submarket Breakfast on Feb. 18. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
Moderate growth in apartment rent, occupancy on Montgomery County's horizon

Experts: County well-positioned for moderate rent growth, average to above-average apartment occupancy for 2020 and 2021

Cheetos Cheese Pickles from Biggy's (Courtesy Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo)
Cheetos cheese pickles, mac and cheese eggrolls, deep-fried cheesecake: 93 food spots to try during the 2020 Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo

From tried and true to something new, the food options at this year's Rodeo include classic staples and crazy concoctions.

Lone Star College System has $185 million remaining from its 2014 bond referendum. (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Lone Star College System updates 2014 bond project progress

Lone Star College System continues to make improvements to campuses through an $485 million bond that passed in 2014.

Matthew Fank, who spoke during the public comment period Feb. 17 opposing adoption of the city's dangerous animals ordinance, said he owns property on South Cherry Street in Tomball and plans to open an exotic pet shop in the city. (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas residents speak out against dangerous animals ordinance at Tomball City Council meeting

Tomball City Council approved an ordinance Feb. 17 prohibiting the possession of dangerous animals within city limits.

TX Arsenal will host a soft opening Feb. 20. (Courtesy TX Arsenal)
TX Arsenal plans Feb. 20 soft opening in Pinehurst

The business is a one-stop source for customers' shooting needs, according to its website.

Texas Central officials announced interior plans Feb. 17 for the company's proposed high-speed train connecting Houston and Dallas. The Shinkansen trains in Japan will be customized for Texas with no middle seats and additional legroom, company officials announced. (Courtesy Texas Central)
JUST IN: Texas Central gives first glimpse of high-speed train car interior

Texas Central officials announced interior plans Feb. 17 for the company's proposed high-speed train connecting Houston and Dallas.

The McTeggart Irish Dance School relocated from Magnolia to Tomball in January. (Courtesy The McTeggart Irish Dance School)
Irish dance school relocates to Tomball

The McTeggart Irish Dance School relocated from along FM 1488 in Magnolia to 701 E. Main St., Tomball, in January.

Brian Clack (left) is running against incumbent Chris Jones for Precinct 5 constable in the March 3 Republican primary.
Q&A: Meet the Republican candidates running for Montgomery County Precinct 5 constable

Two candidates are running for Montgomery County Precinct 5 constable in the March 3 Republican primary.

The Tex-Mex restaurant will be the first dining option at Creekside Park West in The Woodlands when it opens its doors this summer. (Courtesy The Howard Hughes Corp.)
Baja Sur Fresh-Mex and Tequila Bar to launch in early summer at Creekside Park West

The new concept is the first Tex-Mex offering from local restaurateurs John Amato and Jason Daly.

Back to top