UPDATED: U.S. appeals court pauses decision voiding face covering exemption at polling places

Face coverings are not required for those entering polling places in Texas during the general election. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Face coverings are not required for those entering polling places in Texas during the general election. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Face coverings are not required for those entering polling places in Texas during the general election. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Updated Oct. 29 12:43 p.m.

A U.S. district court judge's decision that would have required all Texans to wear face coverings in polling places during the general election is on hold following after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit temporarily halted the ruling Oct. 28.

The Oct. 27 decision by U.S. District Judge Jason Pulliam voided a portion of Gov. Greg Abbott's statewide face covering order issued in July that had exempted voters, election workers and poll watchers from adhering to the masking mandate at polling locations. In his decision, Pulliam sided with plaintiffs, including the civic and civil rights organizations Mi Familia Vota and the Texas State Conference of the NAACP, who said the exemption violated the Voting Rights Act due to the disproportionate COVID-19 case, hospitalization and death rates that Black and Latino Americans experience.

The plaintiffs argued that, due to higher health risks related to COVID-19, a lack of protection against the disease at the polls could disenfranchise minority voters by keeping them from voting in person. In his decision, Pulliam acknowledged the face covering exemption could deter or deny Black and Latino Texans from voting and that voiding the exemption would not substantially affect the ongoing election.

Gov. Abbott and Secretary of State Ruth R. Hughs, the defendants in the case, appealed Pulliam's decision Oct. 27 resulting in the Fifth Circuit granting a temporary administrative stay Oct. 28. The court will now decide whether to grant the stay on the district court decision requested by Abbott and Hughs.


Posted Oct. 28 6:20 p.m.

An exemption in Gov. Greg Abbott's July statewide face covering order that allowed voters, election workers and poll watchers to abstain from wearing masks in polling places was invalidated Oct. 27 by a San Antonio judge who cited the exemption as discriminatory against Black and Latino Texans' voting rights.

With the voiding of the exemption, face coverings over the wearer's nose and mouth are now required at polling places—although the decision was appealed by the state Oct. 27. In-person voting remains open statewide through the less than three remaining days of early voting, which concludes Oct. 30, and on Election Day Nov. 3.

The decision by U.S. District Judge Jason Pulliam stemmed from a complaint initially brought against Abbott and Secretary of State Ruth R. Hughs in July by Texas residents Micaela Rodriguez and Guadalupe Torres, the national Latino and immigrant civic engagement organization Mi Familia Vota, and the Texas State Conference of the NAACP civil rights organization.

The October decision concerned the plaintiffs' claim Exemption 8 of the statewide masking mandate, which made face covering requirements optional for "any person who is voting, assisting a voter, serving as a poll watcher, or actively administering an election," violated Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act by creating an alleged "discriminatory deterrence from voting," according to the October decision.

Torres, Mi Familia Vota and the NAACP conference initially argued for a wider array of changes to voting procedures during the general election in Texas this year, arguments that were dismissed by Pulliam in September. The judge's Oct. 27 decision concerned only the exemption for mask-wearing in polling places after the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals handed the case back down to the district court to determine whether the portion of Abbott's July order in question conflicted with the Voting Rights Act and if removing the exemption would affect the election and address the plaintiffs' concerns.

According to the October district court filing, the plaintiffs alleged Black and Latino Americans' general increased risk of COVID-19 infection and related hospitalization and death combined with the health risks associated with possible exposure and spread of the disease at polling places could keep minority voters from political participation this fall.

"[The] disproportionate infection rate and the more severe health consequences that Black and Latino people face from the coronavirus mean that voting procedures that fail to provide the necessary health and safety protections to all voters in the context of this pandemic will disproportionately burden the rights of Black and Latino voters, in particular," the plaintiffs argued, according to Pulliam's decision.

Nationwide data compiled by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention shows that, compared to non-Hispanic white people, the COVID-19 case rate ratio is 2.6 times higher among non-Hispanic Black or African-American people and 2.8 times higher for Hispanic or Latino people. COVID-19 hospitalization rates compared to white people are 4.7 times higher among Blacks and 4.6 times higher among Latinos, while COVID-19 death rates among Black and Latino Americans 2.1 and 1.1 times higher than among whites, respectively.

In his decision, Pulliam voided Exemption 8 of the face-covering order and said any effects of the change would be outweighed by the resolution of the discriminatory issue at the polls. All other exemptions and enforcement provisions of Abbott's order were unaffected.

"Exemption 8 imposes a 'voting practice or procedure which results in a denial or abridgement of the right of Black and Latino citizens to vote on account of race or color,'" Pulliam wrote. "The mask-mandate Exemption 8 is invalid and void does not 'materially or substantially affect the ongoing election,' and any disruption is outweighed by the racially discriminatory deterrent effect on Black and Latino citizens’ fundamental right to vote."

Abbott and Hughes filed a notice of appeal to the Fifth Circuit Oct. 27 following Pulliam's decision.
By Ben Thompson
Ben joined Community Impact Newspaper in January 2019 and is a reporter for The Woodlands edition.


MOST RECENT

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced Dec. 2 that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has allotted 1.4 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccines to the state of Texas. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
First allotment of COVID-19 vaccinations expected to arrive in Texas in mid-December

About 1.4 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccines have been allotted to the state of Texas and will arrive the week of Dec. 14.

The East Montgomery County Industrial Park off Gene Campbell Road will welcome the Lowe's Distribution Center in July. (Courtesy East Montgomery County Improvement District)
Lowe's to bring 200 jobs to Montgomery County and more Houston-area news

Read the latest Houston-area business and community news.

A new coronavirus testing site is coming to The Woodlands on Dec. 14. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Second free mobile coronavirus testing clinic coming to The Woodlands on Dec. 14

The free clinic from Curative will be available until Jan. 31, 2021.

The letter came a week after Longoria was virtually sworn into the office by Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo on Nov. 18. (Screenshot via Zoom)
Harris County scrambles to make creation of Elections Administrator Office lawful after Attorney General's letter identifies deficiencies

Harris County is working to make right the appointment of Isabel Longoria as the county's first-ever elections administrator after County Attorney Vince Ryan received a letter Nov. 25 from Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton stating that the county did not follow the proper appointment process.

Gwen Sims first joined Harris County Public Health in 1997. (Courtesy Harris County Public Health)
Deputy Director Gwen Sims appointed interim executive director of Harris County Public Health

Harris County Commissioners Court unanimously appointed Gwen Sims to serve as the interim executive director of Harris County Public Health in anticipation of Executive Director Umair Shah's departure Dec. 18.

Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Hewlett Packard Enterprise to relocate headquarters from Silicon Valley to Springwoods Village

Hewlett Packard Enterprise announced Dec. 1 plans to relocate its headquarters from San Jose, California to a brand new campus in the Greater Houston area, which is under construction in CityPlace at Springwoods Village.

CCEMS provides emergency medical services for approximately 177 square miles of North Harris County. (Courtesy Cypress Creek EMS)
Judge rules Harris County Emergency Services District No. 11 can no longer withhold payments from Cypress Creek EMS

The ESD No. 11 board voted to terminate its contract with CCEMS on Sept. 3 after a long history of disagreements over the two entities’ 16-year relationship.

Houston Methodist The Woodlands Hospital is undergoing an expansion. (Andrew Christman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Work on $250M Houston Methodist The Woodlands Hospital expansion continues, completion expected in 2022

The new patient tower at Houston Methodist The Woodlands Hospital will include for 100 more beds.

To support this initiative, community members are encouraged to visit NAM's Blessing Tree, located at 15555 Kuykendahl Road, Houston, where they can choose a child's name and shop specifically for that child. (Courtesy Northwest Assistance Ministries)
Northwest Assistance Ministries in need of donations to support biggest Season of Blessings campaign in nonprofit's history

Northwest Assistance Ministries is in need of toys, food and monetary donations to provide meals to more than 1,700 families and toys to more than 5,300 children this holiday season. By comparison, the nonprofit provided meals for 994 families and toys for 1,773 children in 2019.

The Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board has launched a campaign to address declining college enrollment numbers across the state since the pandemic started. (Courtesy Pexels)
Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board launches campaign to boost college enrollment

The decline in college enrollment across the state of Texas has prompted several agencies to partner up and create online resources for students and counselors.

(Courtesy Press Waffle Co.)
Press Waffle Co. set to open in The Woodlands on Dec. 4

The restaurant features sweet and savory waffles, gourmet milkshakes, and coffee and espresso drinks.