Sugar Land officials react to Texas Legislature's red-light camera ban

Image description
Texas Legislature stops red-light cameras with HB 1631
Image description
Texas Legislature stops red-light cameras with HB 1631
Image description
Texas Legislature stops red-light cameras with HB 1631

By now, drivers in Sugar Land may have noticed red-light cameras and signage have been removed from six busy intersections within the city.

With the passage of House Bill 1631 during Texas’ 86th regular legislative session, red-light cameras were banned in the state June 1, and all red-light cameras in Sugar Land were turned off June 2.

“We used these cameras as a tool to help us out,” Sugar Land Police Chief Eric Robins said. “When we had the cameras, we were hoping to get a lot more compliance and people not running those red lights and not having those accidents.”

Robins said he anticipates needing more staff over the next couple of years to make up for the loss of the cameras.

In 2008, Sugar Land received about $280,000 in revenue through the red-light camera program. In 2018, the city received $966,617 from the program, and by June 30 of this year, the city had received a little over $590,000, according to city data.

“That was set aside to pay for other traffic safety programs,” Robins said.

Money matters

Before HB 1631 was passed, when a driver ran a traffic signal equipped with a red-light camera, the vehicle owner whose name was associated with the car’s license plate number would have been mailed a notice of a $75 fine. Of this $75, $37.50 went to the state of Texas into the trauma fund for hospitals, Sugar Land Mayor Joe Zimmerman said during a June 18 City Council meeting.

“[The state] now has to make up that shortfall in revenue,” Zimmerman said.

The city retained the remaining $37.50. Throughout the 11-year duration of the program, the city received a total of $6.1 million. Each year, the net share of revenue produced by red-light cameras accounted for about 1% of the city’s general fund operating budget, Robins said.

“I’ve received a lot of emails about some people accusing us of using this as a revenue source, which is laughable,” Zimmerman said.

State Rep. Ron Reynolds, D-Missouri City, who co-authored HB 1631, said he supports the ban because it would prevent cities from being incentivized to issue tickets to increase revenues. Reynolds added it was difficult to enforce ticket payment.

“Studies also showed that red-light cameras do not necessarily end the practice of running red lights, as individuals still run them and then never pay the ticket,” he said. “Since there is not a strong payment enforcement system, the cameras do not have the desired deterrent effect.”

Roughly 23% of violations issued in Sugar Land throughout the program’s duration remained unpaid as of June 1. Under HB 1631, outstanding violation fees are no longer being collected, Robins said. In fact, any payments that were in the pipeline but had not been processed will be returned, Robins said.

In response to getting rid of the red-light cameras, Robins requested funds for one additional traffic officer be added to the fiscal year 2019-20 budget that council will adopt in September.

There are about four hours of rush-hour traffic each day—two hours in the morning and two hours in the evening—during which increased patrolling would be needed, Robins said.

“Those are the critical times that I’m in need of some support,” he said. “That equates to about three officers, when you add up the amount of time. It’s either that or trying to have our officers work extra overtime, and that can become a little bit of a burden.”

Robins said he will monitor the effect of having one additional officer in FY 2019-20 and look at accident data to determine if more officers will be needed.

“It’s always been about safety,” he said. “The way the funds went, the city and the police department basically used the funds that we got from the system to pay for the system itself.”

Creating a safety net

City Manager Allen Bogard said he feels legislative actions such as this one are making cities less safe.

“This is not the first action that has been taken,” Bogard said. “Two or three years ago, City Council adopted [an ordinance] where individuals were going to be ticketed if they had a phone in their hands while driving. The ordinance that our city passed had to be removed because of the Texas Legislature. Here, we have another one.”

In 2017, the Legislature did pass a measure banning texting while driving.

Implementing the red-light cameras in Sugar Land in 2007 resulted in a 58% decrease in accidents between 2009-12, Robins said. In 2018, however, three spots monitored by cameras, including Hwy. 6 N at Hwy. 59 N, Hwy. 6 S at Hwy. 59 and Hwy. 90A West at Dairy Ashford Road, were among the top collision areas in the city with 29, 20 and 16 accidents, respectively.

Additionally, about 70% of violators did not live in Sugar Land, and nearly 90% of violators did not receive a second ticket, Robins said.

Sugar Land resident Atia Ibrahim said she received a violation notice from a red-light camera once, and she found the process to be easier and more understandable than being stopped by an officer on the road.

“It allowed me to see the picture,” Ibrahim said. “It’s actually a video showing me that I slowed down yet I didn’t stop. But when the police officer pulls you over, you just take their word for it.”

Ibrahim also said she felt safer knowing the cameras were there to review footage for red-light runs or accidents.

“I know the cameras were there for our safety. It’s not intrusion,” she said. “I don’t see cameras any different than having a police officer sitting there pointing a speeding gun at you to see how fast you’re going.”

However, in a Community Impact Newspaper poll on Nextdoor, 64% of 497 responders in the Sugar Land and Missouri City area voted in support of the ban.

“HB 1631 ends a harmful practice by prohibiting the use of red-light cameras, which deprive citizens of their due process rights,” Reynolds said in an email. “An individual is forced to face a camera, rather than an officer who was present at the scene, as their accuser and is presumed guilty until proven innocent.”

Reynolds also said he feels the loss of the cameras makes communities in Texas safer as studies have shown rear-end crashes increase with the red-light camera system.

“Rather than following the normal flow of traffic, drivers brake too quickly upon entering the intersection to avoid getting ticketed, leading to crashes,” he said.

However, in Sugar Land, an analysis of the red-light camera programs showed rear-end crash counts stayed low with an average of 12 per year between 2012-17.

Although the red-light cameras have been banned, and Sugar Land has complied, Robins said the city will continue to look at other ways technology could help the police department.

“We’re constantly looking at what’s out there and what can give us an edge to help keep our city safe,” he said.

Bogard said he hopes in future legislative sessions the city will be able to discuss these issues further.

“I hope that as time goes on, there’s going to be an opportunity for us to have more dialogue with the leadership in Austin and get them back on the team for helping local communities build safe communities because it’s not happening anymore,” Bogard said.

By Beth Marshall
Born and raised in Montgomery County, Beth Marshall graduated from The University of Texas at San Antonio in 2015 with a bachelor's degree in communication and a minor in business. Originally hired as a reporter for The Woodlands edition in 2016, she became editor of the Sugar Land/Missouri City edition in October 2017.


On April 2, New Strength Pilates moved to a larger location on Riverstone Boulevard in Missouri City. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
New Strength Pilates relocates to larger Missouri City studio

The Missouri City business of 16 years offers private sessions and group classes that help clients become pain free.

See how some Greater Houston area school districts are planning to go back to school for the 2021-22 academic year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
See how some Greater Houston area school districts are planning to go back to school for the 2021-22 academic year

While some school districts in the Greater Houston area are doing away with face mask requirements and virtual schooling completely, others are pivoting to continue offering online learning options for students and plan to require face masks.

CDC ends all mask requirements for fully vaccinated people

The guidance states fully vaccinated people do not need to wear masks indoors or outdoors.

Hwy. 36A has not been approved as a project, so the route of the road has not been decided. However, this map shows the study area for the road. (Courtesy Highway 36A Coalition)
TxDOT, advocacy group look at feasibility of Hwy. 36A corridor through Brazoria, Fort Bend, Waller counties

The Highway 36A Coalition is hoping to get the road placed on HGAC's 2045 Regional Transportation Plan.

House Bill 1024, signed into law May 12, allows restaurants and bars to permanently sell alcoholic beverages to-go. (Courtesy Pexels)
Cocktails to-go are here to stay in Texas: Gov. Greg Abbott signs change into law May 12

Supporters say the change will help restaurants continue to recover from the economic effects of the coronavirus pandemic.

Applications will open May 17 for small businesses seeking monetary relief through Fort Bend County's small business emergency grant program because of the COVID-19 pandemic. (Photo courtesy Pexels)
New funding available soon for small businesses hit by COVID-19 in Fort Bend County

Small businesses in Fort Bend County that have been impacted by the coronavirus pandemic can soon apply for up to $25,000 in relief due to new funding made available by the county.

3323 Oaklawn Place Drive, a 1,804-square-foot house in Olympia Estates, sold for between $185,001-$215,000 on Jan. 30. (Courtesy Houston Association of Realtors)
Median price of homes sold increased across Sugar Land, Missouri City year over year in March

Find recent real estate trends, plus information on the Missouri City neighborhood Olympia Estates here.

Dry Eye & Specialty Center opened April 22 in Sugar Land. (Courtesy Pexels)
Dry Eye & Specialty Center opens on University Boulevard in Sugar Land

The practice offers optometry services such as routine exams as well as treatment for eye diseases and other causes of dry and itchy eyes.

The U.S. Food & Drug Administration on May 10 expanded Pfizer's emergency use authorization to include adolescents ages 12-15. (Courtesy Pexels)
Fort Bend County residents ages 10-20 make up majority of recent COVID-19 cases

The majority of recent COVID-19 cases in Fort Bend County have been infections among residents between the ages of 10 and 20, according to county officials.

Residents will have until May 2023 to obtain a Real ID. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
US Department of Homeland Security extends Real ID deadline until 2023

Drivers will have until May 2023 to get the Real ID, which will be required for adults boarding a U.S. commercial flight.

Property owners who believe an error was made in determining their property's value can use the protest process to reduce their tax burden. (Courtesy Pexels)
Deadline for residents, business owners to protest Fort Bend County property values is May 17

Property owners who believe an error was made in determining their property's value can use the protest process to reduce their tax burden.

During the 2021-22 school year, Fort Bend ISD plans to require individuals to wear masks when moving about indoors in large crowds and when unable to separate from others by at least 3 feet. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Fort Bend ISD will continue to require masks in 2021-22 school year

Students and staff at Fort Bend ISD will be required to wear masks when moving about indoors in crowded spaces and when unable to socially distance from others during the 2021-22 school year, district officials announced May 10.