Federal judge denies motion ordering release of up to 4,000 Harris County Jail inmates

As the number of positive coronavirus cases among both Harris County Jail inmates and employees continues to climb, Federal Judge Lee Rosenthal rejected a petition for the emergency release of up to 4,000 inmates. (Courtesy Brian Jackson/Adobe Stock)
As the number of positive coronavirus cases among both Harris County Jail inmates and employees continues to climb, Federal Judge Lee Rosenthal rejected a petition for the emergency release of up to 4,000 inmates. (Courtesy Brian Jackson/Adobe Stock)

As the number of positive coronavirus cases among both Harris County Jail inmates and employees continues to climb, Federal Judge Lee Rosenthal rejected a petition for the emergency release of up to 4,000 inmates. (Courtesy Brian Jackson/Adobe Stock)

As the number of positive coronavirus cases among both Harris County Jail inmates and employees continues to climb, U.S. District Judge Lee Rosenthal rejected a petition April 14 for the emergency release of up to 4,000 inmates.

The motion—filed by plaintiffs in Russell v. Harris County, a lawsuit regarding felony bail practices—asked for a 14-day emergency order from Rosenthal in light of the coronavirus that would require Harris County not to enforce pretrial detention orders for felony detainees who were being detained because they could not afford bail.

In her ruling, Rosenthal wrote it would be risky for a federal district court to "wade into policy and political disagreements among state and county elected officials." She also argued the plaintiffs failed to prove the emergency release would be in the public interest.

"Granting temporary relief and allowing the alleged lengthy detention both present risks," she wrote. "There is the threat of releasing on a personal bond those who should not be released because of risks such as not only failure to appear, but also of new offenses. On the other hand, there is the risk that if they are detained in tight jail conditions, they may have a greater likelihood of being infected or infecting others, as well as the risks of the collateral consequences of prolonged wealth-based detention and constitutional violations. The court cannot find that the present record, sparse and fast-changing as it is, meets the plaintiffs’ burden to show that it is in the public interest to grant the relief sought, or that denying it will disserve the public interest."

Harris County officials have advocated for their own version of what they have called "compassionate release" of jail inmates, though their efforts dealt exclusively with certain pretrial inmates who did not have any history of violent crime. As previously reported by Community Impact Newspaper, Hidalgo authorized a review process for the release of inmates March 31, but the order was voided by administrative Judge Herb Ritchie on April 3, shortly after the first few inmates were released.


The subject was further discussed by Harris County Commissioners Court during a meeting April 7.

In her ruling, Rosenthal acknowledged efforts that have taken place since then to release inmates in compliance with both Hidalgo's and Ritchie's orders. Since April 13, the county has temporarily released 372 inmates using a review process that includes the sheriff, the Harris County Justice Administration Department, the district attorney's office, the public defender's office and state district judges.

"The court does not want to disrupt the laudable existing efforts to address the crisis," Rosenthal wrote. "Disrupting a process that strives to recognize the different interests and concerns is an added risk of intruding with a temporary restraining order that is backed by the threat of contempt."

State Sen. Paul Bettencourt, R-Houston, filed an amicus brief objecting to the release of Harris County inmates April 8 along with a number of other Houston area representatives. In an April 15 press release, Bettencourt lauded the decision.

"Ordering mass inmate release has been tried three times now," Bettencourt said. "First, Judge Hidalgo’s overreaching order was stopped. Next, Sheriff Gonzalez and sixteen Harris County misdemeanor judges sued in Travis County but were blocked by the Texas Supreme Court, and now a Federal Court has said no again on an existing federal suit. This is a victory for the citizens."

Although Rosenthal denied the motion for a restraining order, she left it open for plaintiffs to return with new information in the future, including on delays for bail hearings and on the number of arrestees and workers who test positive for COVID-19.

"The court has not addressed, much less foreclosed, the substantive issues on the merits," she wrote. "The court is not foreclosing any party or interested nonparty from raising additional issues or substantially different facts that this pandemic continues to produce."

As of April 15, the Harris County Sheriff's Office reported 85 jail employees and 68 inmates had tested positive for the coronavirus.

Hannah Zedaker - Shawn Arrajj



MOST RECENT

To support this initiative, community members are encouraged to visit NAM's Blessing Tree, located at 15555 Kuykendahl Road, Houston, where they can choose a child's name and shop specifically for that child. (Courtesy Northwest Assistance Ministries)
Northwest Assistance Ministries in need of donations to support biggest Season of Blessings campaign in nonprofit's history

Northwest Assistance Ministries is in need of toys, food and monetary donations to provide meals to more than 1,700 families and toys to more than 5,300 children this holiday season. By comparison, the nonprofit provided meals for 994 families and toys for 1,773 children in 2019.

The Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board has launched a campaign to address declining college enrollment numbers across the state since the pandemic started. (Courtesy Pexels)
Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board launches campaign to boost college enrollment

The decline in college enrollment across the state of Texas has prompted several agencies to partner up and create online resources for students and counselors.

The 24-hour hospital boasts the latest in diagnostic and surgical expertise, including health care, women's health and orthopedics. (Courtesy CHI St. Luke's Health The Vintage Hospital)
CHI St. Luke's Health The Vintage Hospital to celebrate 10 years in Northwest Houston on Dec. 10

The 24-hour hospital boasts the latest in diagnostic and surgical expertise, including health care, women's health and orthopedics.

Nearly 750 cases of COVID-19 were confirmed in Cy-Fair ISD from Sept. 8-Nov. 29. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Cy-Fair ISD reports 170 COVID-19 cases among students, staff Nov. 16-29

Most of these cases came the week leading up to Thanksgiving break from Nov. 16-22—only 38 cases were confirmed over the weeklong break when campuses were closed Nov. 23-29, according to district data.

The ice skating complex has been in business since 1995. (Courtesy Aerodrome Ice Skating Complex)
Aerodrome Ice Skating Complex celebrates 25 years of business in Willowbrook this month

A pro-shop tent sale is planned Dec. 4-5, featuring discounted hockey gear and figure-skating merchandise.

Dozens of clinics throughout the county offer COVID-19 testing services. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
COVID-19 testing locations remain open in Montgomery County and more local news

Read the latest Houston-area business and community news.

Heading into Thanksgiving, Texas Medical Center continues to report uptick in hospitalizations

The total number of COVID-19 patients hospitalized at Texas Medical Center facilities has increased by more than 50% over two weeks.

The Harris County Justice Administration Department is working to release final reports and launch pilot programs in early 2021. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County Justice Administration Department makes headway on countywide criminal justice studies

The department is working to release the final versions of several studies and launch pilot programs with local law enforcement groups in early 2021.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced a COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan for the state Nov. 23 for a vaccine he said could be available as soon as December. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announces COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan

The vaccine could start being distributed "as early as next month," according to a Nov. 23 news release.

Harris County Precinct 4 and the Champions Municipal Utility District celebrated the completion of Champions Drive in a ribbon-cutting ceremony Nov. 19—just weeks before the 2020 U.S. Women's Open Golf Tournament is scheduled to take place in the area. (Courtesy Harris County Precinct 4)
Harris County Precinct 4, Champions MUD celebrate completion of Champions Drive ahead of 2020 U.S. Women's Open Golf Tournament

In anticipation of increased traffic on the roadway for the 75th annual event, Harris County Precinct 4 and the Champions Municipal Utility District began construction in September 2018 on a $13.3 million joint project to upgrade Champions Drive from a two-lane asphalt road to a two-lane concrete paved section with improved drainage between FM 1960 and Cypress Creek.