Spring ISD joins lawsuit against Gov. Greg Abbott over executive order prohibiting mask mandates

Spring ISD is among several school districts throughout the state that is requiring all students, staff, teachers and visitors to wear masks while in district buildings in the 2021-22 school year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Spring ISD is among several school districts throughout the state that is requiring all students, staff, teachers and visitors to wear masks while in district buildings in the 2021-22 school year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Spring ISD is among several school districts throughout the state that is requiring all students, staff, teachers and visitors to wear masks while in district buildings in the 2021-22 school year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Editor's note: This article has been updated to include comments from Spring ISD Superintendent Rodney Watson and SISD Board President Rhonda Newhouse.

The Spring ISD board of trustees voted to join La Joya ISD's lawsuit against Gov. Greg Abbott over his executive order barring school districts from mandating face masks at a special-called Aug. 23 board meeting.

The board unanimously approved the decision after meeting in executive session but did not comment on the matter after voting.

SISD Superintendent Rodney Watson touched on the lawsuit after the meeting.

“The decision of our board of trustees to join the lawsuit against Gov. Abbott’s ban on mask mandates demonstrates a continued commitment to the health and safety of our students and staff,” Watson said in an Aug. 24 emailed statement. “Our goal is to do everything we can to mitigate the risk and spread of COVID-19 among our students and staff so we can keep our schools open and minimize the potential for disruptions to learning and teaching.”


SISD is the latest of several school districts throughout the state that have joined the lawsuit as intervenors—or third parties entering an existing civil case that were not named as an original party but have a stake in the outcome. In addition to LJISD, plaintiffs in the lawsuit include Edinburg CISD, Hidalgo ISD, Brownsville ISD, Crowley ISD and Edcouch-Elsa ISD.

"We don't believe that the governor's executive order can limit our rights as an independent school district from implementing safety measures," SISD Board President Rhonda Newhouse said in an Aug. 25 emailed statement. "We also believe the local school boards have the right and the responsibility to make decisions based on what's best for our students, our employees and our community based on the public health conditions in our area. The highly contagious delta variant means we must use every strategy available, including universal masking, to protect our students and staff."


Initially filed Aug. 12, LJISD’s lawsuit argues Abbott does not have the authority to stop school districts from implementing mask mandates.

“The Texas Disaster Act does not delegate any authority to the governor that would allow him to issue such a prohibition,” the lawsuit reads. “Plaintiffs respectfully request the court declare that the governor’s declaration in Executive Order GA-38 that school districts cannot adopt masking requirements is ultra vires and invalid because the Texas Disaster Act conveys no such power to the governor.”

The lawsuit highlights the rising number of COVID-19-related hospitalizations in Texas, which had surpassed 13,300 as of Aug. 22, according to data provided by the Texas Department of State Health Services.

“This data is particularly troubling for school districts because Texas schoolchildren under the age of 12 cannot currently be vaccinated,” the lawsuit reads. “Based on data from the Texas Department of State Health Services, 99.5% of the COVID-19 deaths since February 2021 have been people who were unvaccinated.”

Further, the lawsuit contends because less than 50% of the Texas population is fully vaccinated, providing in-person classroom instruction without appropriate safety measures threatens the broader public.

SISD began requiring masks on all district properties Aug. 16. According to Abbott’s executive order, entities that establish such mandates are subject to a fine of up to $1,000, though the order does not specify how the penalty would be applied to school districts.


MOST RECENT

At a Sept. 11 practice, Houston Girls Hockey Association teams took the ice to prepare for their first games the weekend of Sept. 17. (Courtesy Houston Girls Hockey Association)
New Houston-area all-girls hockey league set to play first games this weekend, Sept. 17-19

The league was created to give school-aged girls a chance to continue playing hockey through college, since young girls can often feel discouraged playing on co-ed teams, Director of Membership Valory Zeck said.

Houston restaurant Lasagna House will be celebrating its 79th anniversary on Sept. 27 with a community event. (Courtesy Matt Vernon)
Eat lasagna, learn to line dance: 12 things to do in Spring and Klein throughout September, October

Here are a few events and things to do in the Spring and Klein area throughout the months of September and October.

graphic
DATA: How population changed in Texas counties between census counts in 2010, 2020

Texas added nearly four million people between 2010 and 2020, according to the latest Census data.

Texas-wide public charter school system Harmony Public Schools will offer a full virtual learning option for eligible students. (Courtesy Harmony Public Schools)
Harmony Public Schools will offer virtual learning for K-12 students in Houston, Katy, Sugar Land, Cypress

Schools under the Harmony Public Schools umbrella may offer up to 10% of its student body a full virtual learning option.

The Texas Department of Transportation is planning to install medians along 5.8 miles of FM 1092 from Hwy. 59 to Hwy. 6 in Missouri City. (Courtesy Fotolia)
As FM 1092 median project goes out to bid, some Missouri City Council Members still object

Construction on the project to install medians on FM 1092—also known as Murphy Road—is expected to begin in the winter and last for seven months, according to officials with TxDOT.

At the Sept. 14 Harris County Commissioners Court meeting, County Administrator David Berry, top left, presents proposed tax rates to commissioners Jack Cagle and Tom Ramsey, Judge Lina Hidalgo, and commissioners Adrian Garcia and Rodney Ellis. (Emily Lincke/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County commissioners propose lower tax rates with split vote

While the proposed tax rate is lower than the current rate, tax payers may actually end up paying more since the values of homes statewide increased this year, according to County Administrator David Berry.

Montgomery County Judge Mark Keough tours the COVID-19 antibody infusion center that opened Aug. 16.
(Courtesy Montgomery County Judge Mark Keough on Facebook)
Federal policy change reduces COVID-19 antibody treatment drugs coming to Montgomery County infusion center

A change in how the federal government distributes the monoclonal antibody treatment means a change for regional antibody centers administering treatments.

About 62% of Harris County residents ages 12 and older have been fully vaccinated against COVID-19. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Harris County commissioners terminate $11 million Elevate Strategies vaccine outreach contract

“There’s absolutely nothing done here that was in any way deviating from the most adequate protocols, and what is sad … [is] that the COVID response is being politicized." -Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo

Dutch Bros Coffee serves hot, iced and blended coffee along with teas, lemonade and smoothies. (Courtesy Dutch Bros Coffee)
Dutch Bros Coffee now open on FM 2920 in Spring

Dutch Bros Coffee celebrated the grand opening of its second Spring-area coffee shop at 5258 FM 2920 on Sept. 17.

Based on a home value of $200,000, the proposed tax rate would result in property tax rate savings of about $75. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Klein ISD officials propose lowest property tax rate in 11 years for FY 2021-22

The Klein ISD board of trustees will hold a public hearing on the proposed tax rate Oct. 12 at 6 p.m.

Shelters around Houston opened to help those affected by Hurricane Nicholas on Sept. 14. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Shelters open to aid those affected by Hurricane Nicholas

Shelters have been opened by the American Red Cross to help those in need following the storm.