Harris County’s new no-cash bail policy stirs controversy 

Image description
Harris County’s new no-cash bail policy stirs controversy 
Image description
Harris County’s new no-cash bail policy stirs controversy 
Image description
Harris County’s new no-cash bail policy stirs controversy 
Harris County officials are grappling with safety and security questions in the wake of a landmark settlement that could make a county bail reform law permanent.

On July 30, county commissioners approved a settlement to address issues with the county’s bail bond practices. The settlement would continue policy reforms that went into effect in February that require the county to not hold misdemeanor defendants in jail if they cannot afford bail. It would also implement other initiatives to increase court appearances.

“[The settlement] ensures that we are spending our resources on real public safety rather than filling our jail with people who are only there because they’re poor,” County Judge Lina Hidalgo said.

While supporters hail the settlement as a watershed moment, local officials and groups, including Harris County District Attorney Kim Ogg and Precinct 4 Commissioner Jack Cagle, said they oppose it, citing public safety concerns, violations of state law and financial burden on taxpayers.

“It’s not very fair to victims,” Cagle said. “[There is nothing in the settlement] to address the civil rights of victims.”

Although the settlement applies only to misdemeanors, the total number of misdemeanor and felony defendants released on personal bond in Harris County jumped 470% from 2015-18 and is continuing to grow this year, according to a report by Harris County Pretrial Services. The increase follows a federal ruling in 2017 that declared the county's bail system unconstitutional.

Settlement history, objections


Three individuals charged with misdemeanors filed a lawsuit against Harris County in 2016, alleging it unfairly jailed poor misdemeanor defendants. In 2017, Judge Lee Rosenthal, chief district judge of the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of Texas, declared the county’s bail system unconstitutional. Although the county initially fought the lawsuit, commissioners eventually began working towards a settlement. In February, Harris County changed its bail practices to grant personal bonds for most misdemeanors, known as Local Rule 9.

The rule requires pretrial release of all misdemeanor arrestees—such as driving with a suspended license— excluding instances such as domestic violence or assault.

The county approved a settlement on July 30 for the original lawsuit, which mandates continued implementation of Local Rule 9 as well as requires the county to create initiatives to improve court appearance rates. It is pending final approval Sept. 19.

“All [of the defendants] are in agreement that this is the best solution,” Hidalgo said. “Everybody somehow [came] together and reached an agreement with the plaintiffs.”

However, as of Aug. 23, nine different officials and groups, including the Harris County Domestic Violence Coordinating Council and The Harris County Bondsmen Association, have written letters of opposition urging Rosenthal to deny the settlement.

Ogg and Cagle said Local Rule 9 already addresses the plaintiff’s concerns in the original lawsuit. They said the settlement—which could require the county to help defendants with child care and transportation to court, with a potential price tag of $97 million—is unnecessary.

“The district attorney has no objection to a settlement approved by this court requiring and monitoring the continued enforcement of that rule,” Ogg wrote in her amicus brief, or written concern sent to court, filed Aug. 22. “The proposed settlement seeks relief far beyond the scope of the original controversy, however.”

Cedric Claiborne, a bondsman at Greenspoint Bail Bond, said the bail bond industry has taken a hit from the recent reform, and he believes bondspersons can do a better job than the county in ensuring defendants show up for court.

“It’s ridiculous for them to say a bondsman is just out to get money,” Claiborne said. “We’ll send text messages; we’ll call a week before court to remind [clients] of court; [we’ll] have them come in every Wednesday to … sign in.”

In 2018, about 22% of misdemeanor defendants supervised by Harris County Pretrial Services had their bond revoked due to failing to appear for court, according to the annual report. By contrast, about 7% of Greenspoint Bail Bond clients fail to show up to court, Claiborne said.

Equality for the poor


Supporters of the settlement said it levels the playing field for poor defendants who do not have transportation to court or cannot afford child care. Meanwhile, the overall bail reform helps solve systemic inequalities, said Don Elder, a former Houston Police Department sergeant and current Spring resident.

Prior to reform, poor defendants would sometimes plead guilty to be released earlier—and face a criminal record—rather than await trial in jail and risk losing a job or home, he said.

“This area has so many people barely making it. … Being accused of a crime could mean the loss of a job, an apartment or home,” Elder said.

In ZIP code 77090, which includes a portion of FM 1960, 21.4% of the population fell below the federal poverty line in 2017, according to U.S. Census Bureau data.

Poverty is the reason many people commit crime, said Allen Rice, executive director of Spirit Key, an organization in the Willowbrook area that helps former male convicts and homeless individuals find jobs.

“[Bail reform is] going to be a quick fix to allow them to get out, but the larger problem is poverty,” he said. “Where are these people going to go? … They’re going to be [released]. … But how are we going to help them to get financially independent?”

On a countywide level, bail reform could alleviate overcrowding at the Harris County Jail, which houses more than 8,000 inmates on any given day, said Darryl Coleman, chief of Harris County’s criminal justice command.

According to data from the Texas Commission on Jail Standards, the average monthly number of people held in the Harris County Jail pretrial for misdemeanors dropped by about 40% from 2016-19, during the time reform initiatives were implemented.

Criminals out on bond


Mark Herman, the county’s constable for Precinct 4, which covers parts of Spring and Klein, said he has seen an increased demand on law enforcement over the past few years.

“It’s a higher demand for us out here,” Herman said. “We're having more and more suspected criminals out on our streets of Harris County.”

At a Houston Northwest Chamber of Commerce meeting on Aug. 9, law-enforcement officials voiced concern over the bail reform, saying they often rearrest defendants out on bond. Susana Salazar, a Houston Police Department sergeant who services the Greenspoint and Willowbrook areas, recounted an incident in which a woman called police on a man for drug possession.

“Within an hour, they went and got him—he had crack cocaine on him. They dropped him off; they did the reports,” Salazar said. “[The woman] texts me a picture of him at 6 p.m. that afternoon. He was back on that corner.”

In the amicus brief filed by the Harris County Deputies’ Organization Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 39, the organization said although Local Rule 9 states automatic personal bonds will not be granted for violent offenders, this is not always followed in practice.

“Under the bail rules, a person can commit capital murder and receive a personal bond at the discretion of the judge hearing the case,” the organization’s attorneys wrote.

Meanwhile, the number of felony defendants granted bond has trended upward in recent years, according to the Harris County Pretrial Services 2018 report. From July 2016 to July 2019, the average monthly number of felony defendants released on bond under county supervision increased from 508 to 4,297. Robin McIlhenny, an attorney for the Harris County Deputies’ FOP 39, said the increase in total defendants on bond is attributable to the political turnover in judges after the 2016 and 2018 elections.

But supporters of the settlement said there is no evidence that a cash bail system improves public safety. At the July 30 Commissioners Court meeting, Precinct 1 Commissioner Rodney Ellis cited a University of Pennsylvania study, which analyzed 380,689 misdemeanor cases filed in Harris County and found detaining individuals pretrial could make them more likely to commit crimes later on.

Ellis said the public safety was a key component of the settlement.

"When a consent decree or lawsuit is decided, public safety is at the heart," he said. "Fairness is a part of it, but public safety is always a big part."

Shawn Arrajj and Vanessa Holt contributed to this report.
By


MOST RECENT

Dozens of clinics throughout the county offer COVID-19 testing services. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
COVID-19 testing locations remain open in Montgomery County and more local news

Read the latest Houston-area business and community news.

Heading into Thanksgiving, Texas Medical Center continues to report uptick in hospitalizations

The total number of COVID-19 patients hospitalized at Texas Medical Center facilities has increased by more than 50% over two weeks.

The Harris County Justice Administration Department is working to release final reports and launch pilot programs in early 2021. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County Justice Administration Department makes headway on countywide criminal justice studies

The department is working to release the final versions of several studies and launch pilot programs with local law enforcement groups in early 2021.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced a COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan for the state Nov. 23 for a vaccine he said could be available as soon as December. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announces COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan

The vaccine could start being distributed "as early as next month," according to a Nov. 23 news release.

Harris County Precinct 4 and the Champions Municipal Utility District celebrated the completion of Champions Drive in a ribbon-cutting ceremony Nov. 19—just weeks before the 2020 U.S. Women's Open Golf Tournament is scheduled to take place in the area. (Courtesy Harris County Precinct 4)
Harris County Precinct 4, Champions MUD celebrate completion of Champions Drive ahead of 2020 U.S. Women's Open Golf Tournament

In anticipation of increased traffic on the roadway for the 75th annual event, Harris County Precinct 4 and the Champions Municipal Utility District began construction in September 2018 on a $13.3 million joint project to upgrade Champions Drive from a two-lane asphalt road to a two-lane concrete paved section with improved drainage between FM 1960 and Cypress Creek.

In addition to chicken, The Port of Peri Peri will also offer lamb chops, salads, burgers, pitas and wraps as well as small bites such as hummus and falafel. (Courtesy The Port of Peri Peri)
The Port of Peri Peri coming soon to The Vintage area

This will be the sixth Texas location for the eatery, which is known for its open-flame-grilled chicken basted with its signature sauces made from African bird's eye chilies mixed with fresh herbs and spices.

As coronavirus cases continue to rise among teachers and students, Spring, Klein and Cy-Fair ISDs have reported that an 32,783 more students are learning in person during the second grading period than were on campus at the start of the 2020-21 school year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
More than 32,700 students in Spring, Klein and Cy-Fair ISDs switch to on-campus learning for second grading period

Spring, Klein and Cy-Fair ISDs have reported that an 32,783 more students are learning in person during the second grading period than were on campus at the start of the school year.

Despite losing his position on the Klein ISD board of trustees by 26 votes in the Nov. 3 general election, incumbent Doug James has been appointed to fill a Position 2 vacancy after the winning challenger, Alvin Vaughn, declined his position as a trustee. (Courtesy Doug James)
Klein ISD appoints incumbent Doug James to fill vacant Position 2 after winning challenger declines candidacy

"I want to thank the Klein community for voting for me," Vaughn said in a statement. "Winning the election is more than I could have hoped for, but upon further investigation as to the time requirements of this position and in consultation with my family, I have decided to decline this position."

The ice cream parlor offers more than 50 flavors of ice cream; yogurt; sherbet; ice; and fat-free, no-sugar-added ice cream available by the quart, pint, scoop or cone. (Courtesy Handel's Homemade Ice Cream)
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream now open on Spring Cypress Road

The ice cream parlor offers more than 50 flavors of ice cream; yogurt; sherbet; ice; and fat-free, no-sugar-added ice cream available by the quart, pint, scoop or cone.

Laura Colangelo
Q&A: Laura Colangelo discusses challenges facing private schools during pandemic

Colangelo said private schools have adapted to remote learning and other obstacles in 2020 despite less revenue and a 9% decline in enrollment statewide.

Shake Shack opened its new standalone location at The Woodlands Mall in November. (Courtesy Christine Han)
Shake Shack opens in The Woodlands Mall and more Houston-area updates

Read the latest business and community news from the Greater Houston area.