Judge calls for more time, potential court-ordered mediation in Proposition B case

Marty Lancton, the president of the Houston Professional Firefighters Association, spoke following a court hearing regarding the constitutionality of Proposition B.

Marty Lancton, the president of the Houston Professional Firefighters Association, spoke following a court hearing regarding the constitutionality of Proposition B.

Update as of 5:09 p.m., April 18: Harris County Judge Tanya Garrison of District 157 sent a court order for parties representing the Houston Police Officers Union and the city of Houston to enter mediation with the Houston Professional Firefighters Association. Both parties have until noon April 22 to agree on a mediator, according to court documents.

The original story, which published 3:36 p.m. April 18, is below:

The city of Houston and the Houston Professional Firefighters Union will not receive any additional clarity about the constitutionality of Proposition B ahead of some key dates in the city’s budget-setting process, including a vote on 220 firefighter layoffs April 24.

Harris County Judge Tanya Garrison of District 157 heard oral arguments April 17 presented by legal representation from the HPFFA and The Houston Police Officers Union alongside the city of Houston, both of which filed a joint lawsuit against the HPFFA, questioning the legality of voter-approved Proposition B and its associated pay raises for all Houston firefighters.

“[A ruling] won't be any time soon,” Garrison said. “There are four or five Supreme Court cases that I am going to outline and digest. There are reams of documents y'all have provided to me, but I haven't had a chance to thoroughly go through.”

While representatives from the city and the HPFFA both said a ruling either way would provide clarity on how to move forward, they also expressed some willingness to return to the negotiating table, especially if given a deadline for a ruling from Garrison.

“I think it's easier to reach a conclusion when you're not dealing with these constitutional questions and what they represent, but what I would suggest is that if we had an outside window within which we would not expect to hear from the court, that would incentivize the parties to try to reach a conclusion prior to that point,” City Attorney Ron Lewis said.

Garrison said while she understands the time-sensitive nature of the ruling, she is looking into ways to issue court-ordered mediation between the HPFFA and city representatives in hopes that they can come to an agreement. The last time the HPFFA, Mayor Sylvester Turner and other city representatives entered mediation was in June 2017, and it did not result in a collective bargaining agreement.

“Whoever I rule in favor in, whether it's the city's arguments or the firefighter's arguments, it would be the equivalent of throwing bomb in the middle of the attempts to negotiate a resolution, which is what I know everybody wants,” Garrison said. “[A resolution is] what the firefighters union wants, it’s what the city wants, it’s what the voters want, it’s what these families deserve, but I will [issue a ruling]. It’s my job.”

Following the hearing, HPFFA President Marty Lancton said he is willing to return to negotiations with or without a court ruling in place.

“I can tell you we respect the judge taking the time to look at this,” Lancton said. “We are here to be available and look forward to whatever the judge has to say.”
By Emma Whalen

Emma is Community Impact Newspaper's Houston City Hall reporter. Previously, she covered health care and public education in Austin.


Early voting is underway in Harris County for the March 2020 primary elections. (Matt Dulin/Community Impact Newspaper)
Voter turnout starts strong in Harris County primary elections

The early voting period runs through Feb. 28.

Houston's first chief transportation officer will help the city coordinate its urban planning efforts with other agencies such as the Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County, the Houston-Galveston Area Council and the Texas Department of Transportation. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Shifting focus from car culture, Houston hires first chief transportation planner

Houston's first chief transportation officer will help the city shift its focus from car-centric urban planning.

Aqua S
Australian ice cream shop Aqua S announces Heights opening date

The ice cream shop, founded in Sydney, Australia, in 2015, serves over 100 flavors that rotate out bimonthly, with a variety of toppings and add-ons, such as cotton candy.

Pi Pizza
Pi Pizza closing in the Heights as Sambrooks focuses on other concepts

The restaurant group Sambrooks Management Co. acquired Pi Pizza in 2018.

Houston City Council
Grappling with equity, Houston City Council approves recommendation for widespread affordable housing proposals

“In an effort to maintain the flow of money from HUD, we have agreed that we are going to be objective and not political about our allocation of these developments,” City Attorney Ron Lewis said.

District 148 covers parts of the Heights, Northwest Houston and Northside. (Courtesy Harris County Clerk)
Primary election Q&A: Democratic candidates for Texas House District 148

Shortly after electing a representative to fill state Rep. Jessica Farrar's vacated seat, voters are returning to the ballot to chose from a slate of primary challengers aiming to compete for the seat in November.

The Burger Joint
Burger Joint opens long-awaited Heights location

The new location includes full bar service and an expanded 3,300 square-foot patio.

Learn about the candidates in the running for the Republican nomination for U.S. Representative for District 18. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
US Representative District 18 Republican primary: 6 contenders vying for nomination

Learn about the candidates in the Republican primary race for U.S. House District 18.

The Brazos Street bridge at Spur 527 was in the process of being rebuilt, but now city officials are rethinking that plan. (Courtesy Houston Public Works)
With Brazos Street bridge gone, officials consider a different approach

On hold since December, the reconstruction of the Brazos Street bridge on Spur 527 has presented an opportunity to Houston officials to rethink the area as a pedestrian-friendly green space.

Cheetos Cheese Pickles from Biggy's (Courtesy Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo)
Cheetos cheese pickles, mac and cheese eggrolls, deep-fried cheesecake: 93 food spots to try during the 2020 Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo

From tried and true to something new, the food options at this year's Rodeo include classic staples and crazy concoctions.

Montrose TIRZ
Montrose TIRZ moving forward with Livable Centers study, a roadmap for investments

In a matter of months, Montrose residents could start to see public meetings and other opportunities to provide input on the development of the community.

The Houston First Corp. operates city-owned convention and entertainment facilities. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Audit of Houston First Corp. finds faults in agency's procurement process, lack of transparency

Among the findings in the audit was a $400,000 contract awarded without going through a competitive bidding process.

Back to top