Friendswood to replace all water meters for $9M

Friendswood will replace water meters citywide. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Friendswood will replace water meters citywide. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Friendswood will replace water meters citywide. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Image description
Image description
Image description
Starting this fall, the city of Friendswood will begin a $9 million project officials hope will save the city millions of dollars in the long run.

The task is to replace each of the city’s more than 14,000 water meters, which are slowly becoming more inaccurate, with new ones capable of staying more accurate for longer. Officials said they expect the project will take about a year to complete.

“Unfortunately, for us to replace our entire 14,000-plus meters is a major upheaval,” Kabiri said.

Over time, Friendswood’s existing water meters, some of which are 25 years old, have begun malfunctioning, resulting in them not accurately counting how much water customers use. This has affected Friendswood’s bottom line, and replacing the water meters is one way to address the issue without raising water rates.

As a result, residents may notice higher water bills once the outdated meters are replaced.

“We’re losing $700,000 a year over 14,000 meters,” Mayor Mike Foreman said. “That’s $50 a meter we’re losing [annually].”

Correcting a problem

Friendswood leaders have known for years its water meters are inaccurate, but they found out just how much this summer.

The city hired Ameresco, a water conservation project company, to assess the city’s meters and eventually replace them. Ameresco’s sample showed the city’s residential water meters are 92.8% accurate on average, which means a resident who uses 10,000 gallons of water will be billed for only 9,280 gallons, on average.

“So basically, the customer is getting free water, and the city is still having to pay for all ... the water,” Ameresco Senior Account Executive Chad Nobles said.

While the meters are inaccurate, they are never inaccurate in the city’s favor.

“They don’t ever record more water passing through,” Foreman said. “They record less of the water, basically.”

Meanwhile, commercial water meters are even worse with an average accuracy of 89.4%, according to Ameresco.

“It could be a lot worse,” Nobles said.

Nobels has seen some cities with average commercial water meter accuracy as low as 30%, he said.

“Water meters fundamentally, especially ones that operate mechanically, have a fatal flaw in them,” Kabiri said, referring to the spinning part inside water meters that slowly corrodes over time, leading to inaccuracies. “They’re all presumed to be inaccurate to some degree.”

Friendswood gets its water from Houston water plants and thus pays Houston for the water Friendswood customers use. The goal is to collect as much water revenue from Friendswood customers as the city pays to Houston for the water, but in recent years, that has not been happening, according to city water data.

In fiscal year 2016-17, Friendswood collected $6.61 million in water revenue from users compared to the $6.79 million it paid Houston, which is a difference of about $180,000.

However, as more meters have degraded, the problem has gotten worse: In FY 2019-20, Friendswood collected $8.16 million and paid Houston $9.19 million, which is a difference of over $1 million, according to city data.

According to city officials, they can either fix the meters or raise water rates, but making sure everyone has an accurate meter is the most equitable way to solve the problem because those with accurate meters are paying more than those with inaccurate ones, Kabiri said.

“They’re subsidizing the folks that have older meters and are not registering correctly,” he said.

It will take the city an estimated eight or nine years to break even on the $9 million projct. Once all meters are installed, the city will save an estimated $1 million on average annually in revenue it otherwise would have lost due to inaccurate meters.

“These [new] meters are 99% accurate, and they maintain that accuracy for a 20-year period,” Kabiri said.

New-meter effects

Once the project begins this fall, Ameresco workers will go door to door to replace meters. Each replacement will take 10 to 30 minutes, but with 14,000 meters across the city, the project will not be complete until about November 2022, Nobles said.

Customers do not have the choice to keep their old meter, Kabiri said.

Once the new meters are in place, some customers might notice higher water bills. Today, there is about a $700,000 annual difference between how much the city collects in water revenue versus what it is costing the city. That means customers will spend $50 more on average annually for water, Foreman said.

This number could be higher or lower depending on how inaccurate a customer’s old meter was.

“Most people are not going to notice,” Foreman said.

However, the new water meters may allow residents to save money as well, officials said.

The new water meters will be able to provide residents real-time water use data, which will allow residents to check and monitor their water usage to target a specific amount, potentially lowering how much water they use and their bills, officials said.

Additionally, residents will be able to set up text alerts at different thresholds of water use. This will warn customers when they are using more water than they want or warn them of a potential leak if they notice water use while they are away from home, officials said.

Nobels said some residents in other Texas cities where smart meters have been installed expressed gratitude for the ability to track their water use, especially during the freezing weather in February. Residents were able to determine whether their pipes had burst by tracking their water use, Nobels said.

“There’s a lot of different uses for these ... smart meter systems,” he said. “These systems can be used in a lot of different ways.”

The new meters come with other cost-saving advantages. For instance, the city will not have to pay a company $150,000 annually to drive around to collect water meter data, Kabiri said; the city will be able to read that data remotely.

Cost breakdown

Debt the city issued in 2019 will pay for the $9 million project. No property tax dollars will be used, Kabiri said.

Additionally, Friendswood charges residents only what it costs to buy water from Houston, not more, he said.

“We’re not in a profit-making business,” Kabiri said. “It’s a zero-sum game.”

Still, officials believe the project is worth the cost, even if it takes nearly a decade for the city to save enough in water revenue it otherwise would have lost to make up the $9 million.

Friendswood City Council Member John Scott was the only council member to vote against the $9 million contract July 12. As a business owner, Scott said a project is not worth the price if it cannot pay for itself within two or three years.

“Quite simply, the return on investment is not there. I think the cost is too high. I think the payback is too long,” he said. “That’s a problem for me.”

Foreman said the city should be more concerned about the consequences of not replacing the meters rather than the city’s return on investment; the problem would get worse.

Scott said the city should continue doing what it has been: let the inaccurate meters remain and audit them more frequently.

“Unless you can present a solution that is cost effective, I’m not going to support it,” he said.
By Jake Magee

Editor, Bay Area & Pearland/Friendswood

Jake has been a print journalist for several years, covering numerous beats including city government, education, business and more. Starting off at a daily newspaper in southern Wisconsin, Magee covered two small cities before being promoted to covering city government in the heart of newspaper's coverage area. He moved to Houston in mid-2018 to be the editor for and launch the Bay Area edition of Community Impact Newspaper. Today, he covers everything from aerospace to transportation to flood mitigation.


Comcast will award $1 million to small businesses owned by people of color in Fort Bend and Harris counties (Courtesy Fotolia)
Comcast Rise Investment Fund to award small business grants in Harris, Fort Bend counties

Comcast will award $1 million to small businesses owned by people of color in Fort Bend and Harris counties.

Several parents of New Caney ISD students spoke at the district's Sept. 20 board meetings about recent allegations that a student brought a firearm to Porter High School's Sept. 18 homecoming dance. NCISD Superintendent Matt Calvert stressed that no gunshots were fired at the event, and that the district is investigating the allegations. (Wesley Gardner/Community Impact Newspaper)
CI Nation roundup: Round Rock ISD trustees considered for censuring; New Caney ISD addresses allegations of student with gun at campus event and more top stories

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Sept. 23.

Houston resident Marissa Hanson spoke on keeping tax rates low during the Harris County Commissioners Court public hearing on Sept. 21. (Emily Lincke/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County Commissioners propose tax cuts at cost of Harris Health System funding

On average, Harris County homeowners may see lower tax rates in the next year, but it will come at the cost of $17 million in funding for the county’s hospital district, according to Harris County Administrator David Berry.

Pearland ISD is taking applications for kindergarten to sixth grade students who are interested in a virtual schooling option. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Pearland ISD offering applications for virtual learning option for K-6 students

Pearland ISD is taking applications for kindergarten to sixth grade students who are interested in a virtual schooling option.

 Redistricting is one of the items on the Texas Legislature's third special session, and the state Senate released proposed maps on Sept. 18. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas Senate releases proposed redistricting maps as special session begins

Redistricting is one of the items on the third special session, and the state Senate released proposed maps on Sept. 18.

The H-GAC also helps guide transportation activities through the Transportation Policy Council, according to the council's website (Courtesy Fotolia)
Houston-Galveston Area Council celebrates 55th anniversary

The Houston-Galveston Area Council will be celebrating its 55th anniversary this October.

This is the first time Friendswood Junior High has been recognized for the award, and the second time for Friendswood High School. (Courtesy Friendswood Junior High band)
Friendswood Junior High, Friendswood High School bands recognized with national award

Friendswood Junior High and Friendswood High School were named national winners in the 2021 Foundation for Music Education’s Mark of Excellence competition, according to a news release.

Director of Community Development Aubrey Harbin presented these changes to the City Council on Sept. 13 after conducting public outreach throughout the month of June. (Screenshot courtesy Friendswood City Council video stream)
Public comments enact change in Friendswood's future land use map; city to continue receiving feedback

The city of Friendswood decided to make changes to the drafted 2021 future land use map based on public comments.

Betty's Salon moved to its new location at 801 S. Friendswood Drive, Ste. 108, Friendswood, in March. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Betty's Salon relocates to new location in Friendswood

Betty's Salon moved to its new location at 801 S. Friendswood Drive, Ste. 108, Friendswood, in March.

Frontier Waste Solutions on Oct. 1 will begin service as Pearland’s waste provider. (Courtesy city of Pearland)
Frontier Waste Solutions to take over as Pearland’s waste services provider in October

Frontier Waste Solutions on Oct. 1 will begin service as Pearland’s waste provider.

Texas Medical Center coronavirus updates: Daily average hospitalizations drop 15% week over week; ICU sees dip in number of patients

Coronavirus patients at TMC hospitals number 2,107, which in itself is an 11% week over week decline.

Anyone 12 years old and older is eligible to receive the COVID-19 vaccine, but must have a parent or guardians permission if they are under 18. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Friendswood ISD to host vaccination event at local campuses

Friendswood ISD will host a COVID-19 vaccination event in partnership with the University of Texas Medical Branch on Sept. 22.