Brio site leaves residents with lingering questions

Image description
Brio site leaves residents with lingering questions
Image description
Brio site leaves residents with lingering questions
Image description
Brio site leaves residents with lingering questions
The Brio Superfund Site, located near Friendswood, has passed the federal Environmental Protection Agency’s five-year review. However, the site is far from livable, EPA officials said.

Today, the site is unrecognizable.

“If you drove around there, it is like a ghost town now,” Friendswood resident Cheryl Johnson said.

For 30 years, the Brio site was used for chemical reprocessing until it was shut down in 1982 and declared a superfund site, which means the government has stepped in due to what it believes are major environmental problems. Those who lived in the Southbend subdivision nearby developed chronic illnesses and birth defects. A school closed, as did the subdivision.

The EPA has since monitored the site to ensure dangerous chemicals leave the site in a safe way.

“For the last 25 years, it has been extremely safe. Does that mean I am totally comfortable in saying it’s safe forever? No way,” said Marie Flickinger, the EPA community liaison for Brio.

Brio History
The Brio site was owned by Brio Refining Inc. in its later years and was used for a chemical refurbishing facility from the 1950s to 1982. The dangers of dumping chemical waste were not fully known at the time, Flickinger said.

“People didn’t realize the problems toxic waste could cause,” Flickinger said.

Flickinger’s interest began an incinerator was going to be built on the site in the 80s. The EPA had intervened at that point, and the solution was to build an incinerator on the site to destroy the chemicals, Flickinger said. However, the incinerator was only going to destroy 99.9% of the chemicals at the site, which was not good enough for Flickinger, she said.

“The burn was supposed to burn off 99.99% of the chemicals, but that was not enough to burn off dioxin,” Flickinger said. “The thing is, they had never tested for dioxin.”

Dioxins are highly toxic compounds of chemicals and is typically a byproduct of industrial waste or pollution. With the other chemicals found on the site, dioxins were inevitable, Flickinger said. The completed incinerator was never used, but much of the damage on the site was already done.

Because the site did not have a cover, the air was full of contaminants, and the neighborhoods nearby suffered.

The Southbend subdivision next to the site was bought out, and Weber Elementary School, located on the site, was shut down in 1992.

Johnson was on the Clear Creek ISD school board when the school had to be shut down. She still has concerns about whether the site is safe.

“There is still enough lingering questions that it is fair to say, ‘Let’s check it out,’” Johnson said.

The site has been monitored by the EPA since 1993. It was taken off the EPA’s national priorities list in 2006. Around the site are San Jacinto Community College, the South Belt Stormwater Detention Basin and a subdivision. While the subdivision is near the site, it is not located in the same place as the former Southbend.

A recent report
The EPA released its five-year report in September. According to the report, everything is going according to plan but still needs careful monitoring.

“It’s serious, and it’s an issue, but it is not currently a problem,” Flickinger said.

The five-year study shows the short-term solution is working well, said Bill Rhotenberry, remedial project manager in the EPA’s superfund program. The short-term solution involved layers of dirt and clay over the contaminated area, with underground wells pumping out gases safely. There are also thick metal walls around the area and a tarp on top to prevent chemicals from spilling out of the area or into the air.

The only concern from the five-year report showed a migration of chemicals from the shallow pool of contaminated water in the sand layer of the site down to a deeper sand layer in the site. This is being investigated, as a layer of clay should have prevented this, Rhotenberry said.

“The majority of the contamination is in the shallow groundwater level and is being monitored,” Rhotenberry said. “We detected some contamination that has migrated vertically from a shallow groundwater zone into a deeper zone.”

In addition to the normal monitoring of the equipment—which occurs on the site daily—those on the site are now tasked with finding a solution for the chemical migration, Rhotenberry said. A short-term solution is to speed up the rate at which the wells draw gases from the pool to prevent any migration.

The groundwater, which is mixed with sand, is separated from the deeper water by a layer of clay, so the EPA is trying to find out how those chemicals were able to penetrate the clay, Rhotenberry said.

The EPA conducts yearly reviews of the site along with the daily monitoring. However, this is only a short-term solution, Rhotenberry said. The long-term solution involves achieving what the EPA calls “unlimited use and unrestricted exposure”: in other words, the ability to build and live on the site without danger.

While things are operating on Brio according to plan, the site is nowhere near the long-term solution, meaning the remedy will stay in place indefinitely, Rhotenberry said.

“Until those conditions are met, the remedy will stay in place,” Rhotenberry said. “[The EPA doesn’t] expect to get there anytime soon.”

Development continues
While the Brio area is not safe to inhabit, the areas around it are, Rhotenberry said.

“It is safe. As far as the areas that are zoned for residential, I don’t think that is an issue,” he said.

Though the area is safe, there has been concern recently with dirt around the site, particularly dirt moved to 2811 Dixie Farm Road for the former Parkwood Plaza development in February 2018.

The dirt was moved from a lot adjacent to the superfund site, but was not contaminated, representatives from the Harris County Flood Control District said.

Both the location of the dirt and the potential flooding risks were concerns,  said Shawn Johnson, a lawyer in Friendswood and Cheryl’s son, in a previous interview with Community Impact Newspaper.

According to the Harris County Flood Control District, the dirt never should have been placed at 2811 Dixie Farm in the first place. However, the dirt is not contaminated and has been tested several times, the district said.

“No soil from the Brio Superfund Site is being excavated by the Flood Control District,” the district said in a written statement to Community Impact Newspaper.

As development continues near the Brio site, the site itself is years away from being safe for use. In fact, it may not ever be safe, Flickinger said.

“They have to keep monitoring. That’s forever,” Flickinger said.

This article has been updated to clarify the Brio site's original purpose and to clarify the timing of sources.
By Haley Morrison
Haley Morrison came to Community Impact Newspaper in 2017 after graduating from Baylor University. She was promoted to editor in February 2019. Haley primarily covers city government.


MOST RECENT

The Texas Central rail connection from Dallas to Houston will feature a bullet train similar to this one. (Courtesy Texas Central Partners/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas Supreme Court declines to review high-speed rail case, freeing company up to use eminent domain

Texas Central, the company looking to build a 236-mile high-speed rail line connecting Houston and Dallas, has been given a big win in an ongoing legal battle over whether the company is legally recognized as a "railroad company" under state law.

There will be various events across the Houston area celebrating the Fourth of July, including League City's Fireworks Extravaganza. (Courtesy of League City)
12 Fourth of July weekend events, celebrations to attend in the Greater Houston area

Here are 12 Fourth of July weekend events throughout the Houston region.

When he is not on the UHCL campus, Delgado is employed part-time as a legal assistant at Travis Bryan Law Group and is also a firefighter with the Pasadena Volunteer Fire Department. (Courtesy University of Houston-Clear Lake)
University of Houston system appoints first-ever University of Houston-Clear Lake Hawk as student regent

Derek Delgado, who is pursuing an undergraduate degree in legal studies at UHCL, will work directly with other student governments throughout the university system and help advocate for student needs.

A new Jersey Mike's Subs location opened April 28 in the Richardson Square development. (Courtesy Jersey Mike's Subs)
Jersey Mike's opens new Pearland location

Jersey Mike’s opened its location at 9811 W. Broadway St., Ste. 121, Pearland.

Paris Coffee Co. serves coffees, espresso drinks and Italian sodas. (courtesy Pexels)
Paris Coffee Co. opens permanent coffee kiosk in Pearland

The business serves coffees, espresso drinks and Italian sodas.

More than 20 countries, including Denmark, participate in CETUSA. (Courtesy CETUSA)
Foreign exchange student program seeks host families

CETUSA is a nonprofit foreign exchange program for high school students.

The Pearland Economic Development Corp. is creating an Entrepreneurship Hub for Pearland with community partners. (Haley Morrison/Community Impact Newspaper)
Pearland to create an Entrepreneurship Hub for small businesses

The Hub will provide resources for the small-business community of Pearland, according to a PEDC press release.

The board meets next on July 19. (Courtesy of Friendswood ISD)
Friendswood ISD board approves 2021-22 teacher salary increase, spending bond funds on security system

Teachers will receive a 1% raise next school year, and about a third of the district's $1 million in bond funds for security upgrades will be spent on a new safety system.

Alvin Community College President Christal M. Albrecht (center) was recently honored with the creation of the Dr. Christal M. Albrecht Endowment scholarship by the ACC Foundation. (Courtesy Alvin Community College)
Alvin Community College Foundation creates scholarship honoring former President Christal Albrecht

Albrecht is retiring June 30 after serving as the college president for seven years, according to a press release.

Alvin Community College President Christal Albrecht (left) and University of Houston-Clear Lake President Ira Blake signed an articulation agreement expansion June 10 that will allow ACC associate degree students to co-enroll in UHCL’s Bachelor of Science in nursing program. (Courtesy University of Houston-Clear Lake)
Alvin Community College, University of Houston-Clear Lake expand nursing program partnership

The agreement between the colleges will streamline the transition process between ACC’s associate degree program for nursing and UHCL’s RN-to-BSN program.

Following Hurricane Harvey, debris lined the streets in many parts of Harris County. (Danica Lloyd/Community Impact Newspaper)
After Department of Housing and Urban Development denies request, Texas General Land Office drafting plan to subaward Harris County $750M for flood mitigation

The Texas General Land Office now plans to subaward Harris County flood mitigation funding after the county was left out of recent Hurricane Harvey relief funds.