Friendswood ISD set to lose more than $200K in state ‘Robin Hood’ taxes

Friendswood ISD anticipates it will lose $232,367 in state funding for the 2016-17 school year due to the districtu2019s reclassification as property wealthy by the state, district officials said.

Friendswood ISD anticipates it will lose $232,367 in state funding for the 2016-17 school year due to the districtu2019s reclassification as property wealthy by the state, district officials said.

Spreading the wealth Source: Friendswood ISD/Community Impact Newspaper[/caption]

Friendswood ISD anticipates it will lose $232,367 in state funding for the 2016-17 school year due to the district’s reclassification as property wealthy by the state, district officials said.


The reclassification—and loss of funds—comes after Friendswood residents approved a 9 cent increase to FISD’s tax rate last year. The district called for a special election in September, saying it was necessary to pay a competitive wage to teachers, recruit talent and retain its employees, who were being poached by neighboring districts that offered more enticing salaries.


“We made some drastic cuts when the Legislature cut [funding] in 2011. We hired back most of the teacher spots but not the administrative and specialist spots,” FISD Superintendent Trish Hanks said. “Our students were suffering. Our schools were suffering. We wanted to be competitive; we were losing teachers to other districts.”


However, the Texas Education Agency took note of the increased tax generation. Because the district crossed a cost-per-student threshold, the state’s wealth equalization plan, known as “recapture” or the “Robin Hood” tax, will kick in this year.



State funding cuts


Every school district in the state has two budgets with separate tax rates: a maintenance and operations—M&O—budget and an interest and sinking—I&S—budget. Friendswood residents approved a tax ratification election in September to specifically increase the district’s M&O tax rate from $1.04 to $1.13, which funds everything from employee salaries and health care plans to school textbooks and office supplies. I&S funds are used to pay down debt.


By raising M&O rates by 9 cents, FISD officials expect to generate more than $2.2 million in the 2016-17 school year over the previous year. However, after the state recaptures some of its funding, FISD will see a net increase of about $2 million.


FISD expects to lose state funding every year following the election due to recapture.


“We calculated all of that for the [election],” FISD Superintendent Trish Hanks said. “We knew that we would probably have to pay a penny’s worth of that increase back to the state. That’s why we raised it the amount that we did.”


Hanks said the district made the decision to hold the tax ratification election—also known as a TRE— after taking into account a variety of factors, such as federal and state funding, tax rates and teacher salaries. She said, as a property wealthy school district, FISD has to find creative ways to balance the budget.


Prior to the TRE, the district said more than $2 million collected for 2016-17 would be used specifically to increase teacher salaries, along with around $700,000 for capital improvement projects.


“It definitely made a difference this year, and will help to make a difference in the future, as well,” Hanks said. “But it is not the permanent solution, at all, as the funding system is written today. We will still have challenges. We will still have to be an efficient district.”


The process of recapture is outlined under Chapter 41 of the Texas Education Code. Recapture was first created in 1993 as a way to divert tax revenue from districts deemed property wealthy to those deemed property poor in an attempt to even the scale for public school students across the state.



Comparing local districts


Recapture was established after a 1989 Texas Supreme Court ruling found the existing school funding system to be unconstitutional. Fast-forward to the 2016-17 school year, and 379 school districts across the state are considered property wealthy and are expected to send more than $2 billion in total to the state, according to the Texas Education Agency.


La Porte, Sheldon and Spring Branch ISDs were the only school districts in the Greater Houston area that paid recapture in the 2015-16 school year. Sheldon ISD, which had 8,477 students that year, paid $1.8 million and La Porte ISD, with 7,753 students, paid $24.5 million.


In Galveston County, both Galveston ISD and Texas City ISD paid out $13.2 million and $1.4 million in 2015-16, respectively.


According to Hanks, each of these districts has one key difference from FISD.


“The difference in all of those other districts is that they are heavily industrial,” Hanks said. “The big difference with Friendswood is that we do not have that kind of profile. We are property wealthy only because our [property] values keep going up and we’re building more houses and some commercial, but we’re not growing in student [enrollment].”



Changes from the legislature


Although the 85th legislative session is underway and would give legislators the opportunity to amend the state’s funding formula, FISD officials do not expect much change.


“I’m not expecting any change this session. I don’t think they are far enough along to do that,” Hanks said. “I haven’t read anything that has been a serious proposal coming out of the Legislature.”


While tweaks to the formula may be more difficult to achieve, the House-proposed 2018-19 biennium budget includes an additional $1.5 billion of public school funding, or a 3.5 percent increase from the last biennium.


House Speaker Joe Straus, R-San Antonio, said the increase is contingent upon a reduction in recapture.


“Our school finance system may meet the legal definition of constitutional. But parents and taxpayers know something different,” Straus said on the session’s opening day. “They know that the system is broken … and they know that it’s our job to fix it.”


Chandra Villanueva, senior policy analyst for the Austin-based Center for Public Policy Priorities, is skeptical recapture would be reduced with a funding increase that size. She said the House budget bill does not adequately raise a district’s basic state funding allotment, which is the starting point for campuses’ funding.


“The easiest way to meet those stipulations is to increase the state’s basic allotment,” Villanueva said of reducing the need for recapture. “When that allotment goes up, recapture goes down because schools are able to keep more.”


All districts receive a basic allotment from the state, but only property poor districts receive money from recapture payments.


Friendswood ISD Chief Financial Officer Connie Morgenroth said the district must keep any potential legislative changes in mind when forecasting the future.


“It’s hard to forecast way into the future,” Morgenroth said. “You can try, and I go out two or three years, but I have to assume the formula is not going to change when I make those assumptions, and nobody knows what’s going to happen.”



MOST RECENT

METRONext is the agency’s $3.5 billion bond approved by voters in November 2019, which aims to ease traffic congestion, add expansion to the METRO, and make accessibility and safety upgrades.
(Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
METRO Board approves $1.3 billion budget, discusses METRONext projects

The METRO board of directors met Sept. 21 to give an overview of the drafted budget as well as to receive public comments. It was unanimously approved at the Sept. 23 board meeting.

Qatar Charity along with the University of Houston-Clear Lake Diplomacy Institute will host a food distribution event. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
University of Houston-Clear Lake to host food distribution event Sept. 25

Qatar Charity along with the University of Houston-Clear Lake Diplomacy Institute will host a food distribution event.

The Texas Secretary of State's office has launched an audit of 2020 election results in four of Texas’ largest counties: Harris, Dallas, Tarrant and Collin. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Texas Secretary of State's office announces audit of 2020 election results in Dallas, Collin, Tarrant and Harris counties

In a statement released Sept. 23, the office said it anticipates the state Legislature will fund the process.

Kyle City Council voted 6-1 and approved the new citywide trail master plan that will utilize 2020 bond election funds for trails that will help connect Austin to San Antonio. (Courtesy Pexels)
CI Nation roundup: Perfect Game coming to Cedar Park; Kyle City Council approves trail master plan to connect Austin to San Antonio and more top stories

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Sept. 24.

Friendswood mayor Mike Foreman holds the scissors for the ceremonial ribbon cutting of the new Friendswood Lakes Boulevard extension. (Andy Yanez/ Community Impact Newspaper)
Friendswood Lakes Boulevard opens as 'one piece of a multiphase project'

Friendswood Mayor Mike Foreman on Sept. 23 cut the ribbon for the opening of Friendswood Lakes Boulevard.

Big League Dreams will reopen in December with updated turf, seating, nets, fencing, graphics and other upgrades. (Courtesy city of League City)
Big League Dreams to reopen in League City; New Caney ISD officials address student possession of a gun, and more top stories from Greater Houston

Read the most popular business and community news from the past week from the Greater Houston area.

Comcast will award $1 million to small businesses owned by people of color in Fort Bend and Harris counties (Courtesy Fotolia)
Comcast Rise Investment Fund to award small business grants in Harris, Fort Bend counties

Comcast will award $1 million to small businesses owned by people of color in Fort Bend and Harris counties.

Several parents of New Caney ISD students spoke at the district's Sept. 20 board meetings about recent allegations that a student brought a firearm to Porter High School's Sept. 18 homecoming dance. NCISD Superintendent Matt Calvert stressed that no gunshots were fired at the event, and that the district is investigating the allegations. (Wesley Gardner/Community Impact Newspaper)
CI Nation roundup: Round Rock ISD trustees considered for censuring; New Caney ISD addresses allegations of student with gun at campus event and more top stories

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Sept. 23.

Houston resident Marissa Hanson spoke on keeping tax rates low during the Harris County Commissioners Court public hearing on Sept. 21. (Emily Lincke/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County Commissioners propose tax cuts at cost of Harris Health System funding

On average, Harris County homeowners may see lower tax rates in the next year, but it will come at the cost of $17 million in funding for the county’s hospital district, according to Harris County Administrator David Berry.

Pearland ISD is taking applications for kindergarten to sixth grade students who are interested in a virtual schooling option. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Pearland ISD offering applications for virtual learning option for K-6 students

Pearland ISD is taking applications for kindergarten to sixth grade students who are interested in a virtual schooling option.

There are eight statewide propositions Texans will get to decide at the polls Nov. 2. (Liesbeth Powers/Community Impact Newspaper)
8 statewide propositions on Texans' November 2021 ballot and what they mean

Brandon Rottinghaus, the University of Houston’s political science chair, breaks down each Texas proposition before voters head to the polls in November.

 Redistricting is one of the items on the Texas Legislature's third special session, and the state Senate released proposed maps on Sept. 18. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas Senate releases proposed redistricting maps as special session begins

Redistricting is one of the items on the third special session, and the state Senate released proposed maps on Sept. 18.