Harris County officials, groups debate bail bond settlement

Image description
Harris County officials, groups debate bail bond settlement
Harris County officials made changes to the bail bond system in July they believe could curb disenfranchisement of low-income individuals. However, some county officials and organizations are challenging the validity of the new system.

Harris County commissioners settled an ongoing lawsuit July 30 the county had been fighting since 2016 and adopted policy reforms that could set a precedent for future bail cases. Commissioners were divided on the reform, passing it on a 3-2 vote.

Under new policies, the vast majority of individuals arrested for misdemeanor crimes would be eligible to be released on automatic, no-cash pretrial bonds based on an evaluated risk of the defendant’s risk to society or of skipping court dates. Precinct 2 Commissioner Adrian Garcia, who represents the Atascocita area, lauded the reform as a historic move in the justice system.

“The best way to keep our communities safe is having a multi-tiered approach that allows our district attorney and law enforcement officers to focus on the most dangerous while enhancing a criminal justice system that promotes fairness for all,” he said in an Aug. 1 news release.

However, nine different Harris County groups and officials filed amicus briefs or written oppositions against the proposed settlement, including Precinct 4 Commissioner Jack Cagle, Precinct 3 Commissioner Steve Radack and District Attorney Kim Ogg, according to an Aug. 23 news release from the Professional Bondsmen of Texas, a bail bond industry association.

They cited public safety concerns, violations of state law and financial burden on taxpayers as reasons to reject the settlement, according to their amicus briefs. A hearing to determine final ruling of the settlement is set for Sept. 19.

Mario Garza, president of the Harris County Professional Bondsmen Association, a bail bond association that also submitted an amicus brief, said he believes the cash bail bond system helps encourage defendants to attend court.

“When we bond somebody out, a family member comes to sign for them—a cosigner, a wife, a relative, a mom, a dad—and they say, ‘If my son or daughter doesn’t go to court, I’m going to be responsible,’” he said. “The likeliness of them returning is a lot higher than if they sign a piece of paper.”

Terms of settlement

Jennifer Chiotti, criminal justice professor at Lone Star College-Kingwood, said she believes the previous cash bail system systematically disenfranchised low-income and minority groups.

“It’s a longstanding notion that the rich get richer and the poor get prison,” Chiotti said. “If you have the financial resources, the criminal justice system is not as big of a burden.”

In April 2017, Lee Rosenthal, the chief district judge of the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of Texas, declared Harris County’s bail bond system unconstitutional, finding the practice of jailing people for not being able to afford bail violates guarantees of due process.

The county appealed the ruling and fought the lawsuit, but after a slate of Democrats were elected to judge and commissioner seats last November, the county began working with the plaintiffs on a settlement. In February, the county changed its bail bond policies, resulting in about 85% of those arrested on misdemeanors getting released pretrial on unsecured personal bonds.

Since February, the number of people being held in the Harris County jail pretrial for misdemeanors has dropped. An average of 465 people were held for pretrial misdemeanors over the first six months of 2016, while that number dropped to 278 over the first six months of 2019, according to Texas Commission on Jail Standards data.

The no-cash bail would not be available for people arrested for certain crimes, including domestic violence or a second arrest for driving while intoxicated. People detained for those reasons must attend a hearing before a judicial officer, who will determine the bond.

Following the federal ruling in 2017, the county already began implementing similar changes to its bail practices, known as Local Rule 9. Among the rule’s requirements, secured money bail must not be required as a condition of pretrial release prior to determining a person’s ability to pay, and all misdemeanor arrestees must be released on a personal bond as soon as practical after arrest, with a few exceptions.

Ogg, who originally supported the plaintiff’s position in 2016, also opposed the settlement in a brief issued Aug. 22.

“The district attorney has no objection to a settlement approved by this court requiring and monitoring the continued enforcement of that rule,” Ogg wrote in her amicus brief. “The proposed settlement seeks relief far beyond the scope of the original controversy, however.”

Public safety concerns

Cagle—who voted against the change and filed an amicus brief—said he has concerns over victims not being accounted for as well as the settlement cost. The settlement is projected to cost up to $97 million and includes a study to assess why people miss court dates and initiatives to improve court appearance rates, such as a text message system to remind defendants of their court date.

“It’s not very fair to victims,” he said. “[There is nothing] there to address the civil rights of victims.”

In the Kingwood, Humble and Atascocita area, the most frequent crime in the last six months—from Feb. 15 to Aug. 14—was breaking and entering with 241 incidents, followed by theft from vehicle at 213 incidents, according to data from the Crime Reports website, which compiles data from Harris County law enforcement agencies. Per the reform, breaking and entering would not qualify for no-cash bond, while burglarizing a vehicle would qualify.

Precinct 1 Commissioner Rodney Ellis said there is no evidence the cash bail system increases public safety, citing a University of Pennsylvania study that found detaining individuals pretrial makes them more likely to commit crimes later on.

The study analyzed 380,689 misdemeanor cases filed in Harris County from 2008-13. Researchers concluded the roughly 40,000 people who were assigned cash bail of $500 or less would have been involved with 1,600 fewer felonies and 2,400 fewer misdemeanors in the 18 months post-trial if they had been released instead of detained.

“[The reform’s] intent is not to release dangerous offenders but to keep individuals out of the system and provide them with the already existing services to prevent them from returning to the system,” Chiotti said.
By Kelly Schafler

Editor, Lake Houston | Humble | Kingwood

Kelly Schafler is the editor for the Lake Houston, Humble and Kingwood edition of Community Impact Newspaper, covering public education, city government, development, businesses, local events and all things community-related. Before she became editor, she was the reporter for the Conroe and Montgomery edition for a year and a half.


Hospitals in the Greater Houston area are adapting to accommodate a surge of coronavirus cases. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Report offers first glimpse at hospital readiness across Houston area

Hospitals within the Texas Medical Center system in the Greater Houston area have plans in place to increase the number of ICU beds available by as much as 80%.

Dr. Campbell talks about the effect of the coronavirus on mental health.(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Q&A: Kelsey-Seybold doctor talks about mental health amid the coronavirus pandemic

Dr. Stefanie Campbell discusses the coronavirus’ effect on mental illness.

Texas Central claims the $12 billion construction process would be privately funded, and the train would transport 6 million annual riders by 2029. (Courtesy Texas Central Partners/Community Impact Newspaper)
State legislators request federal officials halt activity on Texas Central's high-speed rail project

Dozens of elected officials representing Texas requested the U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao put an end to activity related to Texas Central’s high-speed rail project between Dallas and Houston.

The amicus brief is in support of an April 7 lawsuit filed by the Texas Democratic Party seeking legislative action to allow voters who fear exposure to the coronavirus to vote via mail-in ballot. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County Attorney's Office authorized to file amicus brief supporting mail-in ballots amid coronavirus outbreak

The amicus brief is in support of an April 7 lawsuit filed by the Texas Democratic Party seeking legislative action to allow voters who fear exposure to the coronavirus to vote via mail-in ballot.

Graphic by Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper
Harris County in ‘standoff’ over proposed inmate release to curb coronavirus spread

Hidalgo said the county is now at a crossroads having to weigh the lesser of two evils: releasing nonviolent inmates back into society or risking coronavirus spreading rampant through the county jail and filling the county’s hospital beds.

The $48,000 deal with the Cambria Hotel in downtown Houston will provide up to 400 rooms over the course of the month. (Screenshot via Google Earth)
Houston leases additional 400 hotel rooms for first responder quarantine

The city secured an agreement with a downtown hotel to provide up to 400 rooms throughout the month of April.

Nonessential visitors can do window-side visits at most senior living facilities. (Photos courtesy Seasons Assisted Living & Memory Care)
Amid pandemic, ‘unsung heroes’ care for Montgomery County’s most vulnerable

The senior living industry has upped its cleaning protocols, limited in-person visits and made use of virtual chat.

Dr. Maria Elena Bottazzi is the associate dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine. (Courtesy Baylor College of Medicine)
Q&A: Dr. Maria Elena Bottazzi discusses vaccine development

Dr. Bottazzi is the associate dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine and co-director of the Texas Children’s Hospital Center for Vaccine Development.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo signed an order April 8 to temporarily close all parks countywide throughout the upcoming Easter weekend, April 10-13, in hopes of discouraging social gatherings. (Hannah Zedaker/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County to close parks countywide for Easter weekend, April 10-13

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo signed an order April 8 to temporarily close all parks countywide throughout the upcoming Easter weekend, April 10-13, in hopes of discouraging social gatherings.

Companion Animal Hospital is now offering curbside service for clients and their pets. (Courtesy Companion Animal Hospital)
ROUNDUP: Coronavirus coverage in North Houston continues

Read some of the latest coronavirus updates from communities in the North Houston area.

Installing orange meshes across local buses is one of the measures METRO is taking to ensure appropriate social distancing between bus operators and passengers. (Courtesy Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County)
METRO heightens preventative COVID-19 measures

The Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County has begun taking more aggressive measures to halt the spread of COVID-19, the transit authority announced April 7.

Figure Four Partners, a subsidiary of Perry Homes, has offered to let government partners purchase Woodridge Village, a 268-acre development that Kingwood residents allege caused flooding in their communities, such as Elm Grove Village. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper) (Designed by Ethan Pham/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County commissioners vote to continue negotiations, partner with entities on Woodridge Village property acquisition

During executive session at a Harris County Commissioners Court meeting April 7, commissioners deliberated purchasing a 268-acre property in south Montgomery County that officials want to turn into a detention area.