Court dismisses city of Houston from lawsuit that seeks to stop Lake Conroe lowering

A judge has dismissed the city of Houston from a lawsuit in which a Lake Conroe nonprofit sought to file a restraining order against the San Jacinto River Authority and the city. (Vanessa Holt/Community Impact Newspaper)
A judge has dismissed the city of Houston from a lawsuit in which a Lake Conroe nonprofit sought to file a restraining order against the San Jacinto River Authority and the city. (Vanessa Holt/Community Impact Newspaper)

A judge has dismissed the city of Houston from a lawsuit in which a Lake Conroe nonprofit sought to file a restraining order against the San Jacinto River Authority and the city. (Vanessa Holt/Community Impact Newspaper)

A judge has dismissed the city of Houston from a lawsuit in which a Lake Conroe nonprofit sought to file a restraining order against the San Jacinto River Authority and the city. The city was dismissed from the lawsuit April 9, but all matters concerning the SJRA are still pending, according to court documents.

The Lake Conroe Association, which advocates for residents and businesses on the lake, and other plaintiffs filed a lawsuit in Montgomery County to stop the seasonal lowering of Lake Conroe. The temporary strategy is intended to mitigate flooding in areas downstream, such as Kingwood and Humble, but Lake Conroe residents have claimed the practice causes harm to their homes, businesses and livelihood.

The lawsuit claimed the lowering is unlawful and sought an immediate temporary restraining order and a final injunction that would prohibit discharging from the lake except in certain circumstances, Community Impact Newspaper reported.

Judge Kristin Bays of the 284th district court dismissed the city of Houston from the case by granting the city’s plea for jurisdiction, which sought governmental immunity from the lawsuit, according to the amended court order.

"The Texas Legislature has held that governmental entities like the SJRA and the city of Houston generally have immunity from many of the kinds of suits that can be brought against them by other companies or individual people, unless the Texas Legislature specifically authorizes that kind of suit," said attorney James Stilwell, who is representing the SJRA.


In an email, Jessica Beemer, chief of staff for District E in Kingwood, verified that the city had been dismissed from the lawsuit.

"Any potential hearing ... will not involve the City as a defendant, because the City is no longer a party to the lawsuit," she said.

Additionally, the court’s ruling disputed the plaintiffs’ unconstitutional takings petition, which claimed that by discharging water from Lake Conroe, the city of Houston was taking a property interest from the lake’s residents. The ruling dismissed this claim, stating that the residents did not own the lake’s water, according to the order.

"The crux of Plaintiffs' takings complaint is that SJRA and the City are wasting state water by lowering the lake level in Lake Conroe. But the operative term here is 'state water.' Plaintiffs do not own the water," Bays' order stated. "Given that they do not own the thing that they complain has been taken, they have no takings claim. Their allegations, even if true, are insufficient under Texas law to create a takings claim."

Meanwhile, the SJRA also filed a plea for jurisdiction April 12, arguing the court should dismiss the claims against the authority because it was established by the state of Texas and therefore has governmental immunity from those claims. Stilwell said the judge is set to hear the SJRA's claim on May 7, and the case will be dismissed if the plea is granted. A temporary injunction hearing will be held May 28 if the plea of jurisdiction is not granted, he said.

Officials began lowering the lake's level April 1, an effort that will continue throughout the month. Lake Conroe will remain at 200 feet above mean sea level until May 31, per the approved strategy.

The temporary lake lowering measure was reapproved by the SJRA board of directors in February 2020. The board agreed to keep the strategy in place until December 2022 when the Lake Houston dam gate project was estimated to be complete—although that date that has been pushed to early 2024.

Eva Vigh contributed to this report.
By Kelly Schafler

Editor, Lake Houston | Humble | Kingwood

Kelly Schafler is the editor for the Lake Houston, Humble and Kingwood edition of Community Impact Newspaper, covering public education, city government, development, businesses, local events and all things community-related. Before she became editor, she was the reporter for the Conroe and Montgomery edition for a year and a half.



MOST RECENT

Imperio Wine & Spirits sells a variety of liquor, beer, wine and spirits. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Imperio Wine & Spirits opens in Katy; Montgomery Chick-fil-A to open dining room and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Greater Houston area.

The current Humble Fire Station No. 2 is located on Wilson Road. (Courtesy Google Maps)
Humble City Council votes to negotiate contract with architect to design Humble Fire Station No. 2 replacement

Members of the Humble Fire Department were also recognized by City Council for their win at the North Harris Firefighter Challenge on April 24.

Crunch Fitness is replacing 24 Hour Fitness, which closed its Atascocita location along with at least 11 other facilities in the Greater Houston area last June. (Rendering courtesy Crunch Fitness)
National gym chain Crunch Fitness to replace former 24 Hour Fitness spot in Atascocita

The pool, sauna and steam room will be renovated, while the basketball court will transition into a turf area for small-group training and a spin class studio.

Mayor Norman Funderburk took the oath of office on May 13. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Humble swears in incoming Mayor Norman Funderburk, incumbent council members

Norman Funderburk was sworn in as mayor and incumbents Charles “Andy” Curry and Charles Cunningham were also sworn in after being re-elected to places 1 and 2, respectively.

See how some Greater Houston area school districts are planning to go back to school for the 2021-22 academic year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
See how some Greater Houston area school districts are planning to go back to school for the 2021-22 academic year

While some school districts in the Greater Houston area are doing away with face mask requirements and virtual schooling completely, others are pivoting to continue offering online learning options for students and plan to require face masks.

masks
CDC ends all mask requirements for fully vaccinated people

The guidance states fully vaccinated people do not need to wear masks indoors or outdoors.

Single-family home sales were up 47.4% compared to last April with 9,105 units sold versus 6,175 a year earlier. (Courtesy Houston Association of Realtors)
HAR: Houston-area home sales in April up 47% compared to last year

Single-family home sales were up 47.4% compared to April 2020.

House Bill 1024, signed into law May 12, allows restaurants and bars to permanently sell alcoholic beverages to-go. (Courtesy Pexels)
Cocktails to-go are here to stay in Texas: Gov. Greg Abbott signs change into law May 12

Supporters say the change will help restaurants continue to recover from the economic effects of the coronavirus pandemic.

New details could emerge soon on the potential use of underground tunnels to carry flood water in Harris County, and officials voted May 11 to dedicate an additional $3.26 million to study efforts along Buffalo Bayou. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
County commissioners expand scope of flood tunnel study as next phase nears completion

New details could emerge soon on the potential use of underground tunnels to carry flood water in Harris County, and officials voted May 11 to dedicate an additional $3.26 million to study efforts along Buffalo Bayou.

Middle School No. 10 will open in August 2022. (Rendering courtesy Humble ISD's presentation for the community input meeting)
Humble ISD trustees approve attendance boundaries for incoming Middle School No. 10

Middle School No. 10 will open in August 2022 near Ridge Creek Elementary School.

Russo's New York Pizzeria will open its second location in the Lake Houston area in New Caney. (Courtesy The Signorelli Co.)
Russo's New York Pizzeria to make June debut in Valley Ranch Town Center

The Italian eatery—located in the space formerly occupied by RC's NYC Pizza & Pasta—will also feature an outdoor patio.