Loss of protected status for Houston’s second-biggest immigrant group expected to cost region $1.8B

7

The federal government entered into a shutdown early Saturday morning, in part due to Congress’ inability to agree on the fate of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals—DACA—program. But another immigration program’s end is expected to have to an economic effect on the Greater Houston area.

Temporary protected status, or TPS, for immigrants from El Salvador will expire Sept. 9, 2019, U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security Kirstjen Nielsen’s office announced nearly two weeks ago. As a result, Salvadoran immigrants who benefitted from the program must either leave the country or find a path to legal residency by the deadline.

Salvadorans are the Houston region’s second-biggest immigrant group and numbered nearly 104,000 in 2012, according to a 2015 report by the Migration Policy Institute. Laura Murillo, president and CEO of the Houston Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, said about 20,000 people in the Houston region will be directly affected by the loss of TPS and another 20,000 U.S.-born children of Salvadoran immigrants will likely have their families disrupted.

“They work in business, they work in the service industry—they contribute,” Murillo said. “There’s a price that’s going to be paid in our GDP.”

The end of TPS for this group would cost the Greater Houston area about $1.8 billion in lost economic activity, she said, adding that she was disappointed by the news but not surprised.

Houston has a larger share of non-citizen immigrants than the country as a whole, in part because of a higher rate of immigrants from El Salvador and Honduras with TPS, which according to DHS does not lead to citizenship. TPS’ expiration for Honduran and Haitian immigrants was also announced in December and November, respectively.

DHS said the 18-month delay for El Salvador is intended to give Congress a chance to pass a legislative solution. But Zenobia Lai, program director for the St. Frances Cabrini Center for Immigrant Legal Assistance, said many of Houston’s immigrants expect the program will simply end.

“Hondurans in TPS status have lived in our community for close to 20 years, many more than that; they pay taxes, contribute to our community, establish homes, raise children and provide the skills and labor needed by our economy,” she said in an email. “Salvadorans in TPS status have been here since 2001, and have similarly contributed to our community; Haitians though for shorter period of time, have also been here for at least eight years.”

El Salvador was granted TPS 17 years ago under then-President George W. Bush due to severe earthquakes in that county, which killed 1,100 people, injured 7,859 and left more than 2,500 missing, according to the Federal Register. The disasters displaced 1.3 million people, or approximately 17 percent of El Salvador’s population.

DHS said its decision was based on a review of “disaster-related conditions upon which the country’s original designation was based,” and determined that the conditions caused by the earthquakes no longer exist.

Meanwhile, the U.S. Department of State has a Level 3 travel advisory in effect for El Salvador, meaning that federal officials recommend people “reconsider” traveling to the Central American nation. A level 4 advisory is the highest issued and would recommend not traveling to the country.

“Violent crime, such as murder, assault, rape, and armed robbery is common,” the advisory states. “Gang activity, such as extortion, violent street crime, and narcotics and arms trafficking, is widespread. Local police may lack the resources to respond effectively to serious criminal incidents.”

In DHS’ announcement, the agency said it has conducted “extensive outreach” to Salvadoran communities. But Lai, whose umbrella organization Catholic Charities has staff with TPS, said she was unaware of any such activity right before the announcement.

“Ending TPS for close to 200,000 Salvadorans, 57,000 Hondurans and another 50,000 Haitians while knowing the level of violence and unfinished recovery since earthquakes seems unconscionable to me,” she said.

Until Sept. 9 next year, immigrants with TPS can and are still recommended to re-register. Lai said it is still uncertain what could happen with the program, and even another 18 months in the country could give people time to find new residency options.

“It is the same reason why DACA recipients would still renew not knowing what the future holds for the program,” she said.

Share this story
7 comments
COMMENT
  1. Robert Anderson and Albert if your immigrant families when they came to this country were in this same situation you would be singing a different tune. As a conservative your rhetoric pisses me off. I was born in the US. I have worked in the service industry most of my life.
    Many of these folks work hard and contribute they deserve a path to citizenship. You and the Cheeto in office have zero clue

    • Born in the US? C’mon give us the rest of your story? How many of your relatives were not? What vested interest do you have in people coming here illegally and leeching off the system? Why does this offend you? Conservative rhetoric, which is based on facts, is more plausible than leftist opinions and same old talking points. Why should any group get a free pass on immigration? Get in line and go through the LEGAL process like the rest of everyone else, including my wife. Get off your non-conservative bias.

  2. SecureOurBorderNOW

    Oh, brother. Murillo needs to quit making up numbers. It’s so deceitful. They are leeching off of us and have no right to be here. We also have 0 obligation to let them stay. Time’s up!

    “Hispanic Chamber of Commerce” How racist. Talk about double standards. It should be disbanded immediately.

    Abbi- “immigrants” get permission, they don’t intentionally breach international borders for self gain. Illegal aliens do. Rewarding lawbreakers only encourages more. This isn’t rocket science. Your little sob stories aren’t working, sorry. You are the one that needs to buy a clue.

  3. When did Community Impact start taking propaganda as news. Loss of GDP is overstated. Sure, there will be some loss, but what about the net effect after decreasing all the aid programs to illegal aliens? No pass on this one; this is biased and false reporting. Murillo is on the wrong side of right; he is part of the problem. This doom and gloom piece is designed to pull on heart strings, what about the purse string$? Same tired old talking points as DACA. Cute how the doom and gloom takes precedence and the facts are pushed way down in this piece, propaganda masquerading as news. #maga #securetheborders #illegalsareillegal #godlessaltleft #corruptmedia

    • I agree 100%. This used to be a place we could come read news. It must’ve been bought out and converted to another propaganda outlet trying to brainwash the sheeple. Notice how many Texas Tribune opinion pieces thinly disguised as news they post. We see what you’re doing, Community Impact.

Leave A Reply

Back to top