Police oversight board seen as target for reform

Tracking police reform text
This story is part two of a series exploring Houston's police reform task force report. (Anya Gallant/Community Impact Newspaper)

This story is part two of a series exploring Houston's police reform task force report. (Anya Gallant/Community Impact Newspaper)

Image description
(Anya Gallant/Community Impact Newspaper)
Image description
(Anya Gallant/Community Impact Newspaper)
Image description
(Anya Gallant/Community Impact Newspaper)
Image description
(Anya Gallant/Community Impact Newspaper)
Editor’s note: This article is the second in a series exploring Houston’s police reform task force report. Read part one here.

Formed amid calls for reform in 2011, Houston’s Police Oversight Board is facing new scrutiny in the aftermath of Houstonian George Floyd’s death in Minneapolis police custody this spring.

The volunteer board serves as an independent check on Houston Police Department’s Internal Affairs Division, which investigates officer misconduct.

In recent years, criticism of the board has grown, even from some of its own members.

“There are a lot of great police officers, and I would’ve thought they would want to get rid of these guys that we see as repeat offenders,” board member Shelley Kennedy said. “You can see them, and it’s a sure pattern of their behavior when you read these complaints.”

The main concerns raised are that complaints are too difficult to file, that misconduct investigations by HPD’s Internal Affairs Division favor police and that too many members of the oversight board consistently approve Internal Affair’s assessments regardless of other members’ dissent.

Mayor Sylvester Turner’s task force on police reform dedicated a 15-page section of its Sept. 30 report to potential changes to the board.

Turner has publicly expressed interest in some of the recommendations, but changes are still being debated.

“With every single one of these recommendations, it requires resources, and there is a cost,” Houston City Council Member Abbie Kamin said; Kamin is also the chair of the city’s safety and homeland security committee.

At the same time, members of the Houston Police Officers Union have said the board is working as intended.

“[Activists] think that officers are just getting away with stuff all the time. It’s just not true,” HPOU Executive Director Ray Hunt said. “If they had ever been investigated by Internal Affairs, they wouldn’t believe that.”

Keeping track

Activists, task force members and former board members have all said the current misconduct review process makes filing complaints difficult and does little to factor in the number of complaints an officer receives over the course of their career.

Former board member Juan Antonio Sorto said that from the start of the process, filing complaints is not easy.

“I don’t even know how [complaints] work, and that’s a problem,” he said.

The board’s website lists local NAACP and League of United Latin American Citizens chapters and the Houston Office of Inspector General as collection points for complaints, but the mayor’s task force found those avenues have “fallen into disuse.”

Only allowing residents to submit complaints directly to HPD via phone or a notarized form creates a barrier, the task force concluded.

HPD data shows that between 2015 and 2019, 20 percent of complaints that ended with any type of sanction came from the public. The rest were filed internally among HPD personnel.

This lack of accessibility prompted local advocacy group Houston Justice to begin an effort to form its own online complaint system. Karla Brown, an organizer with the group, said the issue was highlighted by a botched no-knock raid in January 2019 that resulted in the deaths of an East End Houston couple, Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas. The aftermath of the raid, which was based on disputed evidence, saw several Houston police officers indicted—including Gerald Goines, who Brown said was known as a threat.

“What we’re seeing is that it takes somebody to die to bring attention to something that an officer had been doing for years,” she said.

The loss of community trust in misconduct reviews can have long-lasting effects, according to a November Kinder Institute of Urban Research report. It found Houston’s board the least effective oversight system among those in major Texas cities.

“Research suggests that the complete lack of an oversight agency is better for a city ... than if they have an agency that lacks effective legal and investigative powers,” it read.

Reviewing allegations

By the time a complaint makes it to the board, the task force and some board members argue, the HPD investigation of it favors police.

In August, nine-year board member Kristin Anderson wrote a resignation letter referring to the issue.

“[The Independent Police Oversight Board] operates inside a closed system without the ability to investigate, conduct its own interviews, or do anything else but follow the narrative offered to them,” she wrote.

Hunt, however, said he believes the process keeps out political influence.

“This is our careers on the line. So we want experienced investigators doing this and not some board created by a bunch of activists,” he said.

After complaints are reviewed by Internal Affairs, they are split among the board’s members, who are divided into four panels led by one panel head each. The members vote on whether to approve of Internal Affairs assessment.

All cases then return to HPD’s Administrative Disciplinary Committee, which is a combination of HPD staff and the board’s panel heads and chair. The disciplinary committee decides the officer’s punishment.

Kennedy said she has been troubled by the process because some panel heads and discipline committee members, she said, consistently vote in favor of Iax disciplinary measures regardless of the severity or frequency of complaints against an officer.

“No matter how much we scream and holler, we can still be outvoted,” she said.

This conflict came to head Sept. 10 when Houston Police Chief Art Acevedo fired four officers who shot and killed 27-year-old Nicolas Chavez while he was in a mental health crisis.

“It is distressing to the Task Force that the civilians put in place to hold officers accountable would defend these officers’ actions when even the Chief of Police himself said that he ‘cannot defend [the officers’] actions,’’ the task force report read, referencing Acevedo’s public remarks.

Hunt contended that the union and the police department do not have influence over the appointees, who are recommended by the mayor and approved by City Council.

“I really have great respect for our current Independent Police Oversight Board,” he said. “Sometimes, they agree with us. Sometimes, they don’t.”

When the panel heads do vote to overturn Internal Affairs’ assessments, Sorto said, he rarely gets confirmation that their opinion was considered.

“If we had any disagreements ... it was really hard to know what the outcomes were,” he said. “It still felt like we were just there to say there was a board representing the communities.”

What’s next

The task force report ultimately calls for a “hybrid” model of oversight borrowing from other cities’ accountability systems. It proposes forming an investigative unit paid by the city to serve alongside the board as well as reducing the number of two-year terms the board members can serve.

In the short-term, they suggest translating complaint forms into foreign languages and changing board membership requirements. Kamin said the investigative powers could come from strengthening the Office of Inspector General.

“One of my priorities is making sure that the Office of the Inspector General has the capacity to do those investigations as the public demands, and that is going to go hand in hand with [board] restructuring,” she said.

At the state level, Sen. Boris Miles, D-Houston, has filed legislation aiming to add subpoena power to the board’s investigative abilities.

Meanwhile, Brown said Houston Justice will continue working on its own database to track complaints. “It’s kind of like you’re asking the city to tell on themselves,” she said. “They tend to skew things in a more positive way.”
By Emma Whalen
Emma is Community Impact Newspaper's Houston City Hall reporter. Previously, she covered public health, education and features for several Austin-area publications. A Boston native, she is a former student athlete and alumna of The University of Texas at Austin.


Eleven days after officials across Harris County's criminal justice system met to discuss how to alleviate overcrowding at the county jail during the coronavirus pandemic, progress has been "excruciatingly slow," according to the Harris County Sheriff's Office. (Courtesy Brian Jackson/Adobe Stock)
Progress 'excruciatingly slow' on effort to address overcrowding at Harris County Jail

"I know it is keeping many of us awake at night, and it should. It absolutely should," said U.S. District Judge Lee Rosenthal, who is presiding over an ongoing lawsuit dealing with the county's felony bail practices.

Texas Medical Center offers coronavirus updates

More than 118,000 people have received their first shot.

Harris County Flood Control District is planning to submit preliminary flood plain maps to the Federal Emergency Management Agency in late 2021. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County's preliminary flood plain maps to be released in late 2021

The new flood insurance rates in Harris County could take effect in 2023 or 2024.

vaccine drive-thru
Houston opens first drive-thru vaccination site

The site aims to distribute 1,000 doses per day for the first week and can scale up if more doses become available.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo announced the opening of a COVID-19 vaccine waitlist at a Jan. 25 press conference. (Screenshot courtesy Facebook)
Harris County to open waitlist for COVID-19 vaccines Jan. 26

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo warned that vaccine supply remains "extremely limited," and it will still take time for those waitlisted to get an appointment.

A monthslong process to reach an understanding between regional leaders and the Texas Department of Transportation about objectives of the I-45 project stalled Jan. 22. (Nathan Colbert/Community Impact Newspaper)
H-GAC group stalls I-45 resolution after TxDOT objects to agreement

TxDOT officials told members of the Houston-Galveston Area Council’s Transportation Policy Council that the agency’s lawyers advised them not to sign off on the new resolution.

“Hope is on the horizon,” Fort Bend County Judge KP George said at a press conference Jan. 4. “The vaccine is here.”
Vaccine distribution starts in Fort Bend County and more top Houston-area news

Read the most popular news from the past week from the Houston area.

Novel at River Oaks
Inner Loop apartment rents tumbled by as much as 16% in 2020

"I would hope that these operators in those areas—at some point, you can’t lower rents anymore. They just have to wait for people to show up," ApartmentData's Bruce McClenny said.

The first-ever Houston Reads Day will take place March 2. (Courtesy Pexels)
Volunteers needed for inaugural literacy-focused Houston Reads Day

Volunteers will read to 10,000 kindergarten through third-grade students.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is coming to Montrose Collective

"What attracted us to Houston was the incredible cultural and culinary diversity and the feeling of progress, growth in modernity the city radiates. The average daily temperature didn’t hurt either,” co-founder Ben Van Leeuwen said.

One local health system leader said he expects everyone, including those under age 65, will have access to the vaccine within the next 90 days. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Houston-area health system leaders talk progress, hurdles during COVID-19

Officials from CHI St. Luke’s Health and UTMB Health said community members must remain vigilant as case counts climb but that they expect the current surge to peak by early February.