Historic preservation dispute complicates embattled Hurricane Harvey recovery program

A dispute between the Texas General Land Office and community leaders in some of Houston’s historic neighborhoods of color is tying up progress on a program designed to rebuild houses damaged by Hurricane Harvey.

As a result, progress on home reconstructions in some areas has stalled or moved forward with a different style and sometimes smaller layout than the homes had prior to the storm. The inconsistency threatens not only the history of these neighborhoods, but the appraised values of the homes as well, said Judson Robinson III, the president of the Houston Area Urban League.

“This is the vehicle that allows them to pass on wealth to the next generation. ... If you take away the tenants of what it takes to have a successful neighborhood ... you are doing a disservice to residents,” Robinson said at a city of Houston press conference about the issue July 26.

At the heart of the disagreement is varying interpretations of deed restrictions in Pleasantville in Northeast Houston and Sagemont in South Houston. In both neighborhoods, community leaders said existing deed restrictions require homes to have specific qualities, such as garages and concrete slab foundations. The Pleasantville neighborhood was one of the first majority-Black communities in the country protected by deed restrictions, said Mary Fontenot, the president of the Pleasantville Civic Club Association, at the press conference.

“Can you imagine owning a home for 30 or 40 years ... and they say, ‘Guess what? We’re going to reduce the size of your home,’” Fontenot said. “What about the equity you have in your home?”


GLO representatives said, however, that funding for the recovery program, which is reserved for low-income households and administered through the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, has restricted uses, which do not include garages or other features listed in the deed restrictions. The land office can only build homes to deed restriction standards, GLO spokesperson Brittany Eck said, if they are enforced by a legally established homeowners association, not a civic club, as is the case in Pleasantville and Sagemont.

“There are limited funds and tremendous remaining needs,” Eck said. “HUD will not allow additional costs beyond the needs of the families, so a house may be bigger or smaller depending on the size of the family and the existing house.”

Mayor Sylvester Turner convened the press conference regarding the issue, making note his administration and the GLO were previously locked in a legal battle over control of the recovery funds for several months. The GLO ultimately received control of the program and its funding.

“When the city had this program, people were very critical, but what I will say, we were rebuilding people’s homes back to the way they were,” Turner said. “We weren’t reducing their value or diminishing their neighborhoods.”

Eck, however, noted as of July 21, after having control over the program for 14 months, the GLO had reconstructed 121 homes in Houston. When the city of Houston was in control of the funds, it was able to construct 45 homes in 14 months, according to the GLO data.
By Emma Whalen
Emma is Community Impact Newspaper's Houston City Hall reporter. Previously, she covered public health, education and features for several Austin-area publications. A Boston native, she is a former student athlete and alumna of The University of Texas at Austin.


MOST RECENT

The Texas Department of Transportation is planning to install medians along 5.8 miles of FM 1092 from Hwy. 59 to Hwy. 6 in Missouri City. (Courtesy Fotolia)
As FM 1092 median project goes out to bid, some Missouri City Council Members still object

Construction on the project to install medians on FM 1092—also known as Murphy Road—is expected to begin in the winter and last for seven months, according to officials with TxDOT.

At the Sept. 14 Harris County Commissioners Court meeting, County Administrator David Berry, top left, presents proposed tax rates to commissioners Jack Cagle and Tom Ramsey, Judge Lina Hidalgo, and commissioners Adrian Garcia and Rodney Ellis. (Emily Lincke/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County commissioners propose lower tax rates with split vote

While the proposed tax rate is lower than the current rate, tax payers may actually end up paying more since the values of homes statewide increased this year, according to County Administrator David Berry.

About 62% of Harris County residents ages 12 and older have been fully vaccinated against COVID-19. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Harris County commissioners terminate $11 million Elevate Strategies vaccine outreach contract

“There’s absolutely nothing done here that was in any way deviating from the most adequate protocols, and what is sad … [is] that the COVID response is being politicized." -Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo

The city of Houston has begun to clean up debris left by Hurricane Nicholas. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
‘It could have been a lot worse': Houston begins cleanup after Hurricane Nicholas

Over 150,000 residents were still without power as of the mayor’s morning update.

Shelters around Houston opened to help those affected by Hurricane Nicholas on Sept. 14. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Shelters open to aid those affected by Hurricane Nicholas

Shelters have been opened by the American Red Cross to help those in need following the storm.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo said there are currently no reported injuries or fatalities from Tropical Storm Nicholas. (Screenshot courtesy Facebook)
Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo encourages residents to stay off roads, reports no fatalities due to Tropical Storm Nicholas

Hidalgo also said she expects all Harris County COVID-19 testing and vaccination sites to be open Sept. 15.

The Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County on Sept. 14 resumed limited services. (Courtesy Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County)
METRO operating on limited service in aftermath of Hurricane Nicholas

The Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County on Sept. 14 resumed limited services.

Hundreds of thousands are without power after Tropical Storm Nicholas made landfall. (Courtesy CenterPoint Energy)
UPDATED: Some CenterPoint customers may be without power for days following Hurricane Nicholas damage

As of 6:37 p.m. Sept. 14, more than 120,000 remaiined without power across the Greater Houston area.

Gov. Greg Abbott issued an emergency disaster declaration Sept. 13 for 17 Texas counties ahead of Tropical Storm Nicholas. (Courtesy office of Gov. Greg Abbott)
Gov. Abbott issues disaster declaration for 17 counties due to Tropical Storm Nicholas

The governor held a briefing where he also provided an update to the state’s response to the storm.

All Harris County residents should be sheltering indoors by 6 p.m., Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo urged during a press conference Sept. 13, as Tropical Storm Nicholas approaches the Texas Gulf Coast. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Hidalgo urges Harris County residents to stay indoors after 6 p.m. Sept. 13 as Tropical Storm Nicholas approaches

All Harris County residents should be sheltering indoors by 6 p.m., Judge Lina Hidalgo announced the afternoon of Sept. 13 as Tropical Storm Nicholas approaches the Texas Gulf Coast.

Kelsey-Seybold Clinic has announced it is closing all of its Houston-area locations due to the incoming Tropical Storm Nicholas. (Courtesy Kelsey-Seybold)
Kelsey-Seybold Clinic closes all Houston-area locations due to Tropical Storm Nicholas

Kelsey-Seybold Clinic has announced it is closing all of its Houston-area locations due to the incoming Tropical Storm Nicholas.

Following the passage of Hurricane Nicholas, Houston ISD officials announced all in-person and virtual classes will resume on Sept. 15. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
UPDATE: All Houston ISD classes to resume Sept. 15

All HISD buildings, schools, and offices will open on that day as well.