Houston ISD trustees ask district to appeal Wheatley High School rating

The Houston ISD board of education is asking the administration to appeal the state accountability rating for Wheatley High School.

The Houston ISD board of education is asking the administration to appeal the state accountability rating for Wheatley High School.

In a 7-1 vote, the Houston ISD board of education instructed the administration to appeal the state's accountability rating for Wheatley High School, whose results this year could require intervention by the Texas Education Agency.

The call came against repeated statements by HISD administrators at the Sept. 5 agenda review meeting that the district had searched for and exhausted all possible grounds for an effective appeal.

"We have looked very deeply and very closely at all the data for Wheatley ... since May," said Carla Stevens, assistant superintendent for research and accountability. "We can’t appeal if you don’t like the model. You can't appeal if we’re just really close."

Chapter 8 of the TEA's accountability manual reads: "requests for exceptions to the rules for a district, charter school, or campus are viewed unfavorably and will most likely be denied."

HISD officials said the state's policies on appeals suggest a rating would likely only be changed if data errors that occur on the state's side result in an inaccurate rating. But trustees said Hurricane Harvey, which allowed the district to receive a ratings reprieve last year, still had an effect on this year's calculations.

"For high schools in the current A to F rating system, half of your data each year is this year's data ... and then half of it is how your seniors did in the previous year in 2018," trustee Anne Sung said. "And if remember, in 2017-18 we had a hurricane here in Houston."

Wheatley High School, located in the Fifth Ward/Denver Harbor area of northeast Houston, has been closely watched as it has been unable to meet standards for seven consecutive years, according to the TEA.

On Sept. 3, TEA Commissioner Mike Morath formally notified the district and the board of education that under a state law that took effect in 2015, he was obligated to either order the campus to be closed or appoint a board of managers to replace the trustees.

"Appeals are data-driven and rule-driven, not emotion-driven. ... This appeal should not be filed for us, the grown ups, to not be taken over. It should be about student accountability," said trustee Jolanda Jones, the only vote against the measure.

Board President Diana Davila said the board has nothing to lose by filing an appeal.

"I don't understand what other sanction could possibly come," Davila said. "We're already at the end of the rope, as some would say it, so I'm not afraid to keep going if it has to be for kids."

The TEA letter stated that any appeals would be resolved by December, when the ratings become finalized. The deadline for an appeal to be considered by the TEA is 5 p.m. Sept. 13, and all appeals are considered by an independent review board, which recommends actions to the commissioner, according to the TEA.

The HISD board next meets Sept. 12.

The district declined to comment further on the appeals process.
SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

At the annual State of the County address Nov. 15, County Judge Lina Hidalgo spoke on several initiatives launched in 2019, including criminal justice reform and emergency recovery, among other topics. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Lina Hidalgo reflects on boundary-pushing first year in State of the County address

Early childhood development will be major focus of 2020, Hidalgo said.

River Oaks Baptist School expansion
Houston private schools experiencing enrollment, building boom

Private school Houston enrollment is growing, while national trends show declines.

Houston Private School Guide 2019: K-12 schools, tuition, enrollment, deadlines

Parents have a variety of education options beyond the public school system. This guide includes a list of area private schools as well as information to help parents make the best decision for their children. Would you like to suggest a school to include in our guide next year? Leave us a suggestion in the comments or send an email to hrmnews@communityimpact.com.

Meyergrove Apartments detention pond
Harris County Flood Control district buys former Meyerland apartment site for detention

After enduring multiple floods, the demolished Meyergrove Apartment property located at North Braeswood and I-610 could soon become a flood mitigation project in the Brays Bayou watershed.

Iora Primary Care continues expansion with Braeburn location

Health care provider Iora Primary Care opened a clinic at 6613 S. Braeswood Blvd., Houston, on Nov. 5, its sixth clinic in the Houston area.

Courtesy Memorial Hermann
Memorial Hermann opens urgent care clinic near West University

A Memorial Hermann Urgent Care clinic opened Nov. 13 at 3501 West Holcombe Blvd. near West University

McHugh Tea Room
McHugh Tea Room and Gifts: Business owner steeps Bellaire in tea culture and knowledge

Kim McHugh’s obsession with tea began with a concern for the health of her husband, who would drink multiple cups of tea a day.

Co-owners Sara Saber, left, and Carin Giga opened Three Dog Bakery in Rice Village in September 2018. (Alex Hosey/Community Impact Newspaper)
Three Dog Bakery: Pet-friendly store creates pastries and treats for furry friends

The display case at the front counter of Three Dog Bakery is filled with a variety of creatively designed and named cookies and cakes, though none of them are meant for people to eat.

Athleisure apparel brand Tasc Performance opens Rice Village popup

New Orleans-based athleisure and lifestyle clothing brand Tasc Performance opened a popup store in the Rice …

Houston Sichuan restaurant Pepper Twins charts two new locations

Sichuan-style Chinese restaurant Pepper Twins will open a location inside Houston’s Galleria, 5065 …

In a split 3-2 vote, the Harris County Commissioners Court passed a nonbinding resolution in favor of legislation requiring universal background checks for all Texas firearm sales, including those involving an unlicensed gun dealer and stranger-to-stranger gun sales, at its Nov. 12 meeting. (Courtesy Fotolia)
In split vote, Harris County approves resolution supporting universal background checks for all Texas firearm sales

The nonbinding resolution's passing demonstrated the court's support of legislation requiring universal background checks for all gun sales in the state, including those involving an unlicensed gun dealer and stranger-to-stranger gun sales.

Ahead of the Dec. 14 mayoral runoff election for the city of Houston, Harris County Clerk Diane Trautman announced plans Nov. 12 to move the county’s ballot box collection center to a more centralized location in hopes of expediting election result returns. (Emma Whalen/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County clerk to move ballot box collection center to centralized location in effort to expedite election result returns

Ahead of the Dec. 14 mayoral runoff election for the city of Houston, Harris County Clerk Diane Trautman announced plans Nov. 12 to move the county’s ballot box collection center to a more centralized location in hopes of expediting election result returns.

Back to top