Appeals court backs Houston's handling of drainage fee

A state district judge ruled against a class action lawsuit against Houston's drainage fee Oct. 18.

A state district judge ruled against a class action lawsuit against Houston's drainage fee Oct. 18.

Houston residents will not see a refund of drainage fees paid to the city since 2011, a state appellate judge ruled Oct. 18.

The fee, which is calculated based off of a property's impervious cover and added to city water bills, was approved by voters in 2010 and then reaffirmed in 2018. It has net about $600 million for the city since it was initiated, court records show.

The plaintiff, Elizabeth Perez, filed a class action lawsuit in 2015, alleging that the city's drainage fees were collected illegally and should be returned to taxpayers.

“Appellant Perez had (and continue to have) no choice but to continue paying the Illegal Rain Tax despite her belief, now proven true, that the Illegal Rain Tax, the Illegal Rain Tax Charter Amendment, and the Illegal Rain Tax Ordinance are each invalid and illegal,” the lawsuit states.

The state appeals court ruling vindicates the city, officials said.

“The Court’s decision makes clear that the City is and has been a careful steward of drainage fee revenue,” Mayor Sylvester Turner said. “Everyone at the City takes very seriously our responsibility to do all we can to prevent flooding and this decision, hopefully, will silence baseless claims about the City’s administration of the drainage fee."

A similar lawsuit against the city under Mayor Annise Parker’s administration in 2011 alleged that street and curb maintenance projects funded by the fee are not included of the state’s legal definition of drainage projects and that the wording of the ballot initiative was misleading, according to court records. The lawsuit, which Perez is also a part of, alleges that a city council decision in 2011 to tweak the definition of "curb and street" projects outlined in the ordinance that defines the fee's usage violated the approved ballot language.

The Texas Supreme Court ruled in favor of the plaintiff in 2015, but the ruling is now under review after an additional appeal from the city.

Community Impact Newspaper contacted Perez's lawyer to confirm whether she planned to file an appeal. He could not be reached as of press time.

 


MOST RECENT

COVID-19 patients now make up an estimated 43.4% of ICU patients in Harris County hospitals, up from 38.1% on July 3 and 25.5% on June 22.
As Harris County hospitalizations rise, COVID-19 patients now take up more than 40% of ICU beds

COVID-19 patients now make up an estimated 43.4% of ICU patients in Harris County hospitals, up from 38.1% on July 3 and 25.5% on June 22.

About 6,000 people are expected to attend the Texas Republican Convention at the  George R. Brown Convention Center on July 16-18. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Mayor Turner calls for cancelation, precautions ahead of Texas Republican Convention

The event is expected to draw 6,000 attendees to Houston's George R. Brown Convention Center.

Early voting is underway in Harris County. (Emma Whalen/Community Impact Newspaper)
DATA: More than 80,000 Harris County residents cast ballots in the first week of early voting

Early voting for the July 14 primary runoff election began June 29 after Gov. Greg Abbott postponed the original date due to the coronavirus pandemic.

Pharmacist Emily Smith opens a cooler for a patient to place their self-swab coronavirus test at a Walmart drive-thru testing site in McKinney on June 29. (Shelby Tauber/The Texas Tribune)
Poll says Texans' hopes for quick return to pre-coronavirus life are fading

Texans remain focused on the coronavirus pandemic and are less optimistic about returning the state to normal quickly, according to polling by the Texas Politics Project at the University of Texas.

Restriping work on South Rice Avenue is set to begin the week of July 6. Community Impact Staff
Bellaire South Rice Avenue restriping to begin week of July 6

The project will return the section of street to four lanes, along with parallel parking along the west side of the street.

Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller recently backed a movement calling for the reopening of winery and distillery tasting rooms and brewery and brewpub taprooms. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas Agriculture Commissioner joins voices calling for reopening of tasting rooms, taprooms

In a letter to Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller said demand from distilleries and breweries provides an important revenue stream to the state's farmers.

Bellaire and West University Place have so far managed to buck the trend, with higher sales tax revenue as compared to a year ago. (Courtesy Pexels)
Despite COVID-19, Bellaire and West University Place sales tax revenue is up year over year

Bellaire and West University Place have maintained sales tax revenue figures as compared to those from over a year ago, though declines are becoming noticeable.

Houston coronavirus testing
Coronavirus testing: Where to find testing sites in Houston the week of July 6

Here is the latest information on how and where to find coronavirus testing locations in Houston

George Floyd protest Houston
Defund or defend: After years of bolstering Houston police, city leaders consider paths to reform

After protests and forums, what will happen to promises of police reform?

New COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations and deaths all rose in Harris County from July 3-5.
Harris County coronavirus count: 2,489 new cases, 13 deaths confirmed over holiday weekend July 3-5

Active COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations hit all-time highs in Harris County on July 5.

Mayor Sylvester Turner issued a set of recommended social distancing guidelines June 2 that go beyond what is required by Gov. Greg Abbott. (Courtesy HTV)
Houston mayor recommends limit on gatherings over 10, businesses scale back to 25% capacity

The mayor is recommending businesses scale back to 25% and residents avoid gatherings of more than 10 people.

The First Street Foundation's dataset includes a forecast models that anticipate the effects of climate change and sea level rise. (Screenshot via First Street Foundation)
Analysis: FEMA may be undercounting national total flood risk by as much as 70%

The new dataset includes an interactive Flood Factor dashboard that anyone can use to assess the risk of flooding over a 30-year period for any address.