With final ruling looming, Harris County bail reforms shake system

Image description
With final ruling looming, bail reforms shake system
After a final hearing set for Oct. 28, a landmark settlement in Harris County could make bail reforms permanent and set the stage for similar changes across the country, including in Dallas, where a lawsuit is challenging bail for felony cases.

“It’s a huge change in how we do things. It’s hard to underestimate how dramatic this is,” said University of Houston law professor Sandra Thompson, who studies criminal justice reform. “You’re really talking about something affecting the vast majority of cases—thousands of people every year.”

In a preliminary ruling issued Sept. 5, Lee Rosenthal, the chief district judge of the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of Texas, affirmed the settlement and consent decree despite objections filed by District Attorney Kim Ogg, the Harris County Domestic Violence Coordinating Council and the Harris County Bondsmen Association. The fairness hearing Oct. 28 at the federal courthouse, 515 Rusk St., will be the last chance for the judge to weigh in on concerns.

While supporters hail the settlement as a watershed moment, opponents cite public safety concerns, conflicts with state law and the financial burden on taxpayers.

“It’s not very fair to victims,” Precinct 4 Commissioner Jack Cagle said.

The settlement will maintain reforms from 2017 that require the county to release misdemeanor defendants prior to trial as well as implement other initiatives. Misdemeanors include crimes such as drug possession, trespassing, theft and driving while intoxicated.

The reforms are already having a measurable effect: From 2015-18, the total number of misdemeanor and felony defendants released on personal bond jumped 371% and is continuing to grow this year, according to a report by Harris County Pretrial Services.

Under personal bonds, an arrestee does not have to post bail on the promise that they will appear in court.

Meanwhile, bail bond businesses are feeling the effects.

“We’re very barely hanging on, waiting to see what happens,” said Carolyn Campbell, the owner of Capital Bail Bonds, which has operated on Houston Avenue for over 30 years. She said business is down by 90% since the reforms began taking effect. “It’ll put most of us out of business for sure.”

Coming to a settlement

Three individuals charged with misdemeanors filed a lawsuit against Harris County in 2016, alleging it unfairly jailed misdemeanor defendants who could not afford bail.

The case came on the heels of a University of Pennsylvania study published that year, which analyzed over 380,000 misdemeanor cases in Harris County and found those who were detained pretrial were more likely to commit crimes later than those who were not.

In 2017, Rosenthal declared the county’s bail system unconstitutional. That same year, Harris County changed its bail practices to grant personal bonds for most misdemeanor arrestees, a policy known as Local Rule 9.

Prior to the reform, judges set bail according to the type of offense and other factors, such as prior convictions and how likely the defendant might commit new crimes. These bail levels could mean that someone with money could be released, while those in poverty remained in jail awaiting trial.

The rule change applies only to misdemeanors and excludes domestic violence, assault or second offenses for driving while intoxicated, and certain other offenses. It also excludes crimes committed after pretrial release.

Ogg and Cagle argued Local Rule 9 addresses the concerns in the original lawsuit and that the settlement—which requires the county to offer defendants rides to court and implement a text message system reminding them of their court dates—is unnecessary.

“The district attorney has no objection to a settlement approved by this court requiring and monitoring the continued enforcement of that rule,” Ogg wrote in her amicus brief, or written concern sent to court, filed Aug. 22. “The proposed settlement seeks relief far beyond the scope of the original controversy, however.”

In his preliminary ruling, Rosenthal also reminded all parties involved that any portion of the decree could be adjusted after it is implemented.

“Current or future officeholders may move to modify or terminate the decree ... if they think changes in circumstances warrant this relief,” Rosenthal wrote.

Day in court

Prior to the reform, poor arrestees would sometimes plead guilty to be released earlier—and face a criminal record, Thompson said, because they could neither post bail by paying the full amount nor by securing a bond, which usually entails paying a bonds company 10% of the bail on the promise that the arrestee will later appear in court.

That financial leverage meant there was a very high likelihood the arrestee would appear, said John McCluskey, the owner of Action Bail Bonds on Congress Avenue and a former president of the Professional Bondsmen of Texas.

“When we issue a bond, we get co-signers, friends, relatives—when you don’t show up, that’s who we start calling to track them down and make sure they show up in court,” he said. In his 35 years in the bond business, he said only around 1.5% of bonds sold resulted in a case in which the person could not be located. “The problem is, the county won’t have that leverage.”

The reform creates a new challenge: getting arrestees to appear in court without a bond as an incentive.

“You’re talking about releasing a lot of people who would otherwise sit in jail and would of course meet their court date,” Thompson said. But being in jail could render multiple “punishments” on an arrestee before a verdict is even reached, such as loss of employment, she said. “That sort of thing can really mess up a person’s life.”

In 2018, about 22% of misdemeanor defendants had their bonds revoked because of failure to appear for court, according to a Harris County Pretrial Services annual report. That figure was more than double the rate in 2014.

New measures in the settlement include open court hours—so if a defendant misses their scheduled appearance, they can show up during certain times to have their case processed. Another measure will allow defendants to waive their right to appear and allow a lawyer to speak on their behalf.

Both would allow people who cannot afford to take multiple days off to avoid legal penalties, Thompson said.

The decree requires the county to spend $250,000 per year in services to help arrestees make their court dates and to commit to a study to better understand the reasons dates are missed. After the study, the county must then spend $850,000 on solutions each year.

Meanwhile, bail reform could also alleviate overcrowding at the Harris County Jail, which houses more than 8,000 inmates on any given day, said Darryl Coleman, the chief of Harris County’s criminal justice command. According to data from the Texas Commission on Jail Standards, the average monthly number of people held in the Harris County Jail pretrial for misdemeanors dropped by about 40% from 2016-19.

Changes across the criminal justice system could take years to realize, said Precinct 1 Commissioner Rodney Ellis, who likened it to Brown v. Board of Education, the landmark 1954 Supreme Court civil rights case that led to racial integration of public schools.

“It took decades … maybe a century to put this system in place that has been ruled unconstitutional,” Ellis said at the July 30 Commissioners Court meeting. “We needed to make sure we were thoughtful in what we do to change it because you cannot dismantle a system like this overnight.”

Shawn Arrajj, Eva Vigh and Vanessa Holt contributed to this report.


Dozens of clinics throughout the county offer COVID-19 testing services. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
COVID-19 testing locations remain open in Montgomery County and more local news

Read the latest Houston-area business and community news.

Several local markets offer ways to support small businesses and artisans this holiday season. (Courtesy Pexels)
Check out these Small Business Saturday and holiday markets in Houston

Here are a few ways to support local businesses as the holiday shopping season kicks off.

Heading into Thanksgiving, Texas Medical Center continues to report uptick in hospitalizations

The total number of COVID-19 patients hospitalized at Texas Medical Center facilities has increased by more than 50% over two weeks.

The Harris County Justice Administration Department is working to release final reports and launch pilot programs in early 2021. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County Justice Administration Department makes headway on countywide criminal justice studies

The department is working to release the final versions of several studies and launch pilot programs with local law enforcement groups in early 2021.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced a COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan for the state Nov. 23 for a vaccine he said could be available as soon as December. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announces COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan

The vaccine could start being distributed "as early as next month," according to a Nov. 23 news release.

"Remember, we don't want to invite COVID-19 to the dinner table," Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner said at a Nov. 23 press conference urging caution amid rising COVID-19 positivity rates. (Screenshot via ABC13)
Mayor Sylvester Turner urges caution heading into Thanksgiving holiday

Houston officials also said 333 health providers had been identified as future vaccine delivery sites.

Houston's Rice Village will be bringing an inaugural farmers market beginning Dec. 6. (Courtesy Rice Village Management Company)
Rice Village announces bimonthly farmers market coming Dec. 6

The open-air market will include more than 40 hand-selected vendors.

protestor in crowd with who police the police sign
New report: Houston police oversight board lagging behind major Texas cities

The report suggested having no oversight board has a better effect on public trust than having a dysfunctional board.

A new building on the campus of the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston, is now open. (Courtesy Museum of Fine Arts, Houston)
New building now open at Museum of Fine Arts, Houston; free admission spots full

A new 100,000-square-foot building dedicated to exhibiting international collections of modern and contemporary art is now open at the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston.

Laura Colangelo
Q&A: Laura Colangelo discusses challenges facing private schools during pandemic

Colangelo said private schools have adapted to remote learning and other obstacles in 2020 despite less revenue and a 9% decline in enrollment statewide.

Shake Shack opened its new standalone location at The Woodlands Mall in November. (Courtesy Christine Han)
Shake Shack opens in The Woodlands Mall and more Houston-area updates

Read the latest business and community news from the Greater Houston area.