In Houston, development must think outside the flood plains, advocates say

Image description
Developers challenged to think outside flood plains
Image description
Developers challenged to think outside flood plains
Image description
Developers challenged to think outside flood plains
Image description
Developers challenged to think outside flood plains
Image description
Developers challenged to think outside flood plains
Editor’s note: This is part one of a series exploring efforts to make Houston a flood-resilient city. Find other coverage in this series at http://communityimpact.com/topics/flood-resilient-houston

As new development regulations in Houston attempt to offset the effects of more frequent heavy storms, some advocates and researchers say targeting the area’s urban sprawl will do more to reduce those at risk than limiting the amount of development in the city’s core.

“The 610 loop is the epicenter of the city of Houston so when we’re thinking about how we can make resiliency work for all Houstonians, how can these neighborhoods play their part?” Jordan Macha, director of advocacy group Bayou City Waterkeeper said. “There are going to be people that are moving into this area … so we’re trying to think through what that will look like while maintaining the integrity of these communities.”

New regulatory changes aimed at keeping these and other areas of the city safe include adjustments to flood plain boundaries, higher elevation requirements within flood plains and more significant detention requirements outside of flood plains.

City of Houston data shows over 25 drainage permits, many of which are subject to stricter city requirements, have been approved in and around the flood plains of Buffalo and White Oak Bayous since Hurricane Harvey.

Environmental researchers and advocates are struggling to agree on whether those regulations effectively address Houston’s flood risk while development continues to expand throughout the region, beyond Houston’s jurisdiction.

“I think it’s important to keep the bigger kind of regional or watershed perspective in mind and focus on the fact that it’s all interconnected system,” said Ryan Bare, a researcher specializing in low-impact development for The Houston Advanced Research Center.

Some advocates, including Sarah Bernhardt, President of the Bayou Preservation Association, said Hurricane Harvey spurred a turning point in collaboration between the city of Houston, Harris County, the Harris County Flood Control District, which takes charge of infrastructure projects, and other stakeholders.

“They’re moving as fast as their bureaucracy will allow them and I think that absolutely has to happen,” she said.

Mapping the risk

The main regulatory tool used by government agencies at all levels is the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s flood plain maps. Within some of the map’s boundaries, homeowners are required to buy flood insurance, and developers are subject to regulations depending on jurisdiction.

These maps are being updated by FEMA using new rainfall intensity data released by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Adjustments to the maps could take years to complete, according to the Greater Houston Flood Mitigation Consortium.

FEMA defines the 100- and 500-year flood plains as areas that are at greatest risk of flooding during rain events that have a 1% and 0.2% chance, respectively, of happening any year.

Both the Harris County Flood Control District and the city of Houston preemptively redefined their 500-year flood plains as 100-year flood plains. Now, structures within the former 500-year flood plain are subject to the regulations that applied to the 100-year flood plain, and regulations within the 100-year flood plain have tightened further, according to the HCFCD.

These changes do not account for the developments on the fringes of the current 500-year flood plain, of which several have been approved in the last two years, even though those boundaries could likely expand when FEMA releases its updated maps, said Shaun Theriot-Smith, a civil engineer with engineering consulting firm Big Red Dog.

After Harvey, a housing needs assessment from the city of Houston and the Houston Housing and Community Development Department found the 500-year flood plain had a higher percentage of households, which includes houses and individual apartment units, that flooded over 4 feet than those in the 100-year flood plain.

“We have too many people who are not in a safe location,” said Kyle Shelton, a Rice University researcher with the flood consortium. “There’s a tipping point between promoting development without impacting people’s safety, and we’re too far over.”

On top of that, mapping risk outside of traditional flood plain maps presents a challenge because there are many variables involved in any flooding event, such as blocked storm drains or heavier rainfall in some areas of the city than others, Theriot-Smith said.“There isn’t a good model out there that will show the drainage conveyance capacity. A lot of it is found out through firsthand experience or the community conveying that,” he said.

Higher standards

Elevation requirements are dictated within floodplains while detention regulations—which dictate how much water a site needs to store to reduce runoff speed—apply to developments outside of the flood plain as well. Under pre-Harvey regulations, developers could get a credit for the amount of detention that already existed on a site undergoing redevelopment. Under new regulations, detention requirements are determined by measuring what a site’s runoff would be if it was entirely undeveloped land, Theriot-Smith said. These changes have impacted how quickly developments get approved and how much they cost, Theriot-Smith said.

“I could say it easily increases a number of development’s detention costs by a factor of 100%,” he said. “It really depends on the existing site, before Sept. 1 some went from needing to connect to a sewer to having to add large concrete vaults. ... In some cases it’s a factor of much more than 100%.”

Within the flood plains stricter elevation and ground cover requirements are a subpar solution compared to eliminating new development in the 100-year flood plain all together, Shelton said.

“There’s a need to grapple with the form of growth and the scale of building that we allow,” Shelton said. “Availability of housing at low risk is not going to get any easier if we continue to develop in a way that increases the number of people in harm’s way.”

A wider view

Researchers, including Shelton, said approaching development regulations from a watershed level rather than a jurisdictional level would make it easier to manage stormwater runoff  across Houston and its suburbs and would reduce the strain downstream on bayous and tributaries. This approach also calls for more dense development on existing property rather than converting open land into new subdivisions.

“We need to be redeveloping decrepit commercial districts [outside of flood plains] that would be suitable for multi-use residential and commercial,” said Susan Chadwick, director of nonprofit Save Buffalo Bayou. “Look at all those strip malls all the way up North Shepherd.”

Moving water through the city more effectively relies on less development upstream as well as more green space surrounding the bayous’ flood plains. This could be aided by the Houston Parks Board’s Bayou Greenways 2020 initiative, which focuses on adding parks and trails along the city’s bayous.

“We’re not against development,” Chadwick said. “It should just be intelligent development.”

Editor's note: this post has been updated for clarity.
By Emma Whalen
Emma is Community Impact Newspaper's Houston City Hall reporter. Previously, she covered health care and public education in Austin.


MOST RECENT

Houston City Council could soon consider an ordinance to require all hotel and motel operators to adopt human trafficking prevention training for all of their employees. (Courtesy Pexels)
Proposed Houston ordinance would require anti-human trafficking training for all hotel workers

If adopted, Houston would be only the second city in the nation to adopt such a requirement.

All city of Houston parks are closed through Easter weekend to curb the spread of coronavirus. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Following Harris County, all city of Houston parks closed for Easter weekend, April 9-13

Mayor Turner said the decision was spurred by the fact the city of Houston reported 615 new positive coronavirus cases April 9, the highest jump to date.

As new resources become available for small business owners, there is hope for some small business owners. (Courtesy Pexels)
Small business owners: How are you getting through this? Have you applied for loans? Considering furloughs? We want to hear from you

Community Impact Newspaper is checking in with businesses to learn about their experience requesting and receiving aid, as well as other ways they are handling the economic fallout of the coronavirus outbreak.

The Harris County Homeless Outreach Team is providing homeless individuals with hand sanitizer, face masks and information sheets on the coronavirus. (Courtesy Harris County Sheriff's Office)
Harris County's Homeless Outreach Team spreads coronavirus awareness, distributes essential supplies to vulnerable populations

On the frontlines of one of the county’s most vulnerable populations, the Harris County Sheriff’s Office’s Homeless Outreach Team is spreading awareness and providing essential supplies to homeless populations amid the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

Affordable Counseling Collaborative Associates offers various kinds of therapy, including family and child therapy. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Houston-based Affordable Counseling Collaborative Associates offers online counseling during coronavirus outbreak

“We don’t come at them like, ‘We’re gonna tell you how to live your life,’” therapist Tracy Morris said. “It’s far more about helping them find the strength even when they feel like they don’t have any.”

The Texas Workforce Commission's phone and online systems have been overwhelmed as measures to slow the spread of the coronavirus continue to have a crippling effect on the economy. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
More Texans have filed for unemployment in past three weeks than in all of 2019

For the second week in a row, more than 6 million Americans filed for unemployment benefits, according to federal data.

Hospitals in the Greater Houston area are adapting to accommodate a surge of coronavirus cases. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Report offers first glimpse at hospital readiness across Houston area

Hospitals within the Texas Medical Center system in the Greater Houston area have plans in place to increase the number of ICU beds available by as much as 80%.

Dr. Campbell talks about the effect of the coronavirus on mental health.(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Q&A: Kelsey-Seybold doctor talks about mental health amid the coronavirus pandemic

Dr. Stefanie Campbell discusses the coronavirus’ effect on mental illness.

The Whole Foods market location at 701 Waugh Drive was cleaned and disinfected. Officials said the employee is at home on self-quarantine. (Courtesy Whole Foods)
ABC 13: Montrose Whole Foods employee has tested positive for COVID-19

The market, located at 701 Waugh Drive, was cleaned and disinfected. Officials said the team member is at home on self-quarantine.

Texas Central claims the $12 billion construction process would be privately funded, and the train would transport 6 million annual riders by 2029. (Courtesy Texas Central Partners/Community Impact Newspaper)
State legislators request federal officials halt activity on Texas Central's high-speed rail project

Dozens of elected officials representing Texas requested the U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao put an end to activity related to Texas Central’s high-speed rail project between Dallas and Houston.

The amicus brief is in support of an April 7 lawsuit filed by the Texas Democratic Party seeking legislative action to allow voters who fear exposure to the coronavirus to vote via mail-in ballot. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County Attorney's Office authorized to file amicus brief supporting mail-in ballots amid coronavirus outbreak

The amicus brief is in support of an April 7 lawsuit filed by the Texas Democratic Party seeking legislative action to allow voters who fear exposure to the coronavirus to vote via mail-in ballot.

Graphic by Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper
Harris County in ‘standoff’ over proposed inmate release to curb coronavirus spread

Hidalgo said the county is now at a crossroads having to weigh the lesser of two evils: releasing nonviolent inmates back into society or risking coronavirus spreading rampant through the county jail and filling the county’s hospital beds.