Updated: Appeals court blocks vote-by-mail expansion; Texas Supreme Court hears separate case

The ruling from federal Judge Fred Biery is the latest in the ongoing debate over whether access to mail ballots should be expanded in Texas during the coronavirus pandemic. (Courtesy Fotolia)
The ruling from federal Judge Fred Biery is the latest in the ongoing debate over whether access to mail ballots should be expanded in Texas during the coronavirus pandemic. (Courtesy Fotolia)

The ruling from federal Judge Fred Biery is the latest in the ongoing debate over whether access to mail ballots should be expanded in Texas during the coronavirus pandemic. (Courtesy Fotolia)

Updated 5 p.m. May 20

One day after a federal district judge ruled all Texas voters qualify for mail-in ballots during the coronavirus pandemic, a federal appeals court has put the ruling on temporary hold.

On May 19, Judge Fred Biery—presiding over a case in which the Texas Democratic Party and several Texas voters sued state officials, including Gov. Greg Abbott and Attorney General Ken Paxton—ruled that Texas could not deny voters access to mail ballots on the basis of age for elections that take place during the pandemic. Doing so would be a violation of the 26th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, Biery said.

On May 20, Paxton appealed the ruling, calling on the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals to issue a stay, which would prevent the ruling from taking effect during the appeal. Paxton also called for the ruling to be put on immediate hold while the appeals court considered his motion.

"Election officials will begin distributing mail-in ballots next week; time is of the essence," Paxton wrote in the appeal, stressing the urgency of his motion.


In his 73-page ruling, Biery had cited dangers posed by the coronavirus, ruling that a lack of immunity to COVID-19 constitutes a “physical condition” that would qualify a person for a mail ballot under the umbrella of “disability.”

“The evidence also shows voters are right to be fearful and anxious about the risk of transmission to their physical condition,” Biery wrote in a 73-page ruling. “Texas saw the largest single-day jump in coronavirus cases since the pandemic [May 16]. The Court finds such fear and anxiety is inextricably intertwined with voters' physical health. Such apprehension will limit citizens' rights to cast their votes in person. The Court also finds that lack of immunity from COVID- 19 is indeed a physical condition.”

Biery’s ruling came as local officials across the state are preparing for July 14 primary runoff elections. Typically, mail ballots are only available to Texans for one of four reasons: The voter is age 65 or older, has a disability, is a resident of Harris County but will not be able to vote in the county during the election, or is in jail but is otherwise eligible to vote.

Several lawsuits related to mail ballot access are also playing out in state courts, including another one in which Paxton is squaring off against the Texas Democratic Party and the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas over whether a lack of immunity to COVID-19 qualifies a voter for a mail ballot. After a lower court judge ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, the Texas Supreme Court stayed that ruling.

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments May 20 related to a petition for a writ of mandamus filed by Paxton last week. In his petition, Paxton asked judges to order election officials in five counties—Harris, Travis, Dallas, El Paso and Cameron—to follow his interpretation of the law.

Officials in the five targeted counties also filed briefs in the case, arguing what they are doing is within state law.

“Election officials in Harris County have not invited people to cower in their homes out of fear on election day,” the Harris County Attorney’s Office wrote in its brief. “They have advised them to vote by mail if they do not have immunity to a highly contagious disease that is likely to injure their health. Under the current circumstances—circumstances almost totally unique in Texas history—that is perfectly within state law.”

Tommy Buser-Clancy, a senior staff attorney with the ACLU of Texas, said he believes Paxton’s effort to take the case directly to the Texas Supreme Court was inappropriate and the proper remedy is to let it go through the appeals process. He said it is unclear at this point how all the different interlocking legal battles might play out.

“I think people think there’s a decent possibility that today’s case will resolve a lot of the statutory issues, but it is also very possible, and we think the right answer, for the court to not resolve them today because the case is improperly before it,” Buser-Clancy said in a May 20 phone interview. “I don’t think we’ll know until we read the court’s opinion.”
By Shawn Arrajj
Shawn Arrajj serves as the editor of the Cy-Fair edition of Community Impact Newspaper where he covers the Cy-Fair and Jersey Village communities. He mainly writes about development, transportation and issues in Harris County.


MOST RECENT

Harris County Emergency Services District No. 11 met Jan. 21 at its new administrative offices. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County Emergency Services District No. 11 lays groundwork for 911 dispatching plans

Cypress Creek EMS currently serves as a dispatch facility for 17 emergency agencies.

(Courtesy The Connection School of Houston)
A guide to Cy-Fair private schools in 2021

See extracurricular activities offered, current enrollment and tuition rates at local private schools.

The new salon specializes in manicures and pedicures as well as waxing and facials. (Courtesy King Nails Cypress)
King Nails Cypress plans grand opening on Hwy. 290

The new salon specializes in manicures and pedicures as well as waxing and facials.

Members of the Cy-Fair Fire Department Emergency Medical Services team respond to an accident on Brittmore Road in Cy-Fair on Jan. 8. (Courtesy Capt. Daniel Arizpe/Cy-Fair Fire Department)
New fund to benefit Cy-Fair firefighters, department members

"We want to be able to come in and do some work that needs to be done for these heroic people."

One local health system leader said he expects everyone, including those under age 65, will have access to the vaccine within the next 90 days. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Houston-area health system leaders talk progress, hurdles during COVID-19

Officials from CHI St. Luke’s Health and UTMB Health said community members must remain vigilant as case counts climb but that they expect the current surge to peak by early February.

During a North Houston Association meeting Jan. 20, Jazz Hamilton—first vice president with the Retail Brokerage Services Group for CBRE—discussed how the future of retail will likely be shaped by the conveniences to which consumers have become accustomed amid the coronavirus pandemic. (Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)
Pandemic-induced retail conveniences are here to stay, official says

According to Jazz Hamilton, first vice president with the Retail Brokerage Services group for CBRE, between January and November of 2020, consumers spent almost $550 billion online—a 33% increase from 2019.

The estimated number of active COVID-19 cases in Harris County has surpassed 50,000, reaching 51,362 as of the most recent data Jan. 20, according to the Harris County Public Health Department. (Community Impact staff)
Harris County coronavirus count: Active cases top 50,000

See the latest trends on COVID-19 in Harris County.

Bao Bros. Bistro opened on Hwy. 6 in October, offering steamed bao buns, boba tea and beer. (Courtesy Bao Bros. Bistro)
44 restaurants, cafes and other eateries that opened in Cy-Fair in 2020

From our January edition: See the new openings in the Cy-Fair area over the past year

Krab Kingz is now open in Cypress. (Courtesy Krab Kingz)
Krab Kingz opens Cypress storefront

Krab Kingz entered a soft opening phase Jan. 14 at 12640 Telge Road, Ste. D, Cypress.

In addition to vaccine hubs, there are also smaller community vaccine providers throughout Texas, such as pharmacies, that may also have the vaccine available. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
EXPLAINED: When, where and how Texans can receive the COVID-19 vaccine

As Texas is still in the early stages of rolling out the COVID-19 vaccine, many Texans are still unsure about where, when and how they can get inoculated.

The barbecue eatery is the second Killen's Restaurant Group venture to launch in The Woodlands area. (Courtesy Killen's Barbecue)
Killen's Barbecue opens in The Woodlands and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.