Montgomery ISD concludes hazing investigation; community still has concerns

The Montgomery ISD board of trustees delivered a statement around 11 p.m. Oct 15.

The Montgomery ISD board of trustees delivered a statement around 11 p.m. Oct 15.

Updated 9 a.m. Oct. 17: This story originally said the MISD board of trustees met Oct. 1 to discuss the incident. It has been updated to say the board was notified of the incident Oct. 1.

This story refers to the incident as an "alleged hazing incident" to be consistent with phrasing delivered by the Montgomery County Sheriff's Office and Montgomery ISD. Details of the incident have not and will not be released, school officials said. 

Montgomery ISD has concluded its investigation of the alleged hazing incident involving Montgomery High School football students. All necessary disciplinary actions have been taken, but details will not be released, according to the district.

The MISD board of trustees delivered a prepared statement at a regular board meeting Oct. 15.

"The board understands that the public wants and deserves answers. Unfortunately due to … [privacy] laws, we can’t divulge any information that would identify specific students or the punishments they may have received," board member Jim Dossey said, reading aloud the statement. "At this point, all necessary student punishments have been administered."

The campus investigation has drawn widespread concern and speculation across the community. Several parents and residents voiced concern over what they call a "culture of hazing" at MISD. Others expressed frustration at the lack of communication and answers from the district.

"I ask that you at least communicate with us, because it is very frustrating not to know what's going on," Jeanne Poulton, a mother of an MISD football student not involved in the incident, said at the Oct. 15 meeting. "[The rumors are] ... very frustrating. The rumors are probably the most nerve-wracking thing."


The incident occurred at an off-campus private residence and involved Montgomery High School football students, according to the district. According to the district, student reported there was a video of the conduct, but MISD police officers have not been able to obtain a copy of the video.

Details of the incident, such as how many students were involved and the nature of the conduct, have not and will not be released, according to the district.

Timeline of events

On Sept. 27, the MISD administration received an anonymous report through its hotline after school hours over a possible hazing incident involving MISD students, Dossey said at the Oct. 15 meeting.

"The district's investigation revealed that prior to the Sept. 27 report, no district employee or administrator had received a report of the type of conduct alleged to have occurred in the situation," Dossey said.

MISD police began a preliminary criminal investigation Sept. 30, including student interviews. Superintendent Beau Rees notified the board Oct. 1, Dossey said.

MISD concluded its portion of the investigation Oct. 4, transferring it over to the Montgomery County Sheriff's Office, according to the district. Detectives from the Montgomery County Sheriff's Office met with officers from the MISD police department to coordinate the transition of the investigation.

"Once the investigation is completed, it will be forwarded to the Montgomery County District Attorney’s Office as well as the Montgomery County Attorney’s Office for review. At this time, we have no further information to release," an Oct. 4 MISD news release stated.

MISD board members shared their thoughts on Facebook.

On Oct. 7, MISD announced that Montgomery High School’s home varsity football game scheduled for Oct. 11 was to be forfeited. This decision was reached because the district's views hazing perpetrators as those who engage in conduct as well as have knowledge of the incident and fail to report it, and to emphasize the district's zero-tolerance policy of hazing, Dossey said Oct. 15.

The Montgomery Sheriff's Office executed a search warrant Oct. 11, seizing cell phones for examination of the rumored video, according to a news release from the sheriff's office.

On Oct. 11, Montgomery County District Attorney Brett Ligon recused himself from the investigation "based on personal relationships" between himself and persons involved in the investigation, according to a news release from the district attorney's office.

MISD held a special meeting Oct. 11 at 8 a.m. regarding the incident. The board of trustees deliberated for nearly two hours in closed session before returning to open session and stating they would not be commenting on the incident until the next board meeting Oct. 15.

"At this point, we're going to hold off on further discussion. ... So this meeting is adjourned," Dossey said.

Parents and community members who were present at the meeting expressed concern and outrage over the announcement, saying they were expecting the board to provide answers.

At the Oct. 15 regular board meeting, the board of trustees went into closed session for about two hours.

The board then approved and delivered a public statement, which stated all necessary disciplinary actions have been taken.

Community response

At the Oct. 15 meeting and prior to when the board went into closed session, parents and residents expressed concern over how the investigation was being handled as well as how the incident resulted in the first place. In accordance with the Texas Open Meetings Act, the board of trustees was not legally allowed to respond to public comments.

MISD parent Diane May addressed the board and said she has seen multiple posts on social media from parents who allegedly said their child was bullied at MISD, and the perpetrators received no consequences. May said she believes there is a culture of bullying at the district.

"I also was really impacted by reading the countless comments [on online platforms] regarding the culture ... [in our community]," May said. "I think what has become clear is that this situation that's happening right here in Montgomery right now [implies] ... a much larger problem."

May continued to say that bullying and hazing can have long-lasting effects on victims, and she said she hopes MISD will provide a better platform for victims to have a voice.

"I really hope the schools and administration can review the current guidelines regarding bullying and hazing and provide education where education is needed, and I mean all the way from students to the top. I hope that we can review reporting procedures," she said. "Finally, I ask the board to examine, address and deconstruct the culture that perpetuates hazing and bullying in our community."

One speaker, Gregory McNelly, shared his thoughts on what he called a "culture of hazing" at the district.

"I want to know, what leadership actions are being taken?" McNelly said. "It's important to consider this is not a single action or a single person; there's a culture in place that allowed this to happen that needs to be addressed from the leadership down."

Poulton said she does not blame the administration for the incident but also feels the district should not have punished the rest of the football team. Poulton recounted an incident where her daughter was physically injured and bullied at MISD.

"By no means did I blame the classroom as a whole, because it's kind of silly to lump everybody into something," she said. "I don't understand how we punish them as a whole."

Poulton said she is concerned her son's future, such as scholarship opportunities, might be jeopardized.

Bill Chilcoat, a former special needs teacher, said he does not blame the district but urged board members to be an advocate for students and to "step up and lead."

"We need to be aggressively accepting our roles as leaders in this community for our school district and setting a standard of holding everyone that works for you [accountable]," he said. "We need to make sure that everything is getting done properly [and we are] communicating efficiently and effectively."
By Eva Vigh
Eva Vigh joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2018 as a reporter for Spring and Klein. Prior to this position, she covered upstream oil and gas news for a drilling contractors' association.


America's ER operated a drive-thru testing site in The Woodlands in mid-April, which later moved to WoodsEdge Community Church. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
America's ER to move to COVID-19 testing by appointment June 8 at Cypress, Magnolia facilities; large-scale testing site closes June 4

While the drive-thru testing site will close permanently June 4, testing will still be available by appointment beginning June 6 at America's ER facilities in Cypress and Magnolia, officials said in a June 2 statement.

(Adriana Rezal/Community Impact Newspaper)
PHOTOS: Scenes from the downtown Houston march for George Floyd

People of all ages, colors and creeds packed downtown Houston June 2 to march in memory of former Houston resident George Floyd.

Smartphone data analysis by Cuebiq shows how Montgomery County residents' mobility habits changed throughout this spring. (April Halpin/Community Impact Newspaper)
DATA: See how Montgomery County residents' mobility changed through stay-at-home orders, economic reopening

Cell phone location data analysis from tracked by Cuebiq shows how resident travel patterns changed through the COVID-19 pandemic.

Nola Z. Valente/Community Impact Newspaper
60,000 gather in downtown Houston June 2 in solidarity with George Floyd's family

Among a series of marches across the U.S. to honor George Floyd, his hometown of Houston turned out in the thousands June 2.

Montgomery County's total coronavirus cases now total 1,010, a jump of 44 from June 1. (Community Impact staff)
Montgomery County breaches 1,000 total coronavirus cases June 2

Montgomery County's total coronavirus cases now total 1,010, a jump of 44 from June 1.

The Montgomery County Hospital District is urging residents to come to the hospital for medical treatment. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Montgomery County sees 30% increase in out-of-hospital deaths, officials say

“We are hearing the same frightening story from our paramedics over and over again,” said James Campbell, MCHD Chief of EMS. “People refusing to go to the hospital because they are scared of COVID-19. So, this is our message to the community and our neighbors here in Montgomery County: It is safe to go to the hospital.”

The flyer with information on George Floyd's Houston-area services was released June 2. (Courtesy Fort Bend Memorial Planning Center)
JUST IN: George Floyd visitation, funeral scheduled for June 8-9 in Houston area

A public memorial will take place June 8 at The Fountain of Praise church from noon-6 p.m.

The June 2 march will culminate with a rally at the steps of Houston City Hall. (Courtesy city of Houston)
Houston city buildings, some METRO services planned to shut down ahead of June 2 march for George Floyd

Ahead of the June 2 march with members of George Floyd's family through downtown Houston, several city services are planning to shut down early in the afternoon.

Businesses shuttering their doors due to coronavirus restrictions lowered the sales tax revenue collected by cities in May compared to May 2019. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas comptroller reports 13.2% year-over-year state sales tax revenue drop in May

Tax collection revenue fell significantly in several sectors from May 2019 to May 2020, according to the comptroller's office.

The Margaritaville resort on Lake Conroe will be the franchise's first location in Texas. (Courtesy Storyteller Communications)
Margaritaville moves Lake Conroe opening date up to June 26

The 186-acre location will feature an 18-hole golf course, two restaurants, a water park, boating, fishing and other lake activities.

Montgomery County commissioners met June 1 for a special session in Conroe. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Montgomery County commissioners greenlight $500 economic stimulus proposal

Application are due between July 1 and Aug. 1. Online and in-person application information will be posted when information becomes available.

Montgomery County reported 12 new COVID-19 cases since May 29. (Community Impact staff)
Montgomery County COVID-19 recoveries increase June 1; 12 new cases reported since May 29

County health officials reported a total of 484 COVID-19 recoveries as of June 1, while 456 cases remain active.