Montgomery County Forensic Services, local forensic lab identify deceased man from 2016 case

David Mittelman (left) is the founder of Othram, a private forensic laboratory in The Woodlands. (Courtesy Othram)
David Mittelman (left) is the founder of Othram, a private forensic laboratory in The Woodlands. (Courtesy Othram)

David Mittelman (left) is the founder of Othram, a private forensic laboratory in The Woodlands. (Courtesy Othram)

For over four years, the body of a man found in a reservoir in The Woodlands remained unidentified.

The body, which was found by kayakers in October 2016, was not visually recognizable and had no identification in his belongings, said Dr. Kathryn Pinneri, director of Montgomery County Forensic Services.

Forensics services attempted to identify the man using fingerprints, dental records and DNA. The department ran press releases with pictures of his belongings and uploaded the information to a national database, the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System, known as NamUs.

Nothing generated leads.

The case sat for four years, becoming one of the estimated 40,000 sets of human remains that are unidentified in the U.S., according to NamUs.


But the mystery of the unnamed man never grew cold, and eventually, it spurred a partnership between the county forensic services and a forensics lab in The Woodlands called Othram, located near the intersection of Research Forest Drive and Gosling Road.

In late 2020, Montgomery County Forensic Services contacted Othram. The two entities had discussed collaborating in the past, and the unidentified man found by kayakers seemed like the perfect case to try to solve, Pinneri said.

Othram has a track record of solving hard-to-crack cases, including those that have sat for decades, such as the 1966 drowning of young woman in Pecos, founder David Mittelman said. They use a technology called forensic-grade genome sequencing that takes DNA data to construct a new genealogical profile, which can be used to find potential genetic relatives.

It was the first time Montgomery County Forensic Services employed the help of the technology, and the results would be fruitful. The collaboration produced a new lead that would eventually give a name to the unidentified man: James Edward St. Peters.

“We’ll do what it takes,” Pinneri said. “The decedent deserves it, and so do the ones they left behind.”

The county forensic services successfully identified all other decedents at its facility through other means, but Pinneri said the department will use Othram’s service again if needed.

Traditionally, forensic evidence is uploaded into the Combined DNA Index System, or CODIS, a national database run by the FBI, Mittelman said. CODIS collects 20 markers from DNA to construct a profile, and it can be used to match persons if their DNA or a close relative’s DNA is in the system.

For instance, if someone committed a crime in Houston and then went on to commit a crime in Dallas and got caught, their DNA could be matched to the crime in Houston.

But there are limitations.

“[It’s] not good if you are not in the database,” Mittelman said. “If you’re not a criminal, it’s hard to find you.”

That is why it is not surprising the DNA of Edwards St. Peters—known for years as John Doe—did not turn up results, he said.

When CODIS fails, that is where Othram steps in, Mittelman said. The technology Othram uses takes thousands of markers from DNA to reconstruct a genealogical profile that can be used to identify distant relatives of the deceased, not just close relatives.

“Instead of 20 markers, [we are] pulling tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of markers, and from that we can kind of reconstruct a lot of information [on] ... distant relatives,” he said.

Othram also uses KinSNP, a service that conducts rapid familial relationship testing. For The Woodlands case, scientists at Othram worked from distant genetic matches—beyond second cousin—through Mennonite and French-Canadian familial records, producing a new lead for investigators.

Cracking cases, especially one so close to home, is rewarding, Mittelman said. But solving cases such as The Woodlands John Doe should be considered the expectation, not a lucky break; the technology is there, and now it needs to scale up, he said.

“At bare minimum, we want to make sure this becomes a standard tool,” he said.

To browse law enforcement cases that are in need of funding, are funded or are solved, or to donate your DNA to help solve cases, visit www.dnasolves.com.
By Eva Vigh
Eva Vigh joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2018 as a reporter for Spring and Klein. Prior to this position, she covered upstream oil and gas news for a drilling contractors' association.


MOST RECENT

Emerging technology and alternative energy sectors could help ease the blow of an oil and gas industry downturn in Houston caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, a Houston-area economist said. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Greater Houston area could see economic relief from pandemic around mid-2021, economist says

Emerging technology and alternative-energy sectors could help ease the blow of the downturn in Houston's oil and gas industry caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Montgomery ISD trustees adopted a resolution calling for the state to prioritize school district employees in the COVID-19 vaccine distribution process, according to a release from the district. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Montgomery ISD trustees urge state to prioritize educators in vaccine distribution

"Since day one of this challenging school year, our teachers and school district staff have been heroes for our students,” Board President Matt Fuller said in the release.

Montgomery County Judge Mark Keough addressed his guilty plea in a Feb. 24 Facebook video. (Screenshot via Mark Keough Facebook)
Montgomery County Judge Mark Keough pleads guilty to DWI charge in September crash

According to a Feb. 24 court filing, Keough's plea bargain terms include fines and a three-month driver's license suspension.

Conroe ISD board of trustees President Skeeter Hubert presented a resolution supporting priority vaccinations for Texas teachers during the Feb. 23 meeting. (Screenshot via Conroe ISD YouTube)
Conroe ISD board discusses incentive program plans, support for teacher vaccinations Feb. 23

Board members also approved several construction and purchasing items during the regular meeting.

Excessive groundwater use from aquifers can lead to subsidence, or sinking of the earth, which can exacerbate the activity of fault lines. Fault lines criss-cross Montgomery County, including this one at the corner of Sgt. Ed. Holcomb Blvd. N. and Hwy. 105 in Conroe. (Eva Vigh, Community Impact Newspaper)
As ground sinks, debate ensues over Montgomery County's groundwater

Excessive groundwater use can lead to subsidence, or sinkng of the earth. Officials disagree on how much groundwater the county should pump.

Volunteers from the food bank distribute clean drinking water. (Courtesy Montgomery County Food Bank)
Montgomery County Food Bank aids over 6,500 during Winter Storm Uri

The food bank is in need of donations and volunteers following the winter storm.

Following a yearlong hiatus due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, Six Flags Hurricane Harbor Splashtown officials are planning to reopen the Spring water park for the 2021 season May 1. (Courtesy Six Flags Hurricane Harbor Splashtown)
Six Flags Hurricane Harbor Splashtown targets May 1 opening

2021 also marks the 60th anniversary of Six Flags Entertainment Corp.

Applications for up to $250 in assistance will be available until Feb. 26. (Andrew Christman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Lone Star College System announces financial aid for students, faculty affected by winter storm

Applications for financial assistance will be accepted until Feb. 26.

Conroe ISD Superintendent Curtis Null spoke during a Feb. 21 livestream about the district's status following the winter storm. (Screenshot via Conroe ISD YouTube)
Conroe, Montgomery, Willis ISDs assessing damages following winter storm

Districts reported burst pipes and flooding on various campuses.

Jason Millsaps, chief of staff for County Judge Mark Keough, addresses questions regarding the operations at Woodforest Bank Stadium. (Screenshot via Montgomery County livestream)
Montgomery County to take over Woodforest Stadium vaccinations in March at cost of $130K per month

The county is looking to consolidate operations to Woodforest Bank Stadium beginning March 1.

The Cargo Homes include a private front porch area. (Courtesy Happy Goat Retreat)
Happy Goat Retreat, a luxury outdoor resort, eyes summer opening in Willis

The venue will include a communal fire pit and an animal pen area with American pygmy goats and a llama.