‘Find the money somewhere else’: Woodlands Water Agency votes to not pay anticipated SJRA rate increases related to legal fees, uncollected revenue

Lawsuits over surface water in Lake Conroe have led to increased water rates. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Lawsuits over surface water in Lake Conroe have led to increased water rates. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)

Lawsuits over surface water in Lake Conroe have led to increased water rates. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)

The Woodlands Water Agency, the managing body for the 11 municipal utility districts in The Woodlands, has sent a clear message: The Woodlands residents should not have to pay for the legal fees and uncollected revenue of other entities.

At its May 13 meeting, the board voted to direct its Woodlands Groundwater Reduction Plan representative to vote to not pay for anticipated increased San Jacinto River Authority surface water rates related to legal fees or budget shortfalls due to other entities not paying their share.

Prior to the vote, SJRA’s Deputy General Manager Ron Kelling outlined four potential rate scenarios based on the outcomes of legal scenarios. Depending on how lawsuits pan out, rates could increase next fiscal year by between 0.4% to 14.5%. The rates will be set May 26 by the SJRA GRP committee and approved, along with the fiscal year 2020-21 budget, by the SJRA board June 22.

A significant portion of the rate increase hinges on the city of Conroe. In 2016, the cities of Conroe and Magnolia refused to pay for the increased rates, deeming them an unfair burden to residents. According to the SJRA, these cities owe a total of $4.78 million and $252,397, respectively, as of March 31.

Quadvest, a private utility company, has also sued the SJRA on the grounds the entity is monopolizing surface water resources in the area and has set costly and unjust rates. Quadvest has filed for a temporary injunction from having to pay GRP fees while its lawsuits are going on, Kelling said.

When entities do not pay the current GRP rates, the cost burden falls on other GRP participants, SJRA officials said. SJRA officials said they anticipate expenses to increase as they have spent $1.5 million on legal fees within its GRP division thus far and anticipate an additional $2.5 million by the end of FY 2020-21.

But officials with the Woodlands Water Agency said they cannot support passing these costs onto residents.

“The 3.7% [increase], ... we’d just look our community in the eye and say that’s fair and reasonable,” WWA President Eric Heard said, referring to the second rate scenario SJRA outlined. “I will say though, Scenario C, where we ask our residents to pay 14.5% increase, probably not truly workable for a number of reasons. And really more than anything it reflects a breakdown from what we bargained for in the agreement.”

Board members agreed the rate increases should reflect operating expenses, not legal fees and costs associated with entities not paying up-to-date rates.

“SJRA has to find another way to pay for these lawsuits,” trustee Arthur Bredehoft said. “Quadvest is not our issue, and the suit with Conroe and Magnolia is not our issue as we are meeting our contractual obligation. And why should the residents of the Woodlands pay for lawsuits and nonpayment by two parties in the contract?”

Kelling said he had anticipated the 14.5% rate increase scenario was unrealistic, which is why he had come up with a fourth scenario, which involves reducing production at the surface water plant.

“I still think your Scenario D at 8.5% is still not workable,” Heard said. “That is basically a 10% increase, and that is because other participants aren’t paying. I think you’re just going to have to find the money somewhere else.”

Kelling said the only option the SJRA would have is to draw from its debt service reserve, which currently holds $34 million. The SJRA is required to have at least a year's worth of debt service payments in its debt service reserves.

“The GRP is its own separate enterprise, so the only money that the SJRA GRP has to take is what is sitting in the GRP,” Kelling said. “When you’re saying find some other place to take the legal fee, if it isn’t coming in from rates ... or reserves... there is no place to pull money from. If we’re not allowed to use the rates to pay for the legal fees or to pay for the uncollected revenue, the only place to pull it from would be the debt service reserve.”

The board unanimously voted to direct its GRP representative to vote to not pay for rate increases related to legal fees or uncollected revenue. Any other options of legal nature related to the contracts will need to be discussed in future closed sessions, officials said.
By Eva Vigh
Eva Vigh joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2018 as a reporter for Spring and Klein. Prior to this position, she covered upstream oil and gas news for a drilling contractors' association.


Riva Row Boat House
GALLERY: Restrictions in Montgomery County easing, but residents remain cautious

Click through this photo gallery to see how residents are slowly adapting to life during a pandemic.

Conroe ISD will distribute meals until the end of June. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Conroe ISD to continue meal distributions through June

The district will offer meal pickups Tuesdays and Thursdays from 10 a.m.-noon through June.

Lone Star College plans to partially open 26 buildings beginning June 1. (Andrew Christman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Lone Star College System discusses reopening plan for June 1

Lone Star College plans to partially open 26 of its buildings June 1, prioritizing health science buildings.

Outdoor venues in all Texas counties will be permitted to operate at up to 25% capacity starting May 31. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Spectators to be welcomed back to Texas outdoor sporting events May 31 at 25% of venue capacity

Venue owners must operate under guidelines that facilitate appropriate social distancing.

Montgomery County has more physicians and registered nurses per 100,000 residents than the nearby Harris County. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Health Care Snapshot 2020: Montgomery County improves state ranking for number of physicians, registered nurses

Montgomery County has more physicians and registered nurses per 100,000 residents than nearby Harris County, according to 2019 data from Texas Health and Human Services.

In terms of county health in 2020, Montgomery County ranked among the top 15 on length of life and quality of life.
Health Care Snapshot 2020: Montgomery County ranks in top 10 in Texas for health outcomes

In 2020 county health rankings, Montgomery County ranked among the top 15 counties in Texas in the length of life and quality of life categories.

A homestead exemption removes part of the value of a property from taxation and lowers taxes. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Conroe City Council approves 2.5% homestead exemption, saving owners of $100,000 homes $10.93 per year

Under a 20% homestead exemption, the city could lose a little over $3 million per year. Under a 2.5% exemption, the city could see a loss of $437,000 per year.

Volunteers pack boxes of food at the Montgomery County Food Bank. (Courtesy Montgomery County Food Bank)
Montgomery County nonprofits receive $235,000 through Greater Houston COVID-19 Recovery Fund

The funding was part of an $8.2 million distribution to dozens of nonprofits in the region announced May 28.

Students enrolled in the University of Houston College of Nursing can take classes at the Sugar Land campus. (Claire Shoop/Community Impact Newspaper)
Q&A: UH College of Nursing dean reflects on how coronavirus has affected education, profession

Kathryn Tart, dean of the University of Houston’s College of Nursing, spoke with Community Impact Newspaper about how the novel coronavirus is changing the way the university is educating nursing students.

Houston Methodist researchers conducted a 25-patient trial in March and April to examine the safety of convalescent plasma transfusions as a possible treatment for COVID-19. (Courtesy Houston Methodist)
Greater Houston-area health systems examine plasma transfusion as possible COVID-19 treatment

The experimental therapy involves the transfer of plasma from recovered COVID-19 patients to those who are currently symptomatic.

Each eligible child will receive $285 in benefits. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Some Texas students eligible for one-time federal benefit to aid with food purchases

Texas received approval from the U.S. Department of Agriculture to provide more than $1 billion in pandemic food benefits.