UPDATED: Montgomery County backs down on proposal to offer $500 stimulus checks to county residents

The plan, which was proposed by Commissioner James Noack, would have provided stimulus checks to all Montgomery County individuals and entities with 2019 property tax filings using a portion of the county’s nearly $105 million in federal funding. (Courtesy Fotolia)
The plan, which was proposed by Commissioner James Noack, would have provided stimulus checks to all Montgomery County individuals and entities with 2019 property tax filings using a portion of the county’s nearly $105 million in federal funding. (Courtesy Fotolia)

The plan, which was proposed by Commissioner James Noack, would have provided stimulus checks to all Montgomery County individuals and entities with 2019 property tax filings using a portion of the county’s nearly $105 million in federal funding. (Courtesy Fotolia)

Editor's note: This story's headline originally said the proposal was halted by the U.S. Treasury. The headline was changed based on new information received. In addition, the story has also been updated to include more comments from county officials and other sources.

On June 1, Montgomery County commissioners unanimously approved a plan to provide $500 stimulus checks to Montgomery County homesteaders for COVID-19 relief, and commissioners said it needed final approval by the U.S. Department of Treasury.

The plan, which was proposed by Precinct 3 Commissioner James Noack, would have used about $65 million of the nearly $105 million the county received in funding from the federal Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act.

On Aug. 24, the office of Precinct 3 released a statement which said that the Treasury showed a "lack of commitment" to provide written approval, and the Commissioners Court opted to not move forward with the plan. County officials said they were concerned the proposed $65 million in stimulus checks would be subject to the federal coronavirus relief package's clawback provision. The clawback provision states that if dollars are spent outside the scope of the intended use of the funds, local governments are responsible for repaying them.

"The county would be on the hook for millions of dollars, so we would have to raise taxes or figure out another way to pay back potentially $65 million," Precinct 3 Chief of Staff Evan Besong said.

However, some legal experts said Montgomery County officials should never have expected approval from the U.S. Treasury, and residents said the county was not transparent throughout the process.

"That's not the way it works," said Tenley Carp, a governmental contracts attorney for Arnall Golden Gregory, a law firm. "There's absolutely no process—there's no concept even—of Montgomery County requesting approval from the Department of Treasury."

County seeks clarification

Although commissioners approved the proposal June 1, county officials sought clarification from the Treasury after its approval for assurance the county would not be subject to a clawback.

On June 15 and 18, County Attorney B.D. Griffin penned three letters to Kevin Brady, R-The Woodlands, U.S. Sen. John Cornyn and U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz seeking to obtain a preliminary opinion that the newly approved program would be eligible for CARES funds. The U.S. Treasury specifies that CARES funds can only be used for expenditures specifically incurred due to the coronavirus pandemic and that they must be used by Dec. 31.

Griffin said in an email that he did not send a letter directly to the Treasury because he was informed the Treasury was working through U.S. representatives and senators.

In his letter, Griffin said the proposal is intended to address the "second order effects" of COVID-19 to aid those suffering from financial loss as well as to prevent foreclosures and evictions. But Griffin said he was worried about potential recoupment.

"It would be of great benefit if Treasury identifies any deficiencies that create ineligibility and/or suggests modifications," he wrote. "The potential risk and exposure of county for recoupment makes the county hesitant to expend such a significant amount of funds in relation the County's future budgets absent some preliminary determination for the U.S. Department of the Treasury."

County officials said it was not clear if the proposal qualified for the use of CARES funds and that they did not wish to proceed with the proposal before receiving confirmation in writing from the U.S. Department of Treasury, which never happened.

Noack said he was frustrated with the Treasury's lack of written confirmation and felt the process was bureaucratic.

"Everybody thought we would be able to get the Treasury to sign off on this. It's really unfortunate," he said, adding that he simply wanted to give money back to the people.

Noack reportedly had one phone call with the Treasury and was told to "go back and read our guidelines," he said. Treasury officials also reportedly said residents would need to show proof that they were affected by COVID-19, he added.

When asked if his proposal was presented to the public prematurely and if in hindsight he would have waited for further guidance, Noack said he was being transparent by publicly sharing what the county intended to do with its CARES funding.

"I needed to put this on the agenda and have a public meeting ... before we could even vet it to the U.S. Treasury," he added, referring to the Texas Open Meetings Act. "There was no way we could have sought their approval for a program that wasn't approved by the court."

Treasury officials did not provide a comment for publication.

Understanding the rules

Carp, who is based in Washington D.C., has experience negotiating governmental contracts and has been working daily with issues related to CARES funding. Carp said following up with the Treasury for approval of a proposal is not the correct process, and state and local governments are responsible for making their own determinations as to how to spend their money consistent with the guidelines.

"When the county decides what they want to do with the money, it is not necessary or even part of the process to submit their proposed expenditures to the Treasury," she said. "The Treasury would be overwhelmed trying to answer yes or no to proposals from state and local governments."

Carp said CARES funding is clearly allocated for expenditures incurred due to the public health emergency, and the only way a stimulus payment might qualify is if individuals who applied were to show direct impact from COVID-19, such as an eviction or foreclosure due to closing their business because of the pandemic.

"The stimulus payment is not at all what these funds are to be used for. It's very clear," she said. "Montgomery County has to understand the guidance for what they can and cannot do with that CARES Act money."

David Reischer, attorney and CEO of LegalAdvice.com, echoed Carp's response.

"The CARES Act specifically requires that there is a verification of income eligibility or income loss for each participant before the distribution of funds," he said.

Delayed communication

Email records and conversations with county residents indicate the county may have decided to backtrack on its proposal at least a few weeks prior to the Aug. 24 announcement.

In a July 30 email forwarded to Community Impact Newspaper, Cody Grimes, a representative of Noack's office, informed resident Maxine Shields that "the U.S. Treasury has no plans to approve the proposed $500 stimulus in writing. Therefore, we are being forced to look at other options."

Nearly 70 residents responded to a Nextdoor post in mid-August voicing their experiences and concerns with the county's plan. Some said they were told by the county that the Treasury had denied the proposal. Others said they were checking the website weekly, waiting for applications to open.

"I called [Noack's office]. I was informed by his office that there would not be any checks since approval has not been received because it was not listed correctly; however, they are trying to see if there are any other avenues where we would receive something," county resident Bertha Murphy said in an Aug. 17 email.

Sara Clayton, a Spring resident, said she was repeatedly emailing the Precinct 3 office asking for updates but received several different answers.

Many others said they felt frustrated by the county's lack of transparency and communication as they struggled to understand when applications would open, what the status of the proposal was and when they may receive their checks.

"I have been praying this would be approved," Montgomery County resident Dorothy Peterson said in an email. "I realize to some, it's a very small amount, but to the elderly, it means survival. I have been plagued with high water
bills, high electricity bills, auto expenses. ... The $500, I was counting on to recoup, but I guess it's not going to happen."
By Eva Vigh
Eva Vigh joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2018 as a reporter for Spring and Klein. Prior to this position, she covered upstream oil and gas news for a drilling contractors' association.


Bocca Italian Kitchen serves seasonal, Italian-inspired dishes, such as polenta and various pastas. (Courtesy Marco Torres)
Italian eateries open in Generation Park; Houston bike lane fines enforced and more local news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

The independent pharmacy went through 500 doses of the Moderna vaccine in nine days. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
Magnolia Pharmacy aims to open volunteer-run COVID-19 vaccine clinic Jan. 22

If everything goes according to plan, the clinic could administer 200-400 doses per day to those who qualify, regardless of their county of residency.

Officials expect demand for the vaccine will be huge once it opens to the general public. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Montgomery County plans vaccine distribution; FDA warns of false negatives and more top Houston-area news

Read the most popular stories from the past week from the Houston area.

Hundreds of positive COVID-19 case reports among Conroe ISD students and employees have been recorded so far this year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Conroe ISD sees COVID-19 case reports climb with second semester underway

Hundreds of positive case reports have been logged by the district since the start of 2021.

Work on Memorial Hermann The Woodlands Medical Center includes the construction of a new patient tower and parking area. (Courtesy Memorial Hermann The Woodlands Medical Center)
Memorial Hermann The Woodlands Medical Center on track to complete $250M expansion in 2022

Since July, the construction team has put in 100,000 work hours and poured more than 8,500 cubic yards of concrtete.

The new plant was completed ahead of schedule. (Courtesy Entergy Texas)
Entergy Texas power station in Montgomery County achieves commercial operation

The plant, located in Willis, was originally slated to come online in the middle of this year.

Commissioner James Metts speaks in support of creating two courts at law for Montgomery County. (Screenshot via Montgomery County livestream)
Montgomery County commissioners begin discussion to add 2 courts in 2021

Montgomery County commissioners wish to gather more information about court needs before approving at least one court at law.

De'ja Vu Beautiful Consignments held a grand opening at 13080 Hwy. 105, Conroe, on Jan. 9. (Courtesy De'ja Vu Beatiful Consignments)
New health care facilities open in the Conroe, Montgomery area and other recent business news

Two health care facilities opened in the Conroe, Montgomery area at the start of the new year, along with other business openings.

A prescribed burning on the W.G. Jones State Forest along FM 1488 is scheduled for Jan. 14-15, weather permitting. (Courtesy Texas A&M Forest Service)
Prescribed burning of W.G. Jones State Forest scheduled for Jan. 14-15

As a result of the burning operations, certain areas of the forest will be closed to the public during this time.

Despite a global pandemic, Houston home sales broke records in 2020 and saw 10% more sales overall compared to 2019. (Courtesy Houston Association of Realtors)
Report: Houston home sales surpassed 2019 volumes despite pandemic

2020 single-family home sales surpassed 2019’s volume by more than 10%.

La Cocina de Roberto launched its second eatery in The Woodlands area in January. (Courtesy La Cocina de Roberto)
La Cocina de Roberto restaurant opens in The Woodlands and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Greater Houston area.

From Jan. 19-29, Coalition for the Homeless and staff from The Way Home will conduct the 2021 Homeless Count & Survey, in which they will work to identify sheltered and unsheltered people experiencing homelessness across Harris, Fort Bend and Montgomery counties. (Adobe Stock)
Coalition for the Homeless, The Way Home to conduct annual Greater Houston-area homeless count Jan. 19-29

The results of the 2021 homeless count and survey are expected to be released to the public this spring.