San Jacinto River Authority lawsuit against Conroe, Magnolia, other entities may proceed after court of appeals affirms three out of four claims

An ongoing lawsuit between the City of Conroe and the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District over water rates is now headed to the Texas Supreme Court.

An ongoing lawsuit between the City of Conroe and the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District over water rates is now headed to the Texas Supreme Court.

Update: This story has been updated on Sept. 6 to include comments from Conroe City Attorney Marc Winberry. 

Update: This story has been updated to include a statement from Jace Houston, general manager for the San Jacinto River Authority. The statement is from the authority's news release issued Wednesday afternoon. 

On Friday, the Court of Appeals for the Third District of Texas ruled to dismiss one of four declarations in the San Jacinto River Authority’s lawsuit against the cities of Conroe, Magnolia and Splendora—as well as other connected utility companies—over water usage fees. With this decision, the SJRA's lawsuit against the entities may proceed in Travis County.

The SJRA—a state agency that works to conserve the water resources of the San Jacinto River watershed—sells surface water from Lake Conroe to select entities as a part of the groundwater reduction plan, or GRP, to comply with groundwater regulations in Montgomery County. Conroe and The Woodlands are among the entities that buy surface water from the SJRA, as Conroe entered into a GRP contract in May 2010, SJRA General Manager Jace Houston said Monday night via a phone interview.

The dispute began after the SJRA voted to increase the water usage rate by 18 cents per 1,000 gallons in May 2016. Houston said the authority published a 10-year projection on its website prior to the GRP contract to give entities an understanding of how the rate may change over time.

Before the rate increase could take effect Sept. 1, 2016, the city of Conroe approved a resolution stating that the SJRA was overcharging and the city would "refuse payment of the increase in fees, rates, or charges" and would pay the SJRA in accordance with pre-existing rates, according to court documents. The city of Magnolia approved a resolution refusing the increase shortly after.

After Conroe and Magnolia refused to pay the authority’s increased water usage fees, the SJRA filed the lawsuit in Travis County in November 2016 under the Expedited Declaratory Judgement Act (EDJA). According to court documents, the city of Conroe then filed several motions that contested whether the SJRA's claims were within the EDJA, including a motion to transfer the lawsuit from Travis County to Montgomery County, but the district court denied the motions.

The next year, the SJRA approved another increase of 14 cents per 1,000 gallons, and the cities again refused to pay the rate increase. The rate increase took effect Sept. 1, 2017, with the authority attributing 12 cents of the increase to legal fees associated with the lawsuit, according to previous Community Impact Newspaper reports.

According to Aug. 31 court documents, the Third District Court of Appeals ruled in favor of three declarations, which stated the fiscal year 2017 rate, rate order and the GRP contracts—including the contract with Conroe—are legal and valid; the SJRA issued its 2017 rate in accordance with the GRP contracts; and the SJRA is authorized to set rates in accordance with the GRP contracts. However, the court of appeals chose to dismiss the SJRA’s claim “that Conroe’s refusal to pay the fiscal year 2017 rate is illegal and invalid, and its failure to pay is a breach of the GRP contract.”

“We’re pleased that the Austin court of appeals agreed that the SJRA exceeded its authority by attempting to find Conroe in default of the agreement,” Conroe City Administrator Paul Virgadamo said in a phone interview Monday afternoon. “We’re going to study the decision and consult with our attorneys whether or not we will appeal it.”

However, Houston said he believes the court's decision is a win for the SJRA, because although the breech of contract declaration was dismissed, the lawsuit's three other declarations were affirmed. Therefore, the EDJA lawsuit may proceed in Travis County on an expedited basis, Houston said.

With the court's most recent decision on Friday, each party will bear its own legal fees relating to this appeal, according to court documents. Furthermore, the entities have until Sept. 17 to motion for a rehearing with the court.

“Once the trial court rules that the contracts and rates are valid, then it is clear that the cities are
breaching the contracts by refusing to pay,” Houston said in a news release issued Wednesday. “The EDJA will allow the court to determine validity relatively quickly. Once the contracts and rates are declared valid, SJRA can easily prove breach in a separate suit.”

In a phone interview Thursday, Conroe City Attorney Marc Winberry—who is not the attorney on this case, but serves as a consulting attorney for the city—said the city is still studying the implications of the Third District Court of Appeal's decision. Winberry said the city will consider whether it is appropriate to appeal the court's decision to deny Conroe's request to change trial venues from Travis County to Montgomery County.

"If the case does actually go to trial at some point, either here or there, one of the things we were gratified about was that the Court of Appeal's decision did point out and recognize that under the [GRP] contract, the SJRA has the obligation, at all times, to maintain the rate at the lowest possible level consistent with good management practices," Winberry said. "We don’t agree that they have done that. And if it goes to trial ... we believe will be able to show that the SJRA has adopted rates that are extremely excessive."


Montgomery County commissioners appointed 10 members to the county's new ethics commission at their Nov. 12 regular meeting.
Community Impact Newspaper staff
Montgomery County commissioners approve 10 members for new county ethics commission

Funding for two county flood planning initiatives was also approved at the couty's Nov. 12 meeting.

Conroe ISD trustee Dale Inman criticized Willis ISD at its Nov. 11 meeting. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Community divided over Willis High School drag queen event

Several parents, teachers and residents spoke at the Willis Independent School District meeting Nov. 11.

Snow fell at the Tomball Museum Center in early December 2017 (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Greater Houston area to experience cold front Nov. 11-13; temperature could reach freezing point

The front is not expected to affect travel because the ground is too warm for precipitation to stick.

The HCA Houston Healthcare Conroe board of trustees unveils the hospital's new sign June 25. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
HCA Houston Healthcare Conroe wins national distinction

The award recognizes the hospital's work in "protecting patients from harm and providing safer health care."

The office offers offer insurance, income tax and notary public services. (Courtesy Flash Insurance & Income Tax)
Flash Insurance & Income Tax now open in Conroe

The office offers offer insurance, income tax and notary public services.

Drivers on the Grand Parkway will pay higher tolls come Jan. 1, 2020. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Tolls to increase Jan. 1 on the Grand Parkway

Drivers on the Grand Parkway will see toll rates increase 2% on Jan. 1, 2020.

Manager Shannon Vinecke and owner Robert Aranguren run Cards and Comics Connection. (Andy Li, Community Impact Newspaper.)
Cards and Comics Connection

At Cards and Comics Connection, comic books line the walls, while gaming tables fill the store.

SHSU Physicians will begin seeing patients Nov. 12. (Courtesy Sam Houston State University)
SHSU Physicians clinic to open in Conroe on Nov. 12

The clinic is located at 690 S. Loop 336 W., Ste. 200, Conroe.

Commissional Coffee will celebrate its three-year anniversary on Nov. 17. (Courtesy Sonya Orr/Commissional Coffee)
Commissional Coffee to celebrate three-year anniversary in Conroe

The store stocks various types of fair trade and organic coffee and also has a small gift shop.

Brian Hayden presents at a Conroe ISD Audit Committee meeting Nov. 6.
Conroe ISD welcomes new internal auditor

Brian Hayden has worked as a former contractor with Houston ISD with 15 years of auditing experience.

spirit of texas bank
Alamo Title relocates from Conroe to Montgomery

The residential and commercial title insurance provider opened in Montgomery on Oct. 7.

Texas capitol
UPDATED: Here is how Texas voters weighed in on 10 state constitutional amendments on the ballot Nov. 5

Ten constitutional amendments went before voters in Texas on Election Day, Nov. 5.

Back to top