UPDATED: Federal court denies SJRA’s motion to dismiss Quadvest antitrust lawsuit

Quadvest filed its antitrust lawsuit in November 2019. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Quadvest filed its antitrust lawsuit in November 2019. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)

Quadvest filed its antitrust lawsuit in November 2019. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)

Updated 8 a.m. Aug. 20: This story has been updated to include comments from a Quadvest news release.

A federal court has denied the San Jacinto River Authority’s motion to dismiss an antitrust lawsuit filed against the regulatory agency.

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas Houston Division ruled the lawsuit brought by private water utility companies Quadvest and Woodland Oaks Utility will be allowed to continue.

In the lawsuit, plaintiffs allege the SJRA has conspired to establish a monopoly on water supply in Montgomery County by purchasing all available surface water resources in the region as well as lobbying the Texas Legislature to create the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District to regulate all available groundwater resources.

The SJRA claimed the lawsuit “frivolous” and filed a motion to dismiss it. The motion to dismiss claimed that the lawsuit was brought too late, that the SJRA was immune from the lawsuit due to the creation by the state and that its action did not violate the Sherman Antitrust Act.

We asked the court to throw out Quadvest’s lawsuit without giving it a hearing. It’s something courts are generally reluctant to do, even with cases as frivolous as this one,” SJRA General Manager Jace Houston said. “The claim is clearly without merit and will eventually be dismissed.


Following the ruling, Quadvest released a news release Aug. 20 claiming the ruling was one of the most impactful losses to the SJRA.

"U.S. District Judge Vanessa D. Gilmore's ruling destroyed SJRA's defenses, making it clear that SJRA must stand to account for its apparent violations of federal antitrust laws," the release stated.

SJRA admitted its actions are anti-competitive but argued the state of Texas authorized its actions, according to Quadvest. Gilmore ruled SJRA cannot provide any proof the Texas legislature authorized SJRA to violate federal antitrust laws.

"After years of appeals and delays, SJRA is getting closer and closer to facing trial for their actions in the Montgomery County water fiasco," the Quadvest news release concluded.
By Eva Vigh
Eva Vigh joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2018 as a reporter for Spring and Klein. Prior to this position, she covered upstream oil and gas news for a drilling contractors' association.


MOST RECENT

The Montgomery ISD board of trustees met Jan. 19. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
Montgomery ISD adopts first legislative platform

“In any year, the stakes are high for public education,” MISD Director of Communications Justin Marino said.

The Conroe ISD board of trustees met Jan. 19 for its regular monthly meeting. (Screenshot via Conroe ISD YouTube)
Conroe ISD board approves Caney Creek attendance boundary changes, 2021-22 calendar

Board members also approved spending for 20 replacement school buses and annual safety and security projects.

Several bills have been filed pertaining to remote learning. (Courtesy Canva)
Remote learning plans for 2021-22 uncertain for Conroe, Montgomery, Willis ISDs

District data shows that an increasing number of students are choosing to attend in person.

In addition to vaccine hubs, there are also smaller community vaccine providers throughout Texas, such as pharmacies, that may also have the vaccine available. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
EXPLAINED: When, where and how Texans can receive the COVID-19 vaccine

As Texas is still in the early stages of rolling out the COVID-19 vaccine, many Texans are still unsure about, where, when and how they can get inoculated.

Steve Hoffart, owner of Magnolia Pharmacy, hopes to be chosen as one of the county's five vaccination hubs. Lone Star Family Health Center in Conroe has already been selected as a vaccination hub provider, and the center began mass-administering doses at the Montgomery County Fairgrounds Jan. 20. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
Montgomery County poised for COVID-19 vaccine rollout

One vaccination hub is now open, but appointments filled up within minutes. Here's what we know about the county's distribution plan.

The barbecue eatery is the second Killen's Restaurant Group venture to launch in The Woodlands area. (Courtesy Killen's Barbecue)
Killen's Barbecue opens in The Woodlands and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

Montgomery County continues to see new daily highs in active COVID-19 case counts as hospitalizations rise. (Community Impact staff)
Montgomery County COVID-19 total case count increases to over 34,000; active case count decreases by 1,500

The total COVID-19 case count across Montgomery County has surpassed 34,000.

The board of trustees will meet at 6 p.m. Jan. 19. (Eva Vigh/Community Impact Newspaper)
Montgomery ISD gathering community input for district goals

The goals are to improve in the following areas: academic achievement, safety, finance and operations, human capital, and communications and customer service.

Feeding Texas hosted a Jan. 19 webinar to discuss legislative highlights for the 87th Texas Legislature. (Screenshot courtesy Feeding Texas)
Food insecurity in Texas' 87th Legislature: Hunger relief organization Feeding Texas to propose legislation addressing hunger

Hunger relief organization Feeding Texas hosted a webinar Jan. 19 to discuss increasing funding and accessibility for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program in the 87th legislative session.

Grand Central Park is located at I-45 North and South Loop 336. (Courtesy Kaplan Public Relations)
Grand Central Park in Conroe opens 148 homesites

New, move-in ready homes are currently under construction.

COVID-19 vaccines
DATA: Texas has vaccinated about 9% of estimated Phase 1 recipients

Over 1.1 million individuals from the Phase 1 population, which is estimated to include 13.5 million individuals total, have received at least one dose.