Galveston Bay earns C in fifth report card: Oysters and dolphins bounce back after Hurricane Harvey

Image description
Pollution in the Bay
Image description
Phosphorus in river and bayous
Image description
Saltwater wetlands
After Hurricane Harvey dumped billions of gallons of water over the Greater Houston area, Galveston Bay suffered. Oysters died off, dolphins developed skin lesions, and fish populations were scattered, officials said.

However, officials said things have largely returned back to normal for the bay and the variety of creatures that call it home. In fact, Harvey acted as a “reset button” for oyster populations, and they have been spawning frequently since, said Raz Halili, the vice president of oyster distributor Prestige Oysters.

“Oysters are resilient creatures. It was less mortality than we originally anticipated,” he said.

For the fifth straight year since its inception, the Galveston Bay report card, released in August, shows Texas’ largest estuary has earned an overall C grade, evidence of its resiliency to the effects of the historic storm. Still, scientists and environmentalists said some aspects of the bay are in danger of degrading further.

The Galveston Bay Foundation and the Houston Advanced Research Center partnered to develop the report card, which includes grades in several indicators across six categories, to give the public an understandable idea of the bay’s health and prompt residents to act to improve its quality, foundation and HARC officials said.

Galveston Bay’s watershed covers thousands of square miles and reaches all the way to Dallas, but those in the Bay Area feel the effects of the bay’s health the most. Boaters, fishers and seafood restaurant owners are some whose livelihoods depend on a high-quality bay, officials said.

“For many residents, the reason they live there is the proximity to the water,” HARC scientist Erin Kinney said. “It’s still integral to the community.”


The 2019 report card is the first featuring a full year of post-Hurricane Harvey data. Scientists were pleasantly surprised to find in their research that Galveston Bay is a resilient ecosystem that was able to quickly bounce back from the hurricane’s damage. This is due to the bay’s size and the huge variety of systems and wildlife that work in tandem to recover from catastrophic events, Kinney said.

Harvey released so much rain that for weeks Galveston Bay turned from a saltwater body to a freshwater body all the way up to Galveston Island. As a result, many fish in streams and rivers entered the bay, and many fish that lived in the bay temporarily swam into the Gulf of Mexico, Kinney said.

Oysters did not have that luxury. Stuck in place, they became stressed and diseased in the bay, HARC President Lisa Gonzalez said.

“Oysters are a keystone species for a habitat that provides a home for many, many other species in Galveston Bay,” Kinney said.

Halili said the bay was closed to oyster harvesting for months after Harvey. Local seafood restaurants had to get oysters from Louisiana instead of the bay at a slightly increased cost until oyster populations recovered, he said.

Harvey also affected fishing, said Doug Pike, the host of SportsTalk790’s outdoors show “The Doug Pike Show.”

“Nothing was where it should have been that time of year, including the fish,” Pike wrote in an email to Community Impact Newspaper. “Fortunately for the resource, most fishermen were preoccupied with recovery throughout the time. In a way, the fish caught a break.”

Dolphins are another species that suffered when the bay turned into a freshwater body. Many of the 600-plus dolphins that live in the bay suffered skin lesions that made them more susceptible to disease, said Kristi Fazioli, a research associate with the Galveston Bay Dolphin Research and Conservation Program.

“Dolphins are meant for saltwater. When exposed to freshwater, it can have detrimental effects on their health,” she said.

Dolphins are an indicator species, which means when researchers see issues with dolphins, it is a sign of an overall problem with the bay. Dolphins have since recovered and returned to the bay, a sign that the bay has quickly recovered from Harvey, Fazioli said.

“Despite the impacts of Hurricane Harvey, we still managed to bounce back,” Galveston Bay Foundation President Bob Stokes said. “The bay really is resilient.”


The 2019 report card saw grade dips for the water quality category and its indicators for phosphorus. The estimated grade for saltwater wetlands also decreased, and these problems can be tied to the urbanization of previously undeveloped areas, officials said.

League City is one of several Bay Area communities that are growing and changing. The thousands of acres of open fields in League City’s southwest quadrant are under development and will one day be almost entirely residential and commercial property, League City officials said.

Such development can adversely affect waterways. Erosion-controlling silt fences developers put up when constructing buildings often fall down, allowing damaging sediments to flow into waterways, Kinney said.

The more an area is developed from farm or natural land to residential or commercial, the more rain runs off into nearby streams and rivers. More roofs and concrete mean more chemicals, bacteria and other pollutants end up in the bay, said Gene Fisseler, Clear Lake resident and longtime environmentalist and bay advocate.

Additionally, as lawns are created, new residents use phosphorus, a chemical necessary for plant growth, to fertilize lawns, and the chemical washes into bayous and ends up polluting the bay. Developers might know when and how much phosphorus to use, but residents who do not could end up polluting water, Kinney said.

“Even if there is an equal amount of fertilizer, more of it is probably washing off,” Fisseler said. “We homeowners are guilty of that.”

It is estimated the grade for saltwater wetlands will drop from a C to a D once officials receive concrete data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, but it is known the acreage for wetlands, even protected ones, has decreased since 2015, in part due to development, officials said.

“Development per se is not bad, but when you … fragment a lot of habitat, you lose the value of that habitat,” Stokes said.

Wetlands are important because they filter stormwater runoff, protect against storm surges, are nurseries for several fish species and provide other benefits, Kinney said.

Major pollution events also have an adverse effect on the bay.

In March, a tank of chemicals at Intercontinental Terminals Co. caught fire and took several days to extinguish. The extinguishing foam firefighters used released harmful chemicals into the Houston Ship Channel, experts said.

In May, two barges collided in the Houston Ship Channel near Bayport, spilling 378,000 gallons of gasoline in Galveston Bay, officials said.

Since both events happened this year, they were not included in the 2019 report card and will appear in the 2020 report card. For the 2019 report card, Galveston Bay earned a B for the pollution category, a B for the total number of oil spills and an A for the total volume of oil spilled.

Increasing phosphorus levels and oil spills and other industry-level pollution are issues of the region’s growing population. Only a small percentage of residents and companies are not “following the rules,” but as more people move to the area, more pollution could come, Kinney said.

“What we’ve seen in the last five years is how much more pressure we’re putting on ecosystems like Galveston Bay … because we have so many people now,” she said.


Despite the devastation of Harvey and dips in certain indicators, Galveston Bay has made progress in several areas since 2015. Recreation is safer, underwater grasses are healthier and nitrogen levels in the bay are excellent. Additionally, the bay is much healthier and features more wildlife than it did 30 or 40 years ago, Stokes said.

Harvey proved the bay is resilient, and that is because it has a strong variety of systems working together for the entire estuary’s benefit, Kinney said.

“If one area gets hit, especially hard, the other areas can pick up the slack,” she said.

The bay’s grades have not fluctuated much because it takes years to see the effects of positive and negative influences on a system as large and complex as Galveston Bay, Gonzalez said.

“We’ve said from the beginning this is like steering a giant ocean liner; it takes a long time to change direction,” Stokes said.

Still, officials are hopeful that, with the public’s help, the grade can climb. Residents can help by participating in trash cleanups, using the Galveston Bay Action Network app to report pollution, properly disposing of pet waste and limiting the use of lawn fertilizers, among other things, Kinney said.

“We need to make it a priority as a society,” Stokes said.
By Jake Magee

Jake Magee has been a print journalist for several years, covering numerous beats including city government, education, business and more. Starting off at a daily newspaper in southern Wisconsin, Magee covered two small cities before being promoted to covering city government in the heart of newspaper's coverage area. He moved to Houston in mid-2018 to be the editor for and launch the Bay Area edition of Community Impact Newspaper.



Donations of protective supplies for Houston's first responders can be given at Minute Maid Park on April 9 from noon-3 p.m. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Gloves, gowns, protective supplies donations to be collected at Minute Maid Park on April 8

The drive only accepts sealed boxes of supplies, but monetary donations can be made as well.

As of April 3, most Houston-area parks remain open with social distancing rules in effect. (Marie Leonard/Community Impact Newspaper)
Houston parks stay open with new distancing measures in effect

The Head of Houston Parks Department said closing some or all, city parks is not off the table is social distancing protocols cannot be followed.

A Harris County administrative judge has ordered county officials to "wholly disregard" an order from Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo that involved releasing certain nonviolent inmates from the Harris County Jail. (Courtesy Brian Jackson/Adobe Stock)
Judge orders halt to Harris County inmate release

The plan to release certain nonviolent inmates was announced earlier this week to try to prevent a coronavirus outbreak at the Harris County Jail.

Houston Airport System officials expect March passenger data to be significantly lower than in other months. Foot traffic at IAH was light March 24. (Emily Heineman/Community Impact Newspaper)
TSA limits checkpoints at George Bush Intercontinental Airport; Houston Airport System expects significant decline in March passengers

With low passenger travel amid the coronavirus pandemic, Transportation Security Administration checkpoints at George Bush Intercontinental Airport have been consolidated to make better use of resources and personnel, Houston Airport System officials said.

As cities and businesses do their part to fight off the spread of COVID-19, health care providers find themselves not only fighting the spread but also fighting other patient ailments. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Pearland, Bay Area pharmacy working to keep people healthy in a COVID-19-focused environment

As cities and businesses do their part to fight off the spread of COVID-19, health care providers find themselves not only fighting the spread but also fighting other patient ailments.

Prices are more of an indicator of real estate activity during the coronavirus pandemic than location or geography, a local Realtor said.
ROUNDUP: 5 recent coronavirus stories from the South Houston area readers should know

Catch up on some of the latest coronavirus updates for the South Houston area below.

Volunteers unload food donations for the Montgomery County Food Bank. (Courtesy Drive West Communications)
ExxonMobil makes $250,000 donation to local food banks

The energy company said the Houston Food Bank will receive $200,000, including $50,000 in gasoline gift cards. The Montgomery County Food Bank will also receive $50,000.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo provided updates on the county's "Stay Home-Work Safe" order at a March 30 press conference. (Screenshot via Harris County)
VIDEO: Texas Tribune interviews Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo about the coronavirus outbreak’s impact in Houston

The Texas Tribune demographics reporter Alexa Ura interviewed Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo on April 3.

The Shaman cleansing wash sold at Bay Area Natural Wellness contains hypochlorous acid, one of eight active ingredients that the Environmental Protection Agency said can prevent, destroy, repel or mitigate the novel coronavirus that causes COVID-19. (Courtesy of Bay Area Natural Wellness)
Bay Area businesses remain open to offer preventive healthcare amid coronavirus concerns

Bay Area Natural Wellness and iCRYO both offer preventive health care, and business owners said customers can still take advantage of their services despite the coronavirus outbreak.

According to recent League City Police Department records, officers have responded to over three dozen reports of residents and businesses violating Galveston County’s stay-at-home order in less than two weeks. (Courtesy Fotolia)
RECORDS: League City police disband parties, visit businesses reportedly violating stay-at-home order

According to recent League City Police Department records, officers have responded to over three dozen reports of residents and businesses violating Galveston County’s stay-at-home order in less than two weeks.

The employees of The Adventure Begins Comics, Games & More gather their characters together in "Animal Crossing: New Horizons." (Kate Looney/The Adventure Begins Comics, Games & More)
5 recent business stories from the Houston area readers should know

Read updates on how local businesses are reacting in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic.

Many renters in the Greater Houston area may be faced with struggles paying rent amid the coronavirus outbreak. There are local resources located throughout the region that can help. (Courtesy Pexels)
Struggling to pay April rent? Here are some resources in the Greater Houston area

The deadline for April rent is looming as renters—both in public and private housing—in the Greater Houston area may be struggling financially in the wake of the coronavirus outbreak.