Harris County adopts 'worst-first' guidelines for remaining flood bond projects

Roughly 80 of the 230 projects funded through a 2018 bond referendum in Harris County have yet to begin.

Roughly 80 of the 230 projects funded through a 2018 bond referendum in Harris County have yet to begin.

With roughly 80 projects yet to be started from a $2.5 billion flood bond passed by voters in 2018, Harris County officials are looking to bring more transparency to the process of deciding which should be done next.

Commissioners approved a new set of guidelines for prioritizing projects with a 3-2 vote Aug. 27 following a recommendation from the Harris County Flood Control District. Proponents said the new guidelines are based on addressing the most flood-prone areas first.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo said the guidelines are also meant to reduce the influence of cost-benefit ratios when dedicating local flood bond money, a metric often required for projects to receive federal funding and one critics said can keep lower-income communities from getting needed improvements.

"We really need to make sure that from today on ..., the decisions we make in Harris County, as it pertains to flooding, are based on being smart—they are based on putting people first," Hidalgo said.

A total of eight metrics will be taken into account when evaluating projects moving forward, according to the Harris County Flood Control District. The metrics to receive the highest consideration include:

  • Flood risk reduction: A metric based on how much of the floodplain is reduced and how many structures benefited by the project. Total number of homes will be taken into account instead of the value of the homes.

  • Drainage level of service: A metric based on the drainage capacity of the channels relevant to a project.

  • Social vulnerability index: A metric devised by U.S. Centers for Disease Control that takes into account the ability of certain communities to recover from disasters, such as flooding. Factors include percentage of elderly residents, prevalence of limited English proficiency and number of households without a vehicle.

Other metrics include project efficiency, partnership funding, long-term maintenance costs, minimization of environmental impacts and potential for multiple benefits.

The adoption of the new guidelines was opposed by Precinct 3 Commissioner Steve Radack and Precinct 4 Commissioner Jack Cagle. Cagle stressed his support for the majority of the guidelines, including "worst-first" guidelines designed to make sure communities that flood repeatedly do not see delays in projects.

However, Cagle said he did not agree with the weight given to social vulnerability in determining how projects should be prioritized. In a project rating system provided by the HCFCD, 25% of a project's score comes from flood risk reduction, whereas about 20% comes from the social vulnerability index.

"Water didn’t care whether you are of a wealthy neighborhood or a poor neighborhood," Cagle said. "Water didn’t care how much education you had. It found the lowest spot. I think we’re getting away from science and we’re getting into other issues."

HCFCD Executive Director Russ Poppe said the district had already been using some version of seven of the eight metrics all along. The eighth—the social vulnerability index—will allow the district to account for the "human factor" when looking at projects, he said.

Poppe said the goal of the HCFCD is to have all 80 remaining projects underway within the next 24 to 30 months. Of the projects yet to start, the highest-rated projects using the new framework include the conveyance improvements along Greens Bayou; the construction of a detention basin on White Oak Bayou at Arbor Oaks; and land acquisition and construction along Sims Bayou.

More information can be found online at www.harristhrives.org.
By Shawn Arrajj

Shawn Arrajj serves as the editor of the Cy-Fair edition of Community Impact Newspaper where he covers the Cy-Fair and Jersey Village communities. He mainly writes about development, transportation and issues in Harris County.


Houston-area hospitals to close include the Tomball, Spring, Heights and Bay Area locations of Kindred Hospital, according to the statement. (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Kindred Healthcare to close 6 Houston, Dallas locations

Four Houston-area locations of Kindred Hospital will close by March 17.

A Pea in the Pod Rice Village
Houston-area stores closing soon as Destination Maternity works through bankruptcy

A Pea in the Pod, at Rice Village will soon close its doors as its corprate owners go through a downsizing.

Bellaire High School
HISD exploring metal detectors, other security measures in wake of Bellaire shooting

Houston ISD is prepared to deploy metal detectors in some schools as early as the next few months.

Express location, Rice Village
Rice Village Express store to close Jan. 26; Meyerland Plaza, Galleria stores to remain open

Amid nationwide closures, the Express fashion store in Rice Village, at 2414 University Blvd., Houston, will have its last day Jan. 26.

I-59 highway
Southbound lanes on Loop 610, I-69 to have nightly closures until Friday

Two southbound outside lanes from Westheimer Road down to the Fournace Place ramp on Loop 610 will be closed 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. beginning tonight until Friday, according to the Texas Department of Transportation.

Pier 1 stores closing
Amid nationwide closures, local Pier 1 stores to shut down

Pier 1 Imports stores in Meyerland and Rice Village will be closing their doors, though a store in River Oaks will remain open.

New studio aims to bring the fun in coding for kids

A fully interactive coding studio is bringing its high-tech features to The Galleria in June.

A Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County study on eliminating ride fares left both METRO board members and officials seemingly unconvinced of the likelihood of implementing it in Harris County. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
METRO board of directors say free fare 'not feasible' for transit authority

A METRO study on eliminating ride fares left board members and officials unconvinced of the likelihood of implementing it in Harris County.

Houston City Council approves revisions to 2015 flood buyout processes

New guidelines adjust single-family and multifamily home buyout process for those affected by 2015 floods.

Breathing Center of Houston moves therapy rehab to new location

Breathing Center of Houston has moved one of its locations to 6108 S. Rice Ave., Houston, on Jan. 8 from its old location on Beechnut Street. The new center offers a more modern decor along with the same program offerings, including outpatient rehabilitation, which focuses on improving the quality of life for patients with lung disease or chronic lung issues. Patients interact one-on-one with medical therapists to learn breathing techniques and strength and endurance exercises. 713-660-0663. www.bchouston.com

Meyerland HEB
H-E-B announces Meyerland store opening date

H-E-B will open its new Meyerland Plaza location Jan. 29 at 4700 Beechnut St., Houston.

Back to top