Program to reform Harris County bail system faces delays

Harris County commissioners discussed the long-term effect of a federal court's ruling on its bail bond system.

Harris County commissioners discussed the long-term effect of a federal court's ruling on its bail bond system.

On Tuesday Harris County commissioners and Judge Ed Emmett discussed the impact of a federal mandate requiring the release of misdemeanor defendants awaiting trial who are unable to post bail on the county's own plans to reform its bail bond system.

An April ruling by Chief U.S. District Judge Lee Rosenthal required the release of qualifying defendants who signed an affidavit on June 6 declaring their inability to post bail.

Precinct 4 Commissioner Jack Cagle said Harris County's Public Safety Assessment—a data-based tool intended to help judges decide whether to release pretrial misdemeanor defendants—scheduled to go into effect at the beginning of July has been delayed.

During Tuesday's meeting, Cagle said he was concerned about public safety when defendants are released without assessment. Emmett said an individual released without paying bail is more likely to commit another crime.

"Yeah, you can reoffend if you’re out on bail," Emmett said, "but the numbers were skewed fairly heavily. If you’re out without paying anything...those individuals seem to reoffend more often than those who are out on bond.”

A total of 21 percent of the individuals released under Judge Rosenthal's order have failed to appear for trial, First Assistant County Attorney Robert Soard. The failure rate for defendants who paid bail was only 3.8 percent, Soard said.

Also known as the Arnold tool, the PSA uses nine factors to measure the pretrial risk level of defendants unable to pay bail, focusing on whether the individual is a threat to the public whether he or she is likely to show up for trial, according to a news release by the Arnold Foundation, which developed the tool. The assessment gives the individual a score ranging from one to six, with higher numbers indicating increased risk.

Although the presiding judge would have the final say in whether to release a defendant, the news release states the assessment would help Harris County reduce the number of misdemeanor offenders in jail and free up funds currently going toward their incarceration.

Judge Emmett said the big question is whether the PSA will operate in conjunction with Judge Rosenthal's order.

"The question is under Judge Rosenthal's ruling; it doesn't matter," Judge Emmett said. "The assessment tool has no effect because her ruling says all you have to do is sign an affidavit that says 'I can't afford bail,' and you're out."
SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

Lake Conroe residents wore "Stop the Drop" shirts at the Dec. 19 SJRA meeting. (Eva Vigh, Community Impact Newspaper)
Lake Conroe residents demand end to lake lowering

Donning red T-shirts that read “Stop the Drop,” Lake Conroe residents gathered in full force at a Dec. 12 San Jacinto River Authority board meeting.

Quest Early College High School will move from within Humble High School to the nearby career and technical education center, or CATE Center, in August 2020. (Courtesy Google Maps)
Quest Early College High School students look forward to new, permanent space

Humble ISD is moving forward with its project to relocate Quest Early College High School from its current space within Humble High School to the district's career and technical education building.

Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner addresses the Texas General Land Office at a Dec. 11 public hearing. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Houston area leaders call for more federal flood dollars at public meeting

Officials expressed concerns about proposed limitations for how federal funds will be allocated throughout the state.

The Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District accepted the resignation of its board president Dec. 10. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District board president resigns; hydrologist contract terminated

The Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District meeting Dec. 10 brought two immediate changes.

Dolce & Cannoli Pizzeria will open in late January in the Deerbrook Mall. (Courtesy Dolce & Cannoli Pizzeria)
Dolce & Cannoli Pizzeria to open second Houston-area eatery in Deerbrook Mall

This is the second location for the Houston-area eatery, as the first is in Memorial City Mall.

Eight roadways in the Lake Houston, Humble and Kingwood areas ranked in the top 1,000 of 1,800 roadways included in the Texas Transportation Institute's 2019 Most Congested Roadways in Texas report. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Northpark, Kingwood drives ranked among most congested roadways in Lake Houston area

The Texas A&M Transportation Institute's 2019 Most Congested Roadways in Texas report ranks more than 1,800 roadways across the state in terms of traffic delays, and money and gas wasted in traffic

Licensed registered nurses can earn the Bachelor of Science in nursing degree to be better prepared for leadership and management roles. (Courtesy Lone Star College)
Lone Star College approved to offer bachelor’s degree programs in 2020

Starting in fall 2020, Lone Star College will be one of the first community colleges in the state where students can work toward certain four-year degrees.

Taste of Paris Creperie & Cafe will open in the West Lake Village shopping center in January. (Courtesy Taste of Paris Creperie & Cafe)
Taste of Paris Creperie & Cafe to offer sweet, savory crepes from West Lake Village shopping center

Taste of Paris Creperie & Cafe will open in the West Lake Village shopping center in January.

City of Houston Mayor Pro Tem Jerry Davis, who currently holds the District B seat on the Houston City Council, addressed the Harris County Commissioners Court Dec. 3. (Hannah Zedaker/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County considers legality, liability of removing Houston City Council Member District B race from Dec. 14 runoff ballot

Harris County commissioners have questions about the removal of the race for Houston City Council Member District B from the Dec. 14 runoff election and what it could mean for future elections.

The Greater Houston area is expected to see a net gain of 42,300 jobs in 2020. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Greater Houston region expected to see slower job growth in 2020

The Greater Houston area is expected to see a net gain of 42,300 jobs in 2020.

Harris County Commissioners Court
Harris County unanimously approves plan for Healthy Food Financing Initiative program

The countywide competitive grant program will provide funding to support healthy food retail, nutrition education and urban agriculture in underserved communities.

Kingwood-based retailer Pretty Little Things Boutique will open its second storefront in Redemption Square on Dec. 7. (Courtesy Pretty Little Things Boutique)
Pretty Little Things Boutique to open second store in Redemption Square in Houston

Kingwood-based retailer Pretty Little Things Boutique will open its second storefront in Redemption Square

Back to top