Analysis: FEMA may be undercounting national total flood risk by as much as 70%

The First Street Foundation's dataset includes a forecast models that anticipate the effects of climate change and sea level rise. (Screenshot via First Street Foundation)
The First Street Foundation's dataset includes a forecast models that anticipate the effects of climate change and sea level rise. (Screenshot via First Street Foundation)

The First Street Foundation's dataset includes a forecast models that anticipate the effects of climate change and sea level rise. (Screenshot via First Street Foundation)

The Federal Emergency Management Agency's estimates are that 8.7 million properties are at risk for flooding across the country, but a new set of data released by the nonprofit First Street Foundation suggests that number should be closer to 14.6 million, according to a June 29 release. When other forward-looking factors such as the climate and sea levels are factored in, First Street estimates the number of at-risk properties to grow to 16.2 million by 2050.

With the new dataset, First Street also unveiled a Flood Factor dashboard that anyone can use to assess the risk of flooding over a 30-year period for any address or city.

The reason for the discrepancy has to do with how the nonprofit incorporated historical data, climate change and forecasting, including drawing on research from over 80 scientists into its risk assessment model, said Ed Kearns, First Street Foundation’s chief data officer.

“In environmental engineering, there is a concept called stationarity, which assumes that today is going to be like yesterday, and tomorrow is going to be like yesterday,” Kearns said in the news release. “This concept used to work, but with a changing environment it’s a poor assumption and no longer does. FEMA’s method assumes stationarity, First Street’s does not.”

The model also serves as the first free, publicly available comprehensive flood risk tool.


“Sophisticated investors have privately purchased flood risk information from for-profit firms for years,” said Matthew Eby, the executive director of First Street Foundation, in the release. “First Street Foundation has not only taken this kind of data to the next level, using peer-reviewed science, but is correcting an asymmetry of information by providing free access to everyday Americans.”

Even more data beyond the public Flood Factor tool will be made available to academics and other partners for further study, the foundation said, and corporations and other groups can pay for access, with revenue going toward future development.

Evaluate flood risks in your city

Here are some of the Flood Factor models for metropolitan areas in Community Impact Newspaper's readership:

  • Houston has increasing flood risk, with 202,320 properties at risk in 30 years.

  • Austin has increasing flood risk, with 16,522 properties at risk in 30 years.

  • Dallas has increasing flood risk, with 22,045 properties at risk in 30 years

  • Atlanta has increasing flood risk, with 14,887 properties at risk in 30 years

  • Phoenix has decreasing flood risk, with 61,466 properties at risk in 30 years.

  • Nashville has an increasing flood risk, with 33,813 properties at risk in 30 years.

By Matt Dulin
Matt joined Community Impact Newspaper in January 2018 and is the City Editor for Houston's Inner Loop editions.


MOST RECENT

The overall death total in Harris County hit 805, with the majority of deaths—78%—occurring in individuals ages 60 and older. (Community Impact staff)
Harris County coronavirus count: 17 deaths confirmed Aug. 5, including man in his 20s

The overall death total hit 805, with the majority of deaths—78%—occurring in individuals ages 60 and older.

Restaurants in Houston can now opt to take up to 50% of its designated parking spaces to create outdoor dining space as long as COVID-19 restrictions remain in effect. (Matt Dulin/Community Impact Newspaper)
Houston restaurants can now tap parking lots for outdoor dining

Houston City Council has approved a proposal to allow restaurants to take over 50% of their parking spaces to expand outdoor dining capacity.

Another $20 million in relief will be available soon for Houston residents struggling to pay rent. (Community Impact staff)
Houston OKs $20M in rent relief with provision to delay evictions

The new funds will also be prioritzed to the most vulnerable residents rather than a first-come, first-served process.

The Confederate Soldiers Monument stands on the south grounds of the Texas Capitol. A group of Democratic lawmakers have called for its removal, along with other statues and portraits honoring the Confederacy. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
State legislators seek removal of Confederate monuments at Texas Capitol

The decision may ultimately lie with Gov. Greg Abbott and the rest of the State Preservation Board, which last year authorized the removal of a plaque in the Capitol that said slavery was not an underlying cause of the Confederate rebellion.

This map shows the corridors that will be subject to new transit-oriented development rules, which are designed to improve access to high-capacity transit options. (Courtesy City of Houston)
Houston adopts new development rules to promote walkable, transit-oriented projects

New development moving forward will have to conform to new standards along transit corridors and new "Walkable Places" areas.

Bellaire has begun the process of applying for COVID-19 relief funds from Harris County. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Bellaire seeking over $1 million in federal COVID-19 relief funding

Eligible uses include public health and safety payroll, equipment and grant programs.

A total of 723 of the new cases were confirmed in Harris County outside of the city of Houston, which is the most to be confirmed outside of the city in a single day. (Community Impact staff)
Harris County coronavirus count: 1,438 new cases, 22 deaths confirmed Aug. 4

A total of 723 of the new cases were confirmed in Harris County outside of the city of Houston, which is the most to be confirmed outside of the city in a single day.

With some Harris County residents waiting up to two weeks to get test results, the county has announced a maximum turnaround time of 3-5 days on county-sponsored tests moving forward. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Harris County announces evening testing hours, faster turnaround on COVID-19 tests

With some Harris County residents waiting up to two weeks to get test results, the county has announced a maximum turnaround time of 3-5 days on county-sponsored tests moving forward.

In the last year, Whataburger launched a new, modern restaurant design and began offering curbside and delivery services for the first time amid the coronavirus pandemic, according to the release. (Courtesy Elizabeth James for Whataburger)
Whataburger to celebrate 70th anniversary, unveil food truck, expand into 3 states

Nine more new Whataburger locations are planned by year's end, and 35 new restaurants are proposed for 2021.