Lawmakers aim to help struggling nursing homes

Lawmakers aim to help struggling nursing homes

Updated May 23

Nursing homes in Texas on average have to cover a gap of nearly $20 per day to take care of residents who pay with Medicaid, but a bill before the state Legislature seeks to close that gap with the help of federal funding.

House Bill 2766, filed by Rep. J.D. Sheffield, R-Gatesville, was voted out of the Texas House of Representatives by a margin of 96-42 on May 10 and sent to the Senate. As of May 23, the bill had been voted out of the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services 6-3.

Proponents said the bill would bring in about $440 million in federal funding per biennium to be distributed across the state’s 1,200 nursing homes at no cost to the state. This money could help nursing homes afford much-needed capital projects and combat high staff turnover rates, Sheffield said.

“HB 2766 would help nursing home owners retain good staff, and that will improve the quality of care more than any other thing I can think of,” he said.

The most recent data collected by the American Health Care Association in 2014—a trade association representing about 500 nursing homes in Texas through the Texas Health Care Association—show providers in Texas spend an average of $157.84 per day caring for Medicaid residents. About $138.37 of that was reimbursed by Medicaid coverage, resulting in a $19.47 gap. HB 2766 could close that gap to around $1, THCA officials said.

However, the bill has garnered opposition from private pay nursing homes—which do not accept payments through Medicaid—which have expressed concern that they would end up paying into the system without receiving a benefit.

How it works


HB 2766 proposes taking advantage of a federal program by creating a Nursing Facilities Reinvestment Allowance paid by nursing homes based on their revenue. Through a self-assessed fee, nursing homes across the state would each contribute about 6 percent of revenue—an estimated $375 million in total—to a state trust fund. The state would use the funds to draw down matching dollars from the federal government through the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

The money paid in fees would be distributed back to the nursing homes dollar-per-dollar, officials said. THCA, which worked with legislators on crafting the bill, estimates a total of $440 million in new dollars from the federal government would be left over and available to distribute to nursing homes. Those funds would be split, with half going toward improving Medicaid rates and half going toward improving resident care based on a CMS five-star rating program.

Texas is one of six states in the U.S. that does not take advantage of this program, said Eddie Parades, vice president of government affairs with StoneGate Senior Living and a member of the THCA who helped craft the bill.

About 85 percent of the 120,000 nursing home residents in Texas are on Medicaid, Parades said. Without the influx of federal funds or a rate increase from the state, long-term care providers that rely on Medicaid reimbursements will quickly be in a crisis, he said.

“We are on razor-thin margins,” he said. “If we don’t get a rate increase this year, there will no doubt be nursing home closings in Texas. Nursing homes will start closing in rural markets first.”

The effects of the low reimbursement rate can be seen in Cy-Fair. Kirby Green, who operates Park Manor of Cy-Fair—a skilled nursing facility with 101 residents, including 63 on Medicaid—said he does everything he can to make sure his staff is recognized and appreciated but is often left simply hoping they do not choose to pursue other work.

“You can be doing all these great things to retain your staff, but ultimately if they cannot support their families, you’ll have them moving on for 50 cents more [or] a dollar more [per hour],” he said. “These are the [certified nursing assistants], the face of the community, the ones providing direct care and interacting with families. It’s extremely frustrating when you cannot pay them what they deserve.”

Opponents raise questions


Similar bills have been filed in past legislative sessions but fell short because of fears that such a system would disadvantage nursing homes that have few or no Medicaid patients.

Officials behind HB 2766 said these low-Medicaid facilities would be made whole, meaning they would not shoulder any financial burden. Part of the process involves creating a nonprofit corporation that allows high-Medicaid homes to offset the cost of the program for low-Medicaid homes through voluntary payments from participating high-Medicaid facilities. About 90 percent of high-Medicaid nursing homes said they would be willing to participate, officials said.

However, the CMS program these bills takes advantage of does not allow any mechanisms that would guarantee private pay nursing homes their money back, so the establishment of the nonprofit cannot be included in the language of the proposed bill.

Opponents expressed skepticism that private pay residents would not be harmed.

“We have concerns about the unwritten portions of this bill and the private arrangement that falls outside the statute,” said George Linial with LeadingAge Texas, a trade association that advocates for nonprofit retirement communities and nursing homes. “The bill guarantees that someone will have to pay a tax, and there’s nothing in the statute that protects pay communities or residents from this tax.”

Paredes said there will be a binding legal contract in place that will make sure low-Medicaid facilities get their money back first. Sheffield ensured the costs paid by low- and no-Medicaid providers would be offset.

“It’s a smart way to improve long-term care and avoid using state revenue,” he said. “It’s also the only viable plan on the table right now.”
By Shawn Arrajj
Shawn Arrajj serves as the editor of the Cy-Fair edition of Community Impact Newspaper where he covers the Cy-Fair and Jersey Village communities. He mainly writes about development, transportation and issues in Harris County.


MOST RECENT

Face coverings are now required for those entering polling places in Texas during the general election. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Citing racial discrimination, district court judge voids exemption to face covering order for voters, poll workers

A district judge's decision sided with arguments that an exemption to the statewide face covering order violated the Voting Rights Act due to disproportionate effects of COVID-19 for Black and Latino Americans.

A new $40 million COVID-19 relief fund is opening to Harris County residents from Nov. 2-6. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County to provide $40 million in new needs-based COVID-19 relief funding starting Nov. 2

A new $40 million COVID-19 relief fund is opening to Harris County residents from Nov. 2-6.

The Center for Houston’s Future released a report Oct. 28 that looks at the economic vitality of the region’s health care system and assesses the region’s community health. (Courtesy Pexels)
Report: 1 in 4 jobs added by 2036 in Greater Houston will be in the health care sector

However, failing to further develop a talent pipeline in medical expertise would lead to job losses, the report notes.

Houston Morning Market Company is poised to launch three new markets across the Greater Houston area by Nov. 19. (Courtesy Houston Morning Market Company)
Heights Morning Market owner to launch markets in Tomball, Conroe, downtown

“The goal is really just bringing communities together, bringing diversity to these rural communities,” Hayley Summers said.

Inspired by Nashville hot chicken, the new restaurant will offer chicken tender bites, jumbo chicken tenders, chicken sandwiches and bone-in chicken with five heat level options, from "Wimpy" to "Cluckin' Hot." (Courtesy Tumble 22)
Tumble 22's Nashville hot chicken coming to Klein and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo also spearheaded an effort to establish a $10 million Early Childhood Impact Fund, which was approved in a split 3-2 vote Oct. 27. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Harris County establishes $10M Early Childhood Impact Fund, selects organizations to administer additional $7.3M in assistance

Approximately $17.3 million in assistance programs will soon be available to Harris County residents in need, thanks to three programs recently established by the Harris County Commissioners Court.

Marketing materials depict the 1,600-acre tract of land purchased by the Johnson Development Corporation in 2017. A plat was recently approved for a general plan at the site. (Courtesy Rockspring Capital)
General plan approved for 1,600-acre project in far northwest Harris County

The land is owned by an affiliate of the Johnson Development Corporation, though few details are known about the planned development.

The Cy-Fair clinic is hosting an open house Nov. 13 to celebrate one year in business. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Sleep and Headache Solutions of Houston to celebrate first anniversary

The Cy-Fair clinic is hosting an open house Nov. 13 to celebrate one year in business.

Officials said Beacon Hill will help spur future growth in the city of Waller and in the surrounding area. (Rendering courtesy Wolff Companies)
New master-planned community to bring 1,000 homes, Hwy. 290 improvements to Waller

Officials said Beacon Hill will help spur future growth in the city of Waller and in the surrounding area.

The newly approved rate of $0.59920 per $100 valuation is a decrease of $0.01250 from the FY 2019-20 tax rate of $0.61170 per $100 valuation; it is intended to mitigate rising property values across the county, officials said. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Harris County Commissioners Court unanimously approves tax rate decrease for FY 2020-21

The newly approved rate of $0.59920 per $100 valuation is a decrease of $0.01250 from the FY 2019-20 tax rate of $0.61170 per $100 valuation.

Harris County residents line up outside of Big Stone Lodge in Spring to cast their votes early. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County polling locations operating with extended hours in final three days of early voting

More than 1.2 million county residents have already voted in the Nov. 3 general election.

A Cy-Fair ISD employee distributes meals via curbside pickup for district students during the summer. (Courtesy Cy-Fair ISD)
Cy-Fair ISD reports 66 COVID-19 cases among students, staff Oct. 19-25

Cy-Fair ISD officials reported the highest number of new weekly cases since the start of the school year.