Cause of August 2018 pipeline failure in Richardson reported to City Council

Richardson pipe rupture
In the days after the pipeline rupture, water district crews worked to repair the damaged infrastructure. (Courtesy North Texas Municipal Water District)

In the days after the pipeline rupture, water district crews worked to repair the damaged infrastructure. (Courtesy North Texas Municipal Water District)

The North Texas Municipal Water District has released the cause of the massive underground pipeline rupture that flooded several homes in Richardson last year.

The incident occurred Aug. 30, 2018, in the Knolls of Breckinridge, a subdivision in northeast Richardson. The failure of a 72-inch underground pipeline caused a 6-foot geyser to erupt through Crystal Mountain Drive, damaging 13 homes and displacing many residents, including Council Member Ken Hutchenrider.

In the months following the incident, the district commissioned two engineering firms—Halff Associates and Freese & Nichols—to conduct independent forensic analyses of the failed segment, according to Deputy City Manager Don Magner, who presented the findings to City Council on Dec. 2.

Both studies found cracks in the exterior mortar of the pipe are what ultimately led to the rupture. Those cracks could have occurred during construction of the pipe, he said. They also could have happened during construction of the subdivision, a time when underground pipes are exposed to unusually heavy loads, Magner said.

“If there was a crack when [the pipe] went in at construction, additional weight would have the likelihood of opening it up,” he said.

Those cracks allowed moisture to seep into the infrastructure and cause a degradation of wires used to strengthen and protect the pipe, Magner said.

Neither study found any issue in terms of design of the pipeline, which dates back to 1979, Magner said. However, it is possible that the pipe’s wiring had microcracks at the time of manufacturing, increasing the likelihood of fractures if exposed to moisture, he added.

“Degradation that occured on those wires, over time, finally gave through,” he said.

Underground pipelines experience varying levels of pressure on a daily basis, but that is not what caused the failure, the studies found.

“Had it not been for this series of events, the crack in the mortar, the water degrading the wire, the wire having microcracks that made it more susceptible, this rupture would not have occurred simply based on operations,” Magner said.

As a result of the incident, the water district also commissioned Pure Technologies to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the 60- and 72-inch lines that encompass the North Garland Pipeline system, which stretches from Wylie to Richardson and also includes small portions of Plano and Garland.

Within the city of Richardson, there are 14 miles of water lines operated by the water district. The majority of that infrastructure comprises 60- or 72-inch pipelines, Magner said.

Of the 6,000 segments of pipe inspected, Pure Technologies identified five segments as having some level of wire degradation, Magner said. Those segments have been recommended for repair or replacement, and all work should be done by next summer. Only one of those segments was located in Richardson, near the intersection of Renner and Brand roads. The remainder are located in Garland.

The analysis also identified six leak locations, all of which have since been repaired, Magner reported.

Moving forward, the district has agreed to do a similar comprehensive assessment every five years, Magner said. The city will work closely with the district on future inspections and analysis of pipeline, he added.
By Olivia Lueckemeyer
Olivia Lueckemeyer graduated in 2013 from Loyola University New Orleans with a degree in journalism. She joined Community Impact Newspaper in October 2016 as reporter for the Southwest Austin edition before her promotion to editor in March 2017. In July 2018 she returned home to the Dallas area and became editor of the Richardson edition.


The University of Texas will host football games at Darrell K. Royal Veterans Memorial Stadium this fall after an announcement from the Big 12 Conference on Aug. 12 that the fall sports season will continue. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
After Big Ten and PAC-12 cancel, Big 12 announces fall sports season will roll on

The conference football season will begin Sept. 26, and fan capacity in stadiums will be up to each of the 10 member universities, according to the Big 12.

In a record vote, commissioners unanimously voted in favor of proposing a no-new-revenue tax rate at an Aug. 11 workshop. (Screenshot via Collin County)
Collin County commissioners propose lower no-new-revenue tax rate for FY 2020-21

The proposed no-new-revenue tax rate is a nearly 1.4% decrease from the current tax rate.

54th Street Grill opened in McKinney in August. (Courtesy 54th Street Grill)
54th Street Grill opens in McKinney and more DFW-area news

Read the latest community and business news from the DFW area.

Richardson ISD campuses will open for face-to-face instruction Sept. 8. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Richardson ISD sees fairly even split among families choosing in-person, virtual instruction

More than 53%, or 19,938 students, plan to return for face-to-face learning Sept. 8. Roughly 45%, or 16,859 students, will participate in virtual learning.

Richardson ISD paused workouts July 17 in compliance with a Dallas County order. (Courtesy Richardson ISD)
Sports workouts could resume in Richardson ISD following partial lift of Dallas County order

Dallas County has rescinded its order to pause strength and conditioning workouts until students return to campus Sept. 8.

Richardson Bike Mart has about 11,000 bicycles on back order. (File photo/Community Impact Newspaper)
Richardson shop has 11,000 bicycles on back order and more DFW news

Read the latest Dallas-Fort Worth business and community news.

Thirteen drive-thru grocery stores operated by the Salvation Army of North Texas are offering backpacks filled with supplies. (Courtesy Salvation Army)
Salvation Army expands North Texas grocery service locations to include school supplies, protective equipment

Backpacks filled with school supplies, personal protective equipment, financial assistance resources and U.S. Census forms will be available at the 13 existing locations.

Cottonwood Creek Trail features platforms for viewing wildlife and fishing in Cottonwood Creek. (Courtesy Visit Frisco)
Trails system in Frisco expands and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the DFW area.

Anika Cooper founded Simply Grace House in 2013 after her own experience in recovery. Proceeds from Simply Thrifty benefit the nonprofit's seven sober living homes. (Olivia Lueckemeyer/Community Impact Newspaper)
First Look: Richardson boutique Simply Thrifty helps women in recovery rebuild their lives

Merchandise in the store includes lightly used secondhand clothing, furniture and household items.

Richardson Bike Mart has about 11,000 bicycles on back-order. (File photo/Community Impact Newspaper)
Bicycle shortage expected to last months, says Richardson Bike Mart owner

In more than 30 years in business, Richardson Bike Mart owner and President Woody Smith said he has never seen a bicycle shortage like the one that has occurred since the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic.

Rapid nasal swab antigen tests are recommended as options for individuals who were potentially exposed to a confirmed positive carrier, as well as for people traveling, returning to work or undergoing a medical procedure. (Courtesy Total Primary Care)
Find out where to get a 15-minute COVID-19 test in Austin, Dallas-Fort Worth metros

Rapid nasal swab antigen tests are recommended as options for individuals who were potentially exposed to a confirmed positive carrier, as well as for people traveling, returning to work or undergoing a medical procedure.

The owner of the Richardson franchise is Darrin Lawrence. (Courtesy Fastsigns)
Fastsigns now open in Richardson

The business creates custom signs and graphics printed on a variety of products.