Layoffs swift in Plano as small businesses, large developments reel from coronavirus restrictions

Drivers once lined Legacy Drive during rush hour in the Legacy West mixed-use development in Plano. (Gavin Pugh/Community Impact Newspaper)
Drivers once lined Legacy Drive during rush hour in the Legacy West mixed-use development in Plano. (Gavin Pugh/Community Impact Newspaper)

Drivers once lined Legacy Drive during rush hour in the Legacy West mixed-use development in Plano. (Gavin Pugh/Community Impact Newspaper)

Ever since crews converted former cattle fields off the Dallas North Tollway into a hub of sprawling offices and upscale retail stores, the Legacy West development has been held up as an example of Plano's economic renaissance.

But the $3 billion mixed-use project has not escaped the disruption caused by the new coronavirus, which has prompted governments to place broad restrictions on economic activity and unleashed a blistering round of layoffs across the country that are being felt throughout Plano.

The Texas Workforce Commission said 82 employees were let go at Legacy West last week, the first major batch of Plano job losses to show up in the state's mass layoff reporting system.

A spokesperson for the ownership group behind Legacy West's core retail property said the 82 layoffs were not employees of the property management company. It was unclear whether the state's reported layoffs were from the property's various restaurants and stores.

What is clear, however, is that the businesses that make up the development were heavily impacted. Thirty-five Legacy West businesses are known to have closed, at least temporarily, since governments began to impose restrictions to slow the spread of the virus. Thirteen others at the property have had to limit their hours or offerings.


Sudden shock

The pace at which businesses have moved to slash their workforces across the country has been unprecedented.

Nearly 10 million Americans have filed for unemployment benefits in the last two weeks alone, exceeding the number of applications in the first six months of the Great Recession, according to unemployment data from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

The number of jobless claims filed last week was 10 times higher than any one week during the Great Recession, which lasted from late 2007 to mid-2009.

As the federal and state data started to come in, the city of Plano's finance department was already bracing for a significant loss of revenue.

"The pandemic most likely is going to bring on an economic recession," Budget Director Karen Rhodes-Whitley told council members March 30. "We’re already seeing some of this."

The city is currently expecting at least a 10% drop in sales tax revenue. Half of its hotel tax revenue could be lost, as could millions in property taxes in future years, although this number is a lagging indicator and difficult to project, Rhodes-Whitley said.

Small business struggles

The Legacy West layoffs may have been the first big wave of Plano job losses reported to the Texas Workforce Commission, but countless businesses in the city have been hit hard by the new economic reality.

A broad range of retail stores now fall under the category of nonessential business, as defined by Gov. Greg Abbott in an executive order earlier this week.

Even restaurants, which are allowed to operate as essential businesses, have had to close off their dine-in areas to customers. Some have closed altogether.

Still, hundreds of restaurants are trying to hang on amid the restrictions and losses of revenue. At least 170 restaurants in Plano are still open and offering some form of takeout, drive-thru or delivery services, according to a Community Impact Newspaper analysis. That number is almost certainly a significant undercount.

Restaurant owners in Plano have expressed uncertainty about how sustainable these measures are to keep their businesses afloat.

Jason Graman, managing partner and creator of Plano's Fork and Fire restaurant, said carryout or delivery can account for less than 10% of a casual dining establishment's business in good economic times. An abrupt shift to 100% is not sustainable, he said.

“If we tighten up fast and quick, the belabored little step—the next little step and the next little step—the little steps are meaningless,” Graman said. “But at some point in time, it's just not viable or realistic that we can go, you know, 60 days or 90 days doing this.”

Even restaurants built more around a carryout concept are not equipped to weather the complete, sudden loss of their dine-in crowd.

Scotty P's, for instance, had an established takeout system that was a significant portion of its business, but takeout only accounted for roughly 30% of its income prior to the onset of the current crisis, owner Scott Pontikes said.

Liesbeth Powers contributed to this report.
By Daniel Houston
Daniel Houston covers Plano city government, transportation, business and education for Community Impact Newspaper. A Fort Worth native and Baylor University graduate, Daniel reported previously for The Associated Press in Oklahoma City and The Dallas Morning News.


MOST RECENT

The city of Plano is allocating $500,000 of its funding from the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act to Plano ISD for custodial items and personal protective equipment. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
City of Plano pitches $500,000 toward COVID-19 prevention in Plano ISD

The money comes from funding given to the city through the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act.

John Muns, chairman of the Plano Planning & Zoning Commission, announced his intention to run for mayor in 2021 at an Oct. 19 meeting. (Courtesy city of Plano)
John Muns announces plans to run for mayor of Plano

Muns, who currently serves as chairman of the Plano Planning & Zoning Commission, was appointed by City Council in 2015.

The cafe offers a library of over 600 games and a bistro-style menu. (Courtesy Friend & Foe)
Friend & Foe to shutter after one year of business in Plano

The board game cafe, which opened last September, cited daily, pandemic-driven revenue losses as the reason behind the closure.

The location is owned by local husband-wife team Jesse and Mary Rose Merin. (Courtesy Dickey's Barbecue Pit)
Dickey's Barbecue opens in Frisco and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Collin County commissioners discuss a possible Property Assessed Clean Energy financing program with Julie Partain from Bracewell during their Oct. 19 meeting. (Screenshot courtesy Collin County)
Collin County considering program for energy efficiency projects on commercial, multifamily properties

Collin County is looking into creating a Property Assessed Clean Energy financing program that would encourage energy and water efficiency projects in commercial and multifamily residential properties.

Rollbacks to rail, bus and shuttle service during the pandemic are being lifted by Dallas Area Rapid Transit on Oct. 19 as the agency begins the transition back to regular operations. (Courtesy Dallas Area Rapid Transit)
DART returns some Richardson, Plano bus and rail routes to pre-pandemic frequency levels

Increased ridership and the reopening of the Texas economy are driving the agency to resume service. The changes are effective as of Oct. 19.

A four-story office building was recently completed at the International Business Park campus. (Courtesy Chad M. Davis)
Construction on new office building, amenity center complete at International Business Park in Plano

The four-story building is part of a 300-acre mixed-use development near Coit Road and the President George Bush Turnpike.

Plano budgets for increased costs, some losses in revenue

Totaling $605.1 million, the budget faced economic challenges due to the coronavirus pandemic, including losses in sales taxes, permit and licensing fees, and hotel and motel taxes, all of which are major revenue sources for the city.

The business offers test prep, tutoring, college consulting, for-credit courses and extracurriculars. (Courtesy Pixabay)
Elite Prep Plano relocates to new location

The business offers test prep, tutoring, college consulting, for-credit courses and extracurriculars.

In Denton County, there have been 743 new cases of COVID-19 confirmed by molecular test in the seven reporting days ending Oct. 16. (Community Impact staff)
Tracking COVID-19: Denton County cases trend upward again as officials report antigen test results

Confirmed cases of COVID-19 are on the rise once again in Denton County and throughout the state.

The U.S. Air Force Thunderbirds will be the featured performers at the 30th Anniversary of the Bell Fort Worth Alliance Air Show. (Courtesy of Bell Fort Worth Alliance Air Show)
Thunderbirds to fly this weekend at Fort Worth air show plus more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.