Court decision leaves McKinney's shelter-in-place ordinance intact

Judge Jill Willis of the 429th District Court on March 31 denied Derek V. Baker’s request for a temporary restraining order against McKinney's shelter-in-place ordinance. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Judge Jill Willis of the 429th District Court on March 31 denied Derek V. Baker’s request for a temporary restraining order against McKinney's shelter-in-place ordinance. (Courtesy Fotolia)

Judge Jill Willis of the 429th District Court on March 31 denied Derek V. Baker’s request for a temporary restraining order against McKinney's shelter-in-place ordinance. (Courtesy Fotolia)

A court left McKinney’s shelter-in-place ordinance intact after a resident’s legal challenge claimed the policy conflicted with the county judge’s order.

Judge Jill Willis of the 429th District Court on March 31 denied Derek V. Baker’s request for a temporary restraining order that would have stopped the city of McKinney from enforcing its shelter-in-place ordinance.

As recently as March 27, both Baker and McKinney Mayor George Fuller expected the judge would rule against the city.

But Willis said it became clear in recent days that the state law in question—which allows county emergency orders to supersede those of city mayors—no longer applied after the McKinney City Council extended the mayor’s policy March 27 by adopting it as an ordinance.

“Picking one policy over another based on my own personal preferences would be veering out of my judicial lane,” Willis said.


The lawsuit prompted Fuller and a number of other area mayors to seek clarification from County Judge Chris Hill over the weekend. Hill’s declaration ordered residents of all Collin County cities to stay home except for travel related to essential activities. It went on to define all business as essential.

Since Hill issued his order last week, several cities went on to approve their own shelter-in-place orders, including Frisco and McKinney. These measures were more restrictive than the county’s, closing a number of additional businesses that were deemed nonessential.

The city of Plano was expected to consider adopting a similar policy April 1.

At the mayors’ request, Hill went on to clarify his position at March 30's county commissioners meeting.

“It has always been my intention to allow the cities and the mayors the room to implement their own guidelines in addition to mine,” Hill said at the meeting. “Some mayors have seen fit to put additional guidelines in place. I’m not the arbiter of their guidelines.”
By Daniel Houston
Daniel Houston covers Plano city government, transportation, business and education for Community Impact Newspaper. A Fort Worth native and Baylor University graduate, Daniel reported previously for The Associated Press in Oklahoma City and The Dallas Morning News.


MOST RECENT

Here is the latest data from Collin County's public health department. (Chase Autin/Community Impact Newspaper)
DATA: Confirmed COVID-19 cases in McKinney ZIP codes

McKinney had 10 new cases of the coronavirus reported on May 29.

(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Collin County to transition coronavirus case management to state health department

The Texas Department of State Health Services will perform all COVID-19 case investigations and contact tracing for Collin County following a vote by Collin County Commissioners Court on May 29.

Gather in downtown McKinney has been unable to book events with 25% occupancy restrictions, the owners said. (Community Impact Newspaper file photo)
‘It’s not enough’: McKinney wedding businesses struggle under 25% occupancy restrictions

While restaurants are allowed to operate at 50% capacity, wedding venues in McKinney and throughout Texas are restricted to the initial 25% occupancy Abbott announced at the start of May due to the coronavirus pandemic.

Collin College is providing this assistance in partnership with the U.S. Department of Education and the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act. (Chase Autin/Community Impact Newspaper)
Collin College offering grants, tuition credit for students affected by coronavirus pandemic

Collin College is offering student grants and tuition credit to students who have been affected by the coronavirus pandemic and the college's shift to online courses.

Bloomdale Road in McKinney is being expanded. (Graphic by Michelle Degard/Community Impact Newspaper)
McKinney transportation update: Bloomdale Road expansion

Construction is not expected to affect existing traffic in the surrounding area.

Across the board, many people are still avoiding in-person visits to reduce their risk of exposure to COVID-19. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Patients delay their medical care in McKinney amid pandemic

With the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, people are slow in returning to their doctors.

A LongHorn Steakhouse was expected to open in early 2020 at The Citadel development near I-35W and Heritage Trace Parkway. The opening has been delayed, according to staff. (Ian Pribanic/Community Impact Newspaper)
Tuesday Morning bankruptcy, census data and three other DFW-area stories

Here are five recent updates from the metroplex, on delayed openings, mass layoffs and more.

Those who give blood through May 31 will receive a t-shirt by mail while supplies last. For the month of June, donators will receive a $5 Amazon gift card through email, courtesy Amazon, according to American Red Cross. (Courtesy American Red Cross)
Red Cross offers incentives for blood donations in Dallas-Fort Worth area

The American Red Cross has roughly 1,300 blood donation appointments in North Texas that need to be filled through June 15.

The White Rock Family YMCA in Dallas is among the seven area locations that are set to reopen at partial capacity June 1. (Courtesy YMCA of Metropolitan Dallas)
MAY 31 ROUNDUP: Business news from Dallas-Fort Worth area

Read the latest business news from Dallas-Fort Worth.

Here are the latest coronavirus updates for Collin County readers. (Community Impact staff)
3 additional coronavirus cases reported in McKinney

Health officials reported 19 new cases of coronavirus in Collin County on May 28, including three McKinney cases.

Airport Drive in McKinney is undergoing construction. (Graphic by Michelle Degard/Community Impact Newspaper)
McKinney transportation update: New turn lane coming to Airport Drive

In June, work will continue to pave new northbound lanes north of FM 546 and create a new southbound right-turn lane at Industrial Boulevard, officials said.

The Bodega at Craig Ranch is an upscale convenience store located in McKinney. (Courtesy The Bodega at Craig Ranch)
New convenience store The Bodega at Craig Ranch opens its doors

A new upscale convenience store opened May 25 at Craig Ranch in McKinney.