Lawsuit challenging McKinney recall election favors district vote over citywide vote

Image description
Image description
Voters will decide in May whether to recall a McKinney City Council member whose actions in office have angered some residents.

District 1 Council Member La’Shadion Shemwell is facing a recall election nearly three years into his four-year term, but a federal lawsuit filed by Shemwell against the city could derail that effort.

Shemwell was elected to represent District 1, which stretches along the city’s east side. But the recall process in McKinney mandates that voters citywide get to weigh in on his fate.

The lawsuit claims that the City Charter is unconstitutional because it dilutes the votes of District 1 residents by allowing the entire city to vote in the recall election.

McKinney Mayor George Fuller said he believes the recall election should be citywide.

“His actions do not just impact the district,” said Fuller, who supports Shemwell’s recall. “They impact every single taxpayer in this city.”

The suit seeks to halt the recall process and declare portions of the McKinney City Charter unconstitutional.

“Single-member districts were formed to protect rights of minorities, so that they may be allowed to have their chosen representatives,” Shemwell’s attorney Shayan Elahi said in an email. “Council Member Shemwell is suing the city of McKinney for ‘voter dilution’ under the Voting Rights Acts of 1965 and 1973.”

Single-member districts were first created in McKinney in 1977 through a charter election. The 2010 Census showed less than 50% of residents in District 1 were white, making it a minority-majority district, according to the city attorney. Results from the 2020 Census will determine whether that is still the case, City Attorney Mark Houser said.

“This is voter suppression 2020,” Shemwell said in a Facebook video posted Jan. 22. “They are taking away the [voices] ... in District 1 to vote for who they want to represent them.”

Fuller said he believes Shemwell’s lawsuit represents a “failure to take responsibility for his actions.”

Elahi said Shemwell hopes to have the recall election limited to District 1 voters so that only the people who elected him will decide whether he stays in office.

If the suit is unsuccessful, Shemwell said he will run an “all-out, citywide campaign.”

According to Elahi, a hearing is scheduled for March 30.

“The judge will decide whether the city of McKinney has violated the Constitution by being dismissive of the Voting Rights Act,” Elahi said in the email.

Recall on the ballot

The recall process was triggered by a citizen-initiated petition that received more than 3,100 signatures from registered McKinney voters—nearly 1,000 more than needed.

The petition claims Shemwell “has not upheld his oath of office, has violated the City Charter, has disregarded the City of McKinney Code of Ethical Conduct [and] has not appeared at meetings and events at which he agreed to represent his constituents.” The recall petition also alleges that Shemwell “made inflammatory statements about residents and staff of the city of McKinney.”

Shemwell had the option to resign from office after the petition was certified. He chose instead to proceed with the recall election.

“I will fight with every breath in my body,” Shemwell said at a council meeting. “What is the point of having a First Amendment right to speak if I cannot use it?”

The petition began circulating last year shortly after a series of contentious McKinney City Council meetings were dominated by racially heated conversations.

The most notable meeting took place Oct. 15 when Shemwell suggested the city declare an official “Black State of Emergency” in Texas after two black residents were killed in their homes by police officers in Dallas and Fort Worth during separate incidents.

During the October meeting, Shemwell said, “The state of Texas and its local governments have declared war on black and brown citizens by conspiring to kill, injure, oppress, threaten, and intimidate, and to willfully deprive citizens of their constitutional rights while acting under color of law.”

This statement led to a separate ethics complaint filed by a citizen alleging that Shemwell’s statement violated the city’s “code of ethical conduct in that it alleges criminal conduct by local and state officials.” That complaint is currently under review by a third-party attorney.

Shemwell’s comments have also drawn residents from outside

McKinney to recent council meetings. His supporters recounted personal experiences of racial prejudices and brutality from police officers.

“This isn’t a state of emergency here. This is a state of emergency everywhere,” said Dee Crane, an Arlington resident whose son was killed by an Arlington police officer in 2017. “Mothers like me are suffering in silence, and nobody seems to care except for him.”

Others have criticized some of Shemwell’s controversial statements as well as his conduct.

Shemwell was arrested in December 2018 on suspicion of continuous violence against the family. A grand jury declined to indict him on the third-degree felony charge. He was also arrested earlier that year on suspicion of speeding and failing to report a change of address or name, according to county records.

Shemwell “displayed uncooperative and argumentative behavior” during that traffic stop and directed the officer to contact his department head, according to city documents.

Shemwell told City Council that he should have handled that situation better, but he voted along with the majority of council to approved a censure and resolution expressing disapproval of his behavior.

Fuller said discussions about Shemwell’s potential recall began after the first arrest.

“This has nothing to do with his color,” Fuller said. “It is about character.”

Charter changes

This petition is the first in McKinney’s documented history to trigger a recall election, according to the city.

The recall election comes less than a year after voters approved changes to the City Charter. Those changes ultimately made triggering recall elections easier by decreasing the number of signatures needed and increasing the time frame during which petitions can circulate.

After the changes, residents now have 45 days to turn in signatures to the city secretary. The previous charter gave residents only 30 days.

The charter also requires signatures from at least 30% of the number of voters who cast ballots in the last regular municipal election. As more than 7,080 voters cast ballots in the May 2019 election, the petition needed at least 2,125 signatures to be valid, according to the city secretary’s office.

Under the previous charter, signatures were needed from at least 25% of the total number of voters who cast ballots in the last municipal election, provided that the petition contain signatures of at least 15% of registered voters in McKinney. With more than 103,130 registered voters in that last election, petitioners would have been required to gather nearly 15,500 signatures to trigger a recall, city officials stated.

These were the first changes to the City Charter related to recall petitions since 1959, Houser said. Last year’s charter amendments also clarified that recall elections remain citywide, he said.

What is next

On the May 2 ballot, voters will be asked: “Shall La’Shadion Shemwell be removed from the office of McKinney City Council Member (District 1) by recall?”

If the majority of votes cast are against the recall, Shemwell will remain in office for the rest of his term, which expires in May 2021. But if the majority of votes are in favor of his recall, he will be removed from office.

Council would have the option to fill the vacancy by appointing someone to serve the remainder of his term. Council could also decide to hold a special election, which would be held Nov. 3, Houser said.

“The citizens are in charge of the recall,” Houser said.
By Emily Davis
Emily graduated from Sam Houston State University with a degree in multi-platform journalism and a minor in criminal justice in Spring 2018. During her studies, Emily worked as an editor and reporter at The Houstonian, SHSU's local newspaper. Upon graduation, she began an editorial internship at Community Impact Newspaper in DFW, where she was then hired as Community Impact's first McKinney reporter in August 2018.


Texas Central claims the $12 billion construction process would be privately funded, and the train would transport 6 million annual riders by 2029. (Courtesy Texas Central Partners/Community Impact Newspaper)
State legislators request federal officials halt activity on Texas Central's high-speed rail project

Dozens of elected officials representing Texas requested the U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao put an end to activity related to Texas Central’s high-speed rail project between Dallas and Houston.

Legacy ER & Urgent Care co-founder Dr. Jay Woody said those hurt in household accidents should not delay in seeing a doctor. (Courtesy Legacy ER & Urgent Care)
Legacy ER advising those with medical issues unrelated to coronavirus to not delay doctor visits

Dr. Jay Woody said those that are sick or hurt should not delay in seeing a doctor.

Venue Verona Villa is located on Dallas Parkway. (Courtesy Verona Villa)
ROUNDUP: DFW businesses, ISDs respond to outbreak

Here are five stories on how business and school districts in the metroplex are adapting during the coronavirus pandemic.

McKinney City Council convened for a meeting April 3. (Screenshot via video)
McKinney City Council to consider action to help businesses facing lockout, eviction

McKinney City Council expects to schedule an emergency meeting before April 21 to assist business owners who are facing eviction or delinquent rent fees.

The McKinney Chamber of Commerce is hosting a webinar April 8. (Courtesy Google Maps)
McKinney chamber to host webinar on loans for small businesses

The McKinney Chamber of Commerce is hosting a webinar at noon April 8 focused on loans available to small businesses through the CARES Act.

Area chief appraisers struggle to meet tax calendar deadlines under stay-at-home orders

Property owners typically begin receiving assessed value notices in the mail around this time each year. Already, the region’s largest districts have announced the delay of those letters until the end of April or middle of May.

Plano ISD trustees on March 15 agreed to continue paying district employees as schools close in response to new coronavirus outbreaks across the country. (Daniel Houston/Community Impact Newspaper)
5 of the latest coronavirus updates from the DFW area

Catch up on some of the latest coronavirus-related developments in the Dallas-Fort Worth area below.

Bendt Distilling Co. is making free hand sanitizer for the community and first responders. (Courtesy Bendt Distilling Co.)
Masks and sanitizer: DFW businesses contribute to community health care

Here are nine stories about how metroplex establishments are stepping up to support health care workers and community members amid the coronavirus outbreak.

Abbott's order closes all state parks and historical sites effective 5 p.m. April 7. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Gov. Abbott closes state parks, historical sites due to coronavirus concerns

Abbott said the closure is to help prevent large gatherings and strengthen social distancing.

VIDEO: Texas Tribune interview with Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar about the coronavirus's effects on the state economy

At 8 a.m. April 7, The Texas Tribune will host a live interview with Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar, conducted by Texas Tribune Executive Editor Ross Ramsey.

County commissioners approved funding for $55,000 for Life Path Systems’ four long-term care facilities at an April 6 meeting. (Courtesy Fotolia)
LifePath Systems direct care professionals to receive wage increase over next 2 months

The funding will raise base pay from $10 per hour to $15 per hour for direct care professionals.