PEC rate change targets solar customers, demand for grid alternatives surge

ERCOT's instability has fueled interest in alternative sources of energy, with one solar installer seeing a 400% increase in business in recent months. However, PEC's rate changes could make solar less accessible. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
ERCOT's instability has fueled interest in alternative sources of energy, with one solar installer seeing a 400% increase in business in recent months. However, PEC's rate changes could make solar less accessible. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

ERCOT's instability has fueled interest in alternative sources of energy, with one solar installer seeing a 400% increase in business in recent months. However, PEC's rate changes could make solar less accessible. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Demand for solar systems quadrupled as Central Texas residents searched for ways to avoid black outs and calls for reduced power usage from the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, or ERCOT.

In recent weeks, ERCOT’s calls for reduced power consumption and rolling blackouts due to heat waves once again led some residents to examine alternative sources of electricity and methods of independence from the power grid.

“Whenever it started getting hot, we started seeing ERCOT in the news again. The same statements were being made about conserving energy, [and] immediately I started seeing [increased] demand again,” said Derrick Hoffman, a co-owner of solar installer HESOLAR in Buda.

The surge in inquiries into these systems began after February’s winter storm left tens of thousands of Hays County residents without power for several days while utility companies scrambled to restore power, he said.

“I just had to increase the amount of meetings I could have per day just to keep up and not leave people waiting,” Hoffman said.


The cost of solar and independence

San Marcos resident Clayton Hartley had 28 solar panels installed in January 2020 and was able to ignore ERCOT’s recent calls to cut power consumption, all while feeling good about his family’s carbon footprint because they generated their own power during peak hours, he said.

They also enjoyed significantly lower utility bills, with monthly costs reduced by 50%-60% on average.

“The system probably saved us anywhere from $150-$200 a month,” Hartley said. “Last year, we produced 12 megawatts, ... and the system was designed to do like 10 and a half.”

Additional power production means Hartley’s system could recoup its cost within seven years instead of 10.

However, Hartley lost electricity just like many of his neighbors during the snowstorm.

Sean Taylor of Texas Solar Guys, which is based in Buda, noted homes with solar panels do not avoid outages unless a backup power system is also installed. Batteries charged during the day can also power a home at night.

“As long as the sun’s out, batteries can operate and recharge from the solar, so you have a continuous infinite energy system,” Taylor said.

Due to the cost, Hartley and his wife still have minimal interest in installing a battery system for rare events, such as the winter freeze, but he said they may consider it if such events become more common.

Interest in backup batteries on new installations has increased, though, Taylor said.

“Typically, in this area I wasn’t getting requests for a battery system; it was few and far between,” he said. “But since that winter storm ... pretty much every [solar] system is quoted with a backup as an option.”

Despite the monthly utility savings, Realtor Eric Johnson of Keller Williams Heritage, who sells homes across the region, said solar systems should not be considered for a home’s resale value.

“Your decision to do it shouldn’t strictly be financial because I don’t think the benefits are there yet,” Johnson said.

Solar systems can be seen as a perk, but do not necessarily lead to closed contracts, he said.

Part of the challenge of selling a home with solar panels are the strings sometimes attached. Many solar systems are financed, and the loan is typically transferred to the new homeowner.

The average cost of a 5 kilowatt, or kW, solar system in Texas is $14,700, according to HESOLAR’s website. Backup batteries can double a system’s cost.

“I don’t think anyone that wants solar and batteries is going to be able to even start out under $20,000,” Hoffman said.

Residents can have significant savings on the upfront investment, though. Through 2023, the federal government offers a 26% tax credit on solar systems, which comes out to $3,822 on an average 5-kW system. However, this credit only benefits those who owe money on their income taxes.

Some municipal utilities, such as San Marcos Electric Utility, offer additional benefits, including a rebate of up to $2,500.

Texas also negates the added value of solar to a home’s appraised value for property taxes, Hoffman added.

However, there is a new challenge for Hays County residents considering solar, with one utility altering rates for customers locked into solar investments.

Utility puts premium on solar

On Dec. 18, the board of directors of Pedernales Electric Cooperative, which provides energy to most of Hays County with the exception of San Marcos, voted in favor of new rates targeting at least 4,443 solar customers.

In addition to PEC’s increased rates, which go into effect at the start of 2022, one-time application and connection fees totaling $650 would be added for new solar customers.

“They really kind of swiftly introduced a new rate structure for solar members ... and pretty much nobody was aware of it,” said Hoffman, who is a PEC customer.

PEC noted in a statement it held three virtual town halls with members and met with solar installers. Hoffman, who is both of those things, said he and many other members did not become aware of the new rates until several months after the vote.

A spokesperson for the cooperative declined to comment on how many customers or installers attended the town halls. Following backlash, the board plans to revisit the changes during its July 16 meeting.

Freedom Solar Power, an Austin solar company, said rate changes could increase monthly bills substantially.

In a news release, FSP, which installs solar in the co-op’s territory, presented a bill for an existing PEC customer with solar who would have seen their monthly bill increase from $3.20 to $90.97 in March under the 2022 rates.

New time-of-use rates are broken into five categories, with additional peak demand charges. If a PEC customer’s solar system goes offline during a hot day, forcing them to draw from the grid, bills could skyrocket.

San Marcos Electric Utility and Austin Energy charge flat rates for their customers with solar systems.

According to PEC, “The cooperative is under-collecting from current members on the interconnection rates, mainly from the rate component of these interconnection rates that is allocated to maintain the Cooperative’s distribution/delivery system.”

An April PEC presentation shows revenue was 17% less than its cost of service for solar customers in 2020, but the bills presented by FSP show a disproportionate increase in charges. The utility’s spokesperson declined to comment.

They also declined to answer questions about the energy solar customers put back into the grid, for which they receive a credit, and how it affected PEC’s overhead.

Austin Energy’s website claims residential solar lowers long-term costs for both the utility and ERCOT.

The bill FSP presented showed a PEC customer put 434 more kilowatt-hours back into the grid than they received from the co-op.

Shelling out green to be green

Not every solar customer creates more energy than they consume, though. Hartley has no expectation of his system ever producing more than his family uses.

For some solar users, the appeal goes beyond monetary savings.

“We’re always trying to look for ways to reduce our carbon emissions,” he said. “My wife and I are both interested in climate change and the effects of it ... and that’s just something that we consciously do.”

Despite not seeing a benefit to a home’s resale value, Johnson still praised the environmental perks.

“If you choose to do it to be a good steward of our natural resources, I think there’s a lot of added benefit or positive feelings about that,” he said. “There’s absolute goodness in doing it.”
By Warren Brown
Warren joined Community Impact at the beginning of 2020 as the editor of its New Braunfels paper and now reports the news in San Marcos, Buda and Kyle. Warren previously wrote for the Dallas Observer and Fort Worth Weekly and he brings a passion for truth and equality to his reporting.


MOST RECENT

After a relatively calm June, COVID-19 cases are being reported in increasing numbers in Hays County with the arrival of the Delta strain. Several free vaccine clinics are available this month. (Community Impact staff)
Hays County's COVID-19 cases are on the rise again

After a relatively calm June, COVID-19 cases are being reported in increasing numbers in Hays County with the arrival of the Delta strain. Several free vaccine clinics are available this month.

Leander Marketplace PUD would be located at the northeast corner of Hero Way and US 183. (Screenshot courtesy city of Leander)
Leander eyes development with restaurants, retail; Bin Drop opens in New Braunfels and more top Central Texas news

Read the top business and community news from the past week from the Central Texas area.

In an effort to encourage remaining unvaccinated staff to take the COVID-19 vaccine, the San Marcos Consolidated Independent School District board of trustees approved a one-time $250 stipend incentive July19. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
San Marcos CISD passes vaccination stipend incentive

Every district employee who has already been vaccinated or does so by October, when the stipend will be distributed, will receive the stipend.

Mortgage purchase applications are down year over year, but the Austin housing market remains hot. (Benton Graham/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin housing market still hot but showing signs of slowing down

Experts say that a decrease in mortgage purchase applications points to “a reversion back to norm” in the Austin housing market.

Peter Lake (left), chair of the Public Utility Commission of Texas, and Brad Jones, interim president and CEO of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, provided an update on state regulators' electric grid redesign efforts in Austin on July 22. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Regulators: Texas electric grid prepared for potentially record-breaking demand next week; 'once-in-a-generation reforms' underway

The heads of the agencies in charge of the Texas electric grid met in Austin on July 22 to provide updates on their grid reform efforts.

According to a San Marcos landscaper, caring for your yard can not only keep your neigbors happy, but can also be therapeutic. (Courtesy Unsplash)
Q&A: San Marcos Landscaper talks about how and why to maintain a lawn properly

According to a San Marcos landscaper, caring for your yard can not only keep your neigbors happy, but can also be therapeutic.

Plumbing problems persist months after winter storm

Louis Ybarra of McGinnis Plumbing, which operates in Hays County, said there were multiple instances of people reporting headaches due to carbon monoxide poisoning from improper plumbing fixes done after February's winter storm.

Travis County has been discussing the possibility of a new Samsung facility with Samsung since January. (Community Impact Staff)
Travis County begins incentives negotiations with Samsung for possible $17B facility

Samsung is hoping to finalize a performance agreement by mid-August, which would include information about how the potential facility would affect property taxes.

Massey Wallace and her husband, Allen Wallace, will open a seventh location of Lonestar Kolaches at the former Little Red Wagon in October. (Brooke Sjoberg/Community Impact Newspaper)
Lonestar Kolaches coming to Round Rock; Kilwins sweet shop to open in Georgetown and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Central Texas area, such as the Williamson County judge doubting more shutdowns as coronavirus rates increase.

Texas native Amy Hageman founded Texas Tiny Pools in 2017. (Courtesy Cate Black Photography)
Texas Tiny Pools now serving Austin area; Round Rock movie theater closes and more top Central Texas news

Read the top business and community news from the past week from the Central Texas area.