New legislation aims to protect freestanding emergency room patients

Image description
Image description
Designed as a means of increasing accessibility to health care, freestanding emergency rooms have become a mainstay in Texas’ health care system since they were first approved by the 81st Texas Legislature in 2009.

The Texas Health and Human Services Commission reports more than 200 freestanding ERs operate in Texas today, and new legislation aims to close the knowledge gap between patients and medical providers as well as hold independent and hospital-affiliated freestanding ERs to the same legal standard as hospital ERs.

The 86th Texas Legislature approved two pieces of legislation related to all freestanding ERs operating in Texas. Senate Bill 1264, which was officially enacted Jan. 1, prohibits health care providers from sending hefty medical bills to insured Texans who sought emergency medical care. Under the new legislation, medical providers and insurance companies are to enter into arbitration and negotiate payment before billing the patient.

House Bill 2041, which was introduced by state Rep. Tom Oliverson, R-Cypress, and went into effect Sept. 1, 2019, pertains to enhancing transparency on in-network and out-of-network ER facilities as well as providing patients disclosure statements on facility fees.

Rhonda Sandel, president of the Texas Association of Freestanding Emergency Centers, said she worked closely with Oliverson on HB 2041 and sees the legislation as an opportunity for independent freestanding ERs to operate in line with hospitals. The legislation, Sandel said, updates chapter 254 of Texas’ Health and Safety Code, with independent freestanding ERs now reporting their data just as hospitals do in an effort to increase transparency notices.

Independent freestanding ERs and hospital-affiliated freestanding ERs function virtually the same for the patient, Sandel said. The main difference between the two, Sandel said, comes down to ownership: Independent freestanding ERs can be owned by physicians or a corporation, while hospital-affiliated freestanding ERs are owned directly by a hospital.

“We have always argued and agreed that we need to be treated just like the hospital-based ERs are to prevent patients’ confusion,” Sandel said. “We requested legislation; we wanted transparency; we worked with Dr. Oliverson on this bill; and we agreed with it. We wanted it so that we could see and we would be on a level playing field with the hospitals.”

Texas Hospital Association could not be reached immediately for comment on recent legislation regarding surprise medical billing.

Nurse and patient perspectives

Jaime Simon has been a registered nurse for 19 years and first began her career in the ER at St. David’s Round Rock Medical Center. As a freestanding ER nurse for the past five years, Simon said these facilities have given her increased flexibility in her own work schedule, ensuring ER workers are not overtired or working through breaks.

Simon also added an important component to freestanding ERs is that they take some of the burden off traditional hospital ERs, allowing her to treat more patients in a shorter period of time.

“The volume at freestandings is much less, so we get to cater to our patients,” Simon said.

Patsy Bradford, a Pflugerville resident, said now that the city has its Baylor Scott & White Medical Center with an attached ER, she does not see the value of visiting a freestanding ER—especially if patients have to be transported to a hospital in an emergency anyway.

Miriam Moorman, also of Pflugerville, said her reservation about freestanding emergency rooms comes from the potential costs affiliated with visits along with whether insurance companies are in-network and will provide coverage for an ER visit.

“Who, in an emergency, is going to be calling their insurance company to see where they can go?” Moorman said. “People who need and deserve medical care may end up with bills that are more damaging to them than the medical condition for which they were treated.”

Increasing accessibility

Sandel said some of the negative connotations affiliated with independent freestanding ERs have extended from patients’ complaints filed against hospital-affiliated ERs. She said her concern with some of the ways in which freestanding ERs have been presented, both in the media and in the Legislature, could impact patients’ willingness to seek treatment for potentially serious health complications.

“Our goal is to be advocates for patients and to provide quality health care and make sure that there’s access for all,” Sandel said. “And there should not be any regulation driven by insurance companies or otherwise that prohibits access to health care, and emergency health care at that.”

Following introduction of his bill, SB 1264, in 2019, state Sen. Kelly Hancock, R-North Richland Hills, said his bill would help remove patients from billing disputes between insurance providers and health care agencies, according to an Apr. 16 article by The Texas Tribune.

Christina Rose, a Hutto resident, said she has visited both First Choice Emergency Room in Pflugerville and Five Star ER in Hutto. One of the biggest misconceptions patients might have with ERs, Rose said, is conflating them with urgent care facilities.

Urgent care facilities are similar to a traditional doctor’s visit, just with longer hours and weekend openings, Sandel said. Urgent cares typically treat more minor ailments that are not life-threatening but need to receive medical treatment.

“I know a lot of people go [to emergency rooms] for things that aren’t necessarily emergencies, but maybe they aren’t aware that there’s an urgent care that they can go to,” Rose said. “The more people that come in that have an issue that’s greater than yours, the longer you’re going to sit and wait.”

Following her freestanding ER visit, Rose said staff walked her through how the billing process would work as well as how to challenge any potential claim by her insurance company that it was out-of-network and not covered by her insurance plan.

Sandel said as SB 1264 goes into effect and prohibits surprise medical billing, it is important for there to be increased transparency among insurance providers to protect patients’ right to access emergency medical care in potentially serious situations.
By Kelsey Thompson

Kelsey Thompson is the reporter for Round Rock, Pflugerville and Hutto, where her work focuses on education, city government and community development. Originally from upstate New York, Kelsey relocated to Austin after graduating from Syracuse University in May 2019.


(Taylor Jackson Buchanan/Community Impact Newspaper)
After more than 30 years, Little Red Wagon Hamburgers closes in Round Rock

The restaurant served breakfast, lunch and dinner in Round Rock, offering chicken-fried steak, tacos, hamburgers and enchiladas.

the globe drive-in hutto
The Globe Drive-In movie theater to begin screening cult classics, family-friendly films in Hutto

The Globe Drive-In will feature fan favorite titles, such as "Back to the Future," "The Princess Bride" and "La La Land," during its winter season, running through Feb. 29.

A demographer told trustees Jan. 16 that PfISD could realistically add 3,400 students in the next five years. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Demographer projects explosive growth in Pflugerville ISD's eastern edges

PfISD is experiencing near-record growth in student enrollment in the current school year, a demographer told trustees Jan. 16.

Hutto City Council finalized its independent, third-party investigation into the city manager's office at its Jan. 16 meeting. (Kelsey Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Hutto City Council votes to finalize independent, third-party investigative report into city manager's office

Hutto City Council finalized the independent, third-party investigation into the city manager's office at its Jan. 16 meeting.

pencils and pens resting on a stack of spiral notebooks fotolia stock image
DATA: Round Rock ISD annual report highlights increasing student diversity, low dropout rates

Among the findings: State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness, or STAAR, test scores that outpace the region and the state.

zanjero park water
Travis County commissioners pursue easement to bring water to Las Lomitas subdivision

Travis County commissioners are working to address colonias—unincorporated areas in the county that lack basic utilities.

Austin Public Health is investigating a confirmed rubella case, the first case of the contagious viral infection in Travis County since 1999. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Austin Public Health confirms city’s first rubella case since 1999

Austin Public Health is investigating a confirmed rubella case, the first case of the contagious viral infection in Travis County since 1999.

Travis County commissioners will receive preliminary estimates for a new peace officer step pay scale at their Jan. 28 meeting. (Courtesy Travis County Sheriff's Office)
Travis County commissioners consider revisions to peace office pay

Travis County commissioners are considering options that will revise the pay scale for peace officers, including law enforcement, corrections and park rangers.

(Courtesy Hotworx)
Infrared fitness studio Hotworx to open a Round Rock location

The studio offers a 24-hour virtually instructed exercise program that uses infrared saunas.

Stockade Kitchen will offer American comfort food dishes in a fast-casual restaurant environment, according to restaurant staff. (Kelsey Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Stockade Kitchen, an American comfort food restaurant, coming to Hutto

Stockade Kitchen marks a new restaurant concept for Stockade Companies, serving up American comfort food in a fast-casual setting.

Round Rock ISD is among four Texas school districts awarded the Caudill Award, recognized for its Nature to Neighborhood Studio at Laurel Mountain Elementary School. (Courtesy Round Rock ISD)
Round Rock ISD awarded in school architecture competition

Round Rock ISD is among four Texas school districts awarded the Caudill Award, the highest honor in the annual Exhibit of School Architecture competition.

Texas oil and gas industry could see a major slowdown in 2020

The oil and natural gas industry paid a record-setting $16.3 billion in taxes and royalties to local governments and the state in 2019, the Texas Oil and Gas Association announced Tuesday.

Back to top