Some in Round Rock ISD divided over Westwood High School pilot program to end class rankings

The district committee that studied the class-rank policy examined several rankings options, including:

The district committee that studied the class-rank policy examined several rankings options, including:

Parents, stakeholders and students flooded Round Rock High School’s lecture hall in September and October for discussions about Westwood High School’s class-rank policy. The policy—the subject of debate since 2010—was drastically altered at a September Round Rock ISD board of trustees meeting and has its share of supporters and opponents at each of the five district high schools.

A year and a half ago, district leaders again initiated discussion on the topic with a committee to study whether to eliminate the ranking system for students who are not in the top 10 percent. The state requires a top 10 percent ranking for the automatic admissions program but has no other requirements for ranking.

Some schools, including Westlake High School in Eanes ISD, have said doing away with the policy allows high-achieving students who miss this mark to be evaluated more holistically and therefore increases student acceptance rates into their school of choice.

As part of the study, students and parents were polled for their opinion. Per the survey, Westwood respondents were overwhelmingly supportive of the elimination proposal compared with peers from other high schools.

As a result, the RRISD board decided to implement a pilot program at Westwood High School that would effectively end class ranking outside of the top 10 percent, effective Oct. 1, for the 2017-18 school year.

Becky Donald, area superintendent for the Westwood Learning Community and the leader of the study, said Westwood was the right school to study because of its high-achieving academic student body.

“If you look at [Westwood’s] academic population of students, they have a larger cluster of very high-performing students,” she said. “Everyone has them, but Westwood right now has 63 National Merit semifinalists, and most schools get anywhere from six to 12-14.”

Following this study, RRISD will review results from college acceptances and collect feedback. Donald said an exit survey for graduating seniors will play a big role in this process.

She said, however, that one year of this study may not yield enough information to make an informed decision for the rest of the district.

“We may not see until we get a couple of years of good data how the class rank decision benefits our students,” Donald said.

Prior to trustees approving the program, a large group of parents spoke in support of removing the class-rank policy.

Hiten Patel, a parent of a Westwood student, said the rank policy increases stress and anxiety around the time of college admissions. Eliminating it, he said, would decrease these factors.

The other side of the debate came out in full force following the decision at the Oct. 19 board meeting.

More than 15 speakers expressed dismay over the end of the program, saying it would negatively affect students and preclude them from being admitted in other ways to universities.

Donald said all feedback from both sides of the issue will be included in the review of the program.

“[The next decision] is up to the board, but we will do our homework in evaluating it, to see feedback and how it went,” Donald said.
SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

Repeal of straight-ticket voting could mean longer lines ahead in Travis County this fall

The Texas Legislature repealed straight-ticket voting in 2017, but the change was not implemented until this year. In November 2018, more than 60% of county voters chose the straight-ticket option.

Round Rock ISD began implementing the program on campuses in fall 2019, with campuses added every few weeks to the busing system. (Courtesy Round Rock ISD Transportation Department)
Round Rock ISD to start SMART Tag bus transportation program districtwide in March

Round Rock ISD began implementing the program on campuses in fall 2019, with campuses added every few weeks to the busing system.

Baylor Scott & White Medical Center-Pflugerville was announced as the 2020 TrueNorth Award winner for its nursing certification efforts in a Feb. 24 news release. (Courtesy Christina Millweard)
Pflugerville's Baylor Scott & White Medical Center wins 2020 TrueNorth Award for nursing certification

One hundred percent of Baylor Scott & White Medical Center-Pflugerville's operating room nursing staff is certified.

(Courtesy Tiny Aquatics)
Tiny Aquatics opens in Round Rock

The store sells fish, shrimp, snails and other aquatic life as well as plants; rocks; moss; and hardware, such as aquarium tanks.

Kilwins, a hand-crafted chocolate shop, is the fourth confirmed tenant at Hutto's upcoming Co-Op District. (Courtesy Kilwins)
Kilwins to open sweets shop in Hutto's Co-Op District

Kilwins specializes in a range of sweet treats, including hand-crafted chocolates, fudge, caramel apples and its original-recipe ice cream.

Pflugerville ISD administration building
DATA: See which Pflugerville ISD schools gained—and lost—the most students with new enrollment zone changes

Pflugerville ISD's two easternmost campuses, Mott Elementary School and Cele Middle School, are projected to gain the most relief from overcrowding due to new enrollment zone changes.

Hutto announces top 3 search firm candidates for city manager hiring process

Hutto City Council approved interviews with Strategic Government Resources, Bakertilly and Affion Public in its search for a permanent city manager.

Krab Kingz Seafood's menu includes crab, shrimp, sausage, potatoes, corn and boiled egg, all seasoned in a signature boil. It also offers a garlic butter sauce that comes in five different flavors. (Courtesy Krab Kingz Seafood Cypress)
Krab Kingz Seafood celebrates opening in Pflugerville

Krab Kingz Seafood's menu includes crab, shrimp, sausage, potatoes, corn and boiled egg as well as a garlic butter sauce that comes in five different flavors.

The Round Rock Parks and Recreation Department will celebrate the grand opening of The Yard on Feb. 22, an outdoor fitness center added to the city's Clay Madsen Recreation Center. (Courtesy city of Round Rock)
The Yard marks grand opening at Round Rock's Clay Madsen Recreation Center

The Round Rock Parks and Recreation Department will celebrate the grand opening of The Yard on Feb. 22, an outdoor fitness center added to the city's Clay Madsen Recreation Center.

The PfISD Board of Trustees voted Feb. 20 to change enrollment boundaries or program offerings in the 2020-21 school year for eight schools. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Looking to get ahead of crowded schools east of SH 130, Pflugerville ISD shifts enrollment boundaries

The PfISD Board of Trustees voted Feb. 20 to change enrollment boundaries or program offerings in the 2020-21 school year for eight schools.

Hutto City Council unanimously approved a resolution of support related to a proposed affordable housing project, Carver Ridge Apartments, located near FM 1660 and CR 137. (Kelsey Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Hutto City Council unanimously approves resolution of support for affordable housing proposal

Hutto City Council unanimously approved a resolution of support related to a proposed affordable housing project, Carver Ridge Apartments, located near FM 1660 and CR 137.

The Round Rock ISD school calendar for 2021-22 includes the districtwide holiday of Martin Luther King Jr. Day on Jan. 17. (Courtesy Fotolia)
2021-22 academic calendar approved for Round Rock ISD

The district’s first day of school is scheduled for Aug. 18, 2021, and the 2021-22 school year will conclude May 26, 2022.

Back to top