Public weighs in as Del Valle ISD considers tax incentives for Tesla, a move which could stave off recapture

A photo of four Tesla vehicles
Electric carmaker Tesla is considering building a new factory in the Del Valle area of Southeast Travis County. (Courtesy Tesla)

Electric carmaker Tesla is considering building a new factory in the Del Valle area of Southeast Travis County. (Courtesy Tesla)

Officials from Del Valle ISD are weighing the benefits of a tax incentives deal that would encourage electric automaker Tesla to establish a presence in Southeast Travis County in exchange for academic and career training partnerships for the district.

Tesla has identified a 2,100-acre site along the Colorado River as a potential location for its next gigafactory, where the company’s new Cybertruck and other vehicle models would be produced. While Tesla simultaneously eyes the Tusla, Okla. area, Travis County and DVISD could propose incentive agreements that would soften the impact of Texas’ comparatively high property tax rates. Without such incentives, Tesla representatives have said a factory in Texas would not be economically feasible.

DVISD trustees, staff, Tesla representatives and community members all weighed in on the district’s proposed tax agreement at a June 25 public hearing.

The role of recapture

DVISD Superintendent Annette Tielle presented on the proposed Chapter 313 agreement, which would limit the property taxes Tesla paid toward the district’s maintenance and operations for a 10-year period by capping the taxable value of Tesla’s project at $80 million. That would be a substantive decrease from the estimated $600 million the project would be worth.

With the $80 million cap, DVISD would rake in around $776,000 annually from Tesla in maintenance and operations taxes in addition to a supplemental $1 million annual donation from Tesla to DVISD’s maintenance & operations fund. Currently, DVISD receives $48,500 per year from the same site under its current use as a sand and gravel mining operation.

According to Tielle, the Chapter 313 agreement would prevent the district from becoming subject to recapture, despite the increase in tax revenue. Also known as Texas’ Robin Hood Law, recapture redistributes revenue from wealthy districts where tax income exceeds state per-student funding averages. From that view, DVISD would not lose tax revenue from Tesla by entering a Chapter 313 agreement, although other low-income districts ultimately could.

Protecting would-be workers

Tesla has said it will bring a number of academic and job-training opportunities to DVISD, including an apprenticeship program that would act as a pipeline for high school students to gain employment at Tesla after graduation. Additionally, Tesla would collaborate with the district on automation curriculum in robotics, engineering and/or manufacturing that would give students skills for employment at the company.

“We want our students to have the best of the best,” Tielle said. “This is something we know would take our students to very high heights.”

DVISD Chief Academic Officer Kerry Gain also praised these opportunities, particularly the benefits the district’s new robotics program would see, and said many students are already in computer science and related classes that make them prime candidates for Tesla’s student programs.

“We have 2,100 students right now in Del Valle who are primed and ready for the support that Tesla would provide,” Gain said.

According to Gain, 115 graduates from a high school that partners with Tesla’s gigafactory in Sparks, Nev. have been employed by the company.

However, some community members who spoke during public comment at the June 25 meeting expressed concern that Tesla would not offer adequate protections for DVISD graduates entering the workforce, citing past Occupational Safety & Health Administration violations and efforts to quash union organization.

“Frankly, I think Tesla is promising the world, but they have yet to promise that they will treat their future workers, our students, right,” local resident Alex Murphy said.

Many speakers from the community called for the district to request contractual promises for the treatment of workers, something that district representatives said was not legally allowed.

“As a community, we deserve a partner that will put those promises in writing,” said Jeremy Hendricks, an Austin resident and representative for the Southwest Laborer’s District Council. “Please use your positions to ask the hard questions of Tesla.”

Meanwhile, Tesla representatives defended their record on worker safety and treatment at the hearing, responding to similar accusations leveled during public comment at a June 23 meeting of the Travis County Commissioners Court, which is also considering incentives for the company.

“We’re on track to participate in OSHA’s voluntary protection program in Nevada and California, and we would expect to do the same in any factory we locate in, whether it’s in Texas or elsewhere,” said Rohan Patel, Tesla senior global director of public policy and business development.

Privileging community voices

Throughout DVISD’s public hearing, both district representatives and community members said they were pleased to have the eyes of the larger Austin-Travis County area on Del Valle, an economically disadvantaged area that is often overlooked, according to multiple speakers.

“I’ve never seen so much attention given to the Del Valle area and the Del Valle community since [Tesla’s] announcement of possibly relocating here. To all of those who have ignored us for decades, welcome to Del Valle,” DVISD trustee Susanna Woody said.

Del Valle community members, including Daniel Segura-Kelly, a member of several local democratic organizations, also encouraged Tesla to take stock of the opinions of Del Valle area residents while fielding feedback from across Austin and Central Texas.

“As history tells us, East Austin will hear from many folks who don’t live in East Austin but have a lot of opinions about what East Austin needs,” Segura-Kelly said in a statement directed toward Tesla. “I hope that you’ll continue to speak for us, the folks who live here, who raise our families here and want to grow here.”
By Olivia Aldridge
Olivia is the reporter for Community Impact's Southwest Austin edition. She graduated from Presbyterian College with a bachelor's degree in English and creative writing in 2017. Olivia was a reporter and producer at South Carolina Public Radio in Columbia, South Carolina before joining Community Impact in Austin.


New signage will be placed at Blue Hole Park notifying people that alcohol is prohibited. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
No alcohol at Blue Hole Park: Georgetown creates ordinance to address increase in police calls

Georgetown PD said "disturbances, fights, welfare concerns and even medical calls can and often do have alcohol as a proximate cause."

Leander ISD trustees and staff are pictured in this screen grab of a previous online meeting. (Screenshot courtesy LISD)
Leander ISD to discuss fall instruction, equity, diversity at July 16 meeting

At the July 16 agenda review meeting, Leander ISD plans to discuss several items in advance of the start of the school year, which is Aug. 13.

Paperboy's brick-and-mortar restaurant is now open in East Austin. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Paperboy opens brick-and-mortar restaurant in East Austin

The breakfast and lunch spot has closed its two food trucks, which were located in East Austin and South Austin.

Hushpuppies stuffed with bacon wrapped shrimp and jalapenos are among menu offerings. (Courtesy Kenneth Rector Jr.)
Rec's Hushpuppie Heaven to open permanent storefront in Pflugerville

Rec's Hushpuppie Heaven will open a storefront at 200 E. Pecan St., Ste. 1, Pflugerville, this fall.

Jjim BBQ will be opening in the fall on South Lamar Boulevard. (Courtesy Jjim BBQ)
New Korean spot JJim BBQ to open in Lamar Union this fall

Min Choe, CEO and co-owner of Tso Chinese Delivery, is also part of the ownership group for the new restaurant.

During its July 15 budget workshop, the Rollingwood City Council held its second budget workshop, with the first occurring June 17. (Courtesy Fotolia)
Water fund, salaries focus of mid-July Rollingwood budget planning

During its July 15 budget workshop, the Rollingwood City Council held its second budget workshop, with the first occurring June 17.

During City Council’s July 15 meeting, officials decided to scrap a plan to rezone the residential property at 503 Vale St. in order to possibly use it for a police building annex. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)
Due to overwhelming community outcry, Rollingwood terminates contract on potential police department annex

During City Council’s July 15 meeting, officials decided to scrap the project in a unanimous vote. This came after council had previously postponed a vote to rezone the property from a residential to governmental site during a June 17 meeting.

A photo of a charcuterie board in a takeout box
Dripping Springs dining establishment Epicure relocates, pivots business to adapt during pandemic

A popular fine dining spot has downsized and focused its business on wine and charcuterie sales.

A teal graphic that reads "Today's coronavirus updates"
Travis County sees 572 new coronavirus cases

Meanwhile, Austin Public Health staff are readying the Austin Convention Center as a field hospital.

A photo of a bench and trees from Headwaters at dusk
Dripping Springs ISD finalizes acquisition of future elementary and middle school site at Headwaters development

The schools will eventually be constructed on the property located off Hwy. 290.

Hays County reported one additional death related to coronavirus July 15. (Community Impact staff)
Hays County reports 70 new coronavirus cases, 1 death July 15

Numbers provided by the Hays County Local Health Department showed 70 new coronavirus cases July 15, raising the number of confirmed cases to 3,769.

Check out Williamson County housing market data for the first half of 2020. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
BREAKDOWN: Williamson County housing market returns after dip in April and May

Check out Williamson County housing market data for the first half of 2020.