Golden-cheeked warbler may shed 'endangered' designation

The Texas Public Policy Foundation intends to file a lawsuit that, if successful, would remove from the federal endangered species list the golden-cheeked warbler, a small black songbird with a yellow head that nests exclusively in Central Texas.

The TPPF notified the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service of the impending lawsuit March 9. The lawsuit is a response to a petition the group filed in 2016 to delist the bird, a request that USFWS denied, said Ted Hadzi-Antich, senior attorney for the TPPF Center for the American Future.

Robert Henneke, director of the Center for the American Future, said the warbler is a recovered species and should no longer be regulated by the federal government under the Endangered Species Act.

Endangered species are animals or plants that are in danger of extinction, and recovered species are no longer at risk, according to the USFWS.

History of warbler protection

The warbler was listed as an endangered species in 1990 based on habitat loss and destruction to juniper and oak woodlands, where the bird nests, said Lisa O’Donnell, senior biologist for the Balcones Canyonlands Preserve.

The warbler’s population was 13,800 in 1990, with a habitat in Texas of 1,270 square miles, Hadzi-Antich said.LTW-2017-04-25-2

The BCP was established in 1992, and by 1996 a plan for Austin and Travis County to acquire additional preserve land and manage the preserve for endangered species was put in place.

“Land acquisition and managing habitat is so important,” O'Donnell said. “For species that depend on old growth habitats, it is really hard to recreate [the habitat] once its lost.”

In 2014, the USFWS conducted a five-year review of the species and determined the warbler continued to be in danger of extinction, USFWS Media Coordinator Lesli Gray said. 

Hadzi-Antich said the TPPF filed the petition to delist the warbler in 2016 based on new research from the Texas A&M Institute of Renewable Natural Resources. The program estimated the species' population was 19 times larger than it was in 1990. The service again reviewed the warbler’s status after the petition was filed.

“We made the determination that the petition didn’t present substantial information to warrant delisting the bird at that time,” Gray said. “It’s not just about population numbers but the current threats it may face.”

Why delist the warbler?

“The point of the Endangered Species Act is to protect species that are in danger,” Hadzi-Antich said. “Obviously, we’re in favor of that, but if a species is no longer threatened, there’s no need for these protections.”

However, he said delisting the warbler is more than just a formality based on the species' signs of recovery.

“Before developers can get any kind of federal permits to construct a building or road, the FWS looks at a proposed project and determines whether the species [is] going to be impacted,” he said. “It could take years for them to issue a biological opinion, which could block a project. It’s potentially a very heavy burden on businesses and individuals if a species is in the way of productive human activity.”

What’s next?

Although the lawsuit will not officially be filed until May, if the warbler was eventually delisted, O’Donnell said it would be more important than ever to protect the land that is already a part of the BCP.

“[The warbler] nests in a very limited range,” she said. “In terms of habitat loss due to growth, you can drive through the Hill Country and see for yourself. That habitat is not increasing.”

Austin Water Assistant Director Daryl Slusher, who manages Austin’s Wildland Division, said the preserve is home to a number of other animals, and conservation would continue even without the warbler’s endangered status.

“We would still continue to manage the preserve and protect other endangered species,” he said. “Hopefully [those efforts] would protect the warbler’s habitat as well.”

For any species that is delisted, the service has a monitoring plan that tracks the species for at least five years, Gray said.

“The service monitors the species to make sure things are going in the right direction and there are no additional threats,” she said.

By Nicholas Cicale

Nick was born in Long Island, New York and grew up in South Florida. He graduated from Florida State University in 2012 with a bachelor's degree in writing and a minor in music. Nick was a journalist for three years at the St. James Plaindealer in Minnesota before moving to Austin to join Community Impact Newspaper in 2016.


Andrew Clark and Andrea Willott are directors on Bee Cave's Economic Development Board. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
City leaders in Bee Cave working on additional assistance plan for local businesses

Economic leaders in Bee Cave are working on plans to help small businesses as much as possible amid fiscal pitfalls created by the COVID-19 crisis.

The city of Austin issued a stay-at-home order March 24. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Coronavirus update: Second death confirmed in Austin, Travis County as local cases rise to 206

Keep up with updates from Travis County and Austin for the week of March 30 here.

Precision Regenerative and Functional Medicine is run by Dr. Mihnea Dumitrescu. (Courtesy Precision Regenerative and Functional Medicine)
Precision Regenerative and Functional Medicine relocates clinic in West Lake Hills

The clinic relocated within the Westlake Oaks Office Park.

Dr. Liam Fry speaks about two nursing home isolation facilities that will be coming to the Austin and Travis County areas on March 30 at the city of Austin's Combined Transportation, Emergency, and Communications Center. (Courtesy ATXN)
Facilities to isolate nursing home residents who test positive for coronavirus will be set up in Travis, Williamson counties

The facilities will be for individuals living at nursing homes who do not need hospitalization or have already been discharged from the hospital.

Austin Regional Clinic Cedar Park
Austin Regional Clinic launches 5 drive-up coronavirus testing locations

Austin Regional Clinic will open drive-up COVID-19 testing sites across five sites.

Bee Cave City Council Member Bill Goodwin has resigned from his positions on the board of the West Travis County Public Utility Agency and the Bee Cave Economic Development Board. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Bill Goodwin resigns positions on economic board and West Travis County Public Utility Agency

Bee Cave City Council Member Bill Goodwin has resigned from his positions on the board of the West Travis County Public Utility Agency and the Bee Cave Economic Development Board.

NBISD workers deliver meals to students at the Veramendi Elementary School meal pickup location March 17. (Courtesy New Braunfels ISD)
Elections, closures, instruction: See what Austin-area schools are doing in wake of coronavirus

During the coronavirus situation, schools have had to make changes in how they deliver instruction, meals, elections and more. Below is a roundup of what local schools are doing to serve students and families.

Capital Metro station
All Capital Metro fares will be free throughout April

Beginning April 1, riders will not have to pay Capital Metro operators or use the farebox.

Mayor Pro Tem Bill Goodwin, center, and Council Member Jon Cobb, left, resigned their posts during a March 28 City Council meeting. Council Member Kara King, right, is now mayor elect of Bee Cave. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Bee Cave Mayor Bill Goodwin and Council Member Jon Cobb resign during special meeting

A special called meeting that initially appeared focused on the removal of a key Bee Cave official due to perceived missteps and lackluster response to crisis ended in the abrupt resignation of both the mayor and a council member.

The Lake Travis ISD board of trustees met virtually March 25 for its regular board meeting. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)
Vail Divide progress, drug testing updates, COVID-19 news, and more from Lake Travis ISD’s first digital meeting March 25

All district facilities are closed until April 13 to mitigate the spread of COVID-19, however, the meeting’s agenda included a variety of subjects from a drug testing program to construction progress.

The district delivered iPads to Dell Seton Medical Center March 27. (Courtesy Eanes ISD)
Eanes ISD donates 70 iPads to Dell Seton Medical Center

The district quickly gathered 70 previously retired iPads to aid those working during the COVID-19 outbreak.

An action item to potentially postpone the May 2 trustee election is listed on the Eanes ISD March 31 meeting agenda. (Taylor Jackson Buchanan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Eanes ISD to discuss whether to postpone its May 2 election in light of COVID-19

The Eanes ISD board of trustees will take action on the May 2 election during its scheduled board meeting

Back to top