Nightingale workforce housing proposal fails before Lakeway council

The Nightingale at Lakeway workforce housing complex, had it been approved, would have brought 248 units at reduced rent. A compromise proposal to allow for less units to be built at the same location was denied Nov. 15 by Lakeway City Council. (Courtesy Conine Residential Group Inc.)
The Nightingale at Lakeway workforce housing complex, had it been approved, would have brought 248 units at reduced rent. A compromise proposal to allow for less units to be built at the same location was denied Nov. 15 by Lakeway City Council. (Courtesy Conine Residential Group Inc.)

The Nightingale at Lakeway workforce housing complex, had it been approved, would have brought 248 units at reduced rent. A compromise proposal to allow for less units to be built at the same location was denied Nov. 15 by Lakeway City Council. (Courtesy Conine Residential Group Inc.)



In a 4-3 vote, the Lakeway City Council voted Nov. 15 against a compromise measure to allow for the development of workforce housing on an undeveloped site at the intersection of RM 620 and Nightingale Lane.

The measure, offered by council member Laurie Higginbotham, would have allowed a density of 20 workforce housing units per acre–less than the roughly 32 units per acre offered earlier in the evening by Conine Residential Group Inc. and its Nightingale at Lakeway proposal.

Higginbotham said she made the motion to balance Lakeway’s generally accepted need for affordable housing and the concerns surrounding neighbors of the Nightingale project had for the density of the Conine housing proposal. Those living nearby the proposed site said during a public hearing that the amount of traffic generated by the project would be unsafe for the neighborhood.

Joining Higginbotham in voting for the lower-density proposal were council members Gretchen Vance and Sanjeev Kumar. Voting against the proposal were Mayor Tom Kilgore, Mayor Pro Tem Louis Mastrangelo and council members Keith Trecker and Steve Smith.


“I think it was a missed opportunity, but I don’t think it was the last opportunity,” Higgenbotham said after the vote. “I think there is universal support for workforce housing. I think the question is always where and how dense.”

Opposition to Higginbotham’s motion centered around the need to adhere to the city’s future land use map, or FLUM, which Higginbotham’s motion would have altered to allow for a residential apartment complex to be built at Nightingale Lane. The current FLUM calls for commercial development at this location.

“I still have great difficulty giving up the commercial lot on 620,” Kilgore said during a council discussion of the Nightingale proposal.

Kilgore said the city has a need to generate sales tax revenue from areas designated for commercial development and that it has made an incremental step toward workforce housing by requiring the developer of The Square at Lohmans to investigate affordable rental units within its mixed-use development planned for acreage off Lohmans Crossing.

Earlier in the meeting Kent and Meg Conine of Conine Residential Group presented their workforce housing plan to Lakeway council members. They had sought to create a public utility district, or PUD, on the 7.6 acres of land at Nightingale Lane and RM 620. That PUD would have allowed for a 248-unit apartment complex intended for people earning on average 60% or less of the area median income. That works out to between $40,000-$60,000 depending on a family’s size, according to statements made by Meg Conine during remarks to council.

Higgenbottom’s motion would have allowed for a complex with about 152 units, and the city’s current zoning for multifamily residential housing allows for a complex with 12 units per acre for a total of 91 units.

After the meeting Kent Conine said he had no comment on the council’s action, but during his presentation to council he said the Nightingale proposal was the city's best option to build workforce housing and that the city has no other feasible locations for workforce housing due to the restrictive zoning within Lakeway.

“Workforce housing is difficult to deliver under any circumstances–and Lakeway does not currently have the land use tools to achieve it,” according to a statement Conine presented to council members.

During a public hearing on the matter, local residents and business owners came out for and against the Nightingale workforce housing complex.

Local business owners said they have trouble retaining employees who drive from other communities into Lakeway to work.

Christy Black, who operates Primrose Schools in Bee Cave and Lakeway, said business owners deserve the support of local government through initiatives like workforce housing.

"Not supporting workforce housing feels like you are not supporting your businesses," she said in her remarks to council.
By Greg Perliski

Editor, Lake Travis/Westlake & Northwest Austin

Greg joined Community Impact as an editor in November 2020. In the communities he covers, Greg reports on local government, transportation, real estate development and business. He has written for newspapers, online publications and corporate communications teams. Greg earned a journalism degree from the University of Texas at Austin.



MOST RECENT

Special Olympics athlete Benji Garcia speaks to the crowd with his Special Olympics Unified partner Mady Zamora during the Winter Games 2022 press conference. (Grace Dickens/Community Impact Newspaper)
Hill Country prepares for Special Olympics Texas in February

Bee Cave and Lakeway are sponsoring the upcoming Special Olympics Texas Winter Games 2022, which will likely bring thousands to the area, according to the organization.

Austin City Council meets for its final regular meeting of 2021 on Dec. 9. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Hall notebook: Council circles back to housing policy in last meeting of 2021

Several items on council's Dec. 9 agenda follow up on last week's housing policy discussions.

Tewbeleaux's Cajun Grill opened in Northwest Austin on Nov. 2. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: Tewbeleaux's Cajun Grill opens first Central Texas location in Northwest Austin; House of Pies opens in Cypress and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 8.

(Courtesy Capriotti's Sandwich Shop)
Made-to-order sandwich shop opening in Bee Cave off RM 620

The restaurant has more than 110 locations in the nation.

Police Chief Joseph Chacon briefed Austin City Council on the police department's work with sexual assault cases and victims Dec. 7. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin police chief provides update on handling of sexual assault cases, support for victims

Police Chief Joseph Chacon said his department has increased officer training and collaboration with victim services experts this year.

Changes to short-term rentals and a search for city manager could be on the way for residents of West Lake Hills. (Grace Dickens/Community Impact Newspaper)
Short-term rentals, opioid settlement up for discussion at West Lake Hills City Council meeting Dec. 8

The city will potentially change the process for short-term rentals and consider a recruitment firm to find a new city manager.

The Gringo's location in Katy is pictured. A new Conroe location is planned for late 2022. (Courtesy NewQuest Properties)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: Gringo's restaurant confirmed for Conroe Waterfront Center; Austin’s longest-standing H-E-B to be rebuilt and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 7.

A child gets a COVID-19 shot in November, shortly after the Food and Drug Administration authorized use of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine for children ages 5 through 11. (Courtesy Dell Children’s Medical Center)
Travis County, Austin Public Health report uptick in COVID-19 vaccine demand

Officials said that booster and pediatric shots are driving the surge.

The Hill Country Galleria is holding several holiday events this season. (Courtesy Giant Noise)
Selfies with Santa, ugly sweater contest and more: 3 holiday events in Lake Travis-Westlake

Residents of Lake Travis-Westlake can look forward to holiday markets and ugly sweater contests this season.

US Attorney General Merrick Garland and US Associate Attorney General Vanita Gupta announced the lawsuit against Texas on Dec. 6. (Screenshot courtesy of Department of Justice)
U.S. Dept. of Justice lawsuit alleges Texas' redistricting maps discriminate against voters of color

The suit alleges that the Texas Legislature redrew the maps to reduce voters of colors' influence on elections.

City and Austin EMS Association representatives discussed a pay increase on the third day of negotiations (Darcy Sprague, Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin EMS Association lays out argument for $27 per hour starting pay

The increase would represent almost a 42% increase in starting salary for EMS medics.