Local mom and pop businesses have a harder time surviving today, experts say

Rising overhead costs and an increase in online shopping options resulted in the closing of Brilliant Sky Toys & Books in West Lake Hills June 30, franchise owner Courtney Brown Brock said.

Rising overhead costs and an increase in online shopping options resulted in the closing of Brilliant Sky Toys & Books in West Lake Hills June 30, franchise owner Courtney Brown Brock said.

Independent retailers, which once made up a prominent part of the Hill Country’s economy, are having a harder time trying to survive in the existing commercial climate, said Tim Laine, a representative for commercial real estate company NAI Partners.

Increased competition from online retailers and national corporations make it more challenging for small-business owners to generate reliable income, he said.  Owners of small businesses “now, more than ever,” need to find a “specific niche,” he said, that offers something to people that is in demand and hard to obtain.

Since opening Faraday’s Kitchen Shop 12 years ago with his wife, Melissa, Tony Curtis-Wellings said he knows of almost 200 local small business owners who have had to shut down their shops. He said area businesses struggle because they are paying too much for rent. This can cause new owners to prematurely close if profits are not seen early, he said.

Courtney Brown Brock, who had owned Brilliant Sky Toys & Books in West Lake Hills for more than five years, closed the franchise June 30 due, in part, to increasing overhead costs associated with operating in the region, she said.

“It was unsustainable,” Brock said of the store’s operations. “We’ve got a great community here. I live here. I grew up here. I know everybody, so it was hard to close. But I’m not the first to close or the last. It’s going to keep happening.” 

The cost of doing business

In the Greater Austin area, commercial rent has increased by 30 percent since 2012, said Sam Tenenbaum, a market economist for commercial real estate analytics company CoStar Group.

“Rents continue to escalate across Austin as more and more people move to town, creating additional demand for retail space,” he said.

Rising rents result in slimmer profit margins, a concern for local businesses that already tend to operate on smaller margins, he said.

As retail space in downtown Austin became more expensive and harder to find, large retailers began moving west within Travis County to take advantage of the area’s population growth and new developments, Laine said.

Many businesses are now forced to spend 14-16 percent of profits on rent, Curtis-Wellings said, an amount that is unsustainable for a family-owned small business.

Nikki Mackenzie, owner and designer at Magpie Blossom Boutique in Lakeway, said small businesses pay the same in rent as national corporations. Using other locations to keep a struggling branch afloat, business chains often have the resources to outlast mom and pop businesses, she said.

“There’s no special deal because we’re local,” she said. “I’m all in on one little store in one neighborhood. If I have a really tough few months, there’s no other [income] to help. National chains can operate a store at a loss for a long time.”

Because retail space is at a premium, shopping center management companies are using the opportunity to modernize their facilities, allowing them to attract higher-priced clients. However, some businesses—such as the Great Harvest Bread Co.’s Westlake franchise—have struggled during renovations, franchise owner Stewart Dickson said.

“There was a literal barrier in front of our store, and everybody thought we were closed,” he said. “Because of the construction, I’ve been doing ride-sharing with Uber to make extra money.”

Dickson said the renovations to the center are not related to aesthetics, and he does not believe they will help attract more customers to his business in the future, although the improvements will likely make space in the center more profitable for the landowner.

“The rents have already gone up dramatically,” he said. “I was up for renewal in July and saw a significant jump.”

Online shopping and convenience

Tenenbaum said the continued rise of online shopping has made it difficult for small businesses to sell goods that can be obtained elsewhere.

“Goods can be purchased online for cheaper prices,” he said. “There is also the convenience of the goods arriving at your door, as opposed to having to leave the house to find what shoppers are looking for.”

Rising rents, along with the emergence of online shopping, contributed to Brock closing Brilliant Sky Toys & Books, she said.

“With the money we lost to online shopping increasing each year, the store wasn’t sustainable with the overhead, property taxes and any additional expenses that came up,” she said. “Customers would come in and say they saw an item for less on Amazon.”

Although bakeries have not yet been affected by the rise in e-commerce, Dickson said the prevalence and convenience of chain supermarkets has made it less necessary for families to stop into his bakery.

“What has changed for us is the fact that all supermarkets now have their own bakeries in them,” he said. “You can get fresh bread at any grocery store, and it wasn’t like that in the past.”

The need for small business

Although chain supermarkets are producing better products than before, Dickson said bread aficionados would know his bread is superior.

“As a society we have sacrificed so much on the altar of convenience,” he said. “What we hope is everyone that walks into the door is able to experience the sights, smells and tastes that come with baking fresh bread.”

Curtis-Wellings said small business is the foundation of innovation, and as family-owned businesses decrease across the country, there could be a decrease in product quality.

“Small businesses come up with a good idea, they take a risk and then sell that idea to a big company,” he said. “If people expect big businesses to be committed to innovation, [business] is going to fail.”

The advantage larger corporations have in high-rent areas has created a country where communities are becoming homogenized with the same handful of retailers found in every city, Mackenzie said.

“Americans have to make a choice in the next decade about what they want their communities to look like,” she said. “If [people] want their communities to have unique personalities, they have to be conscious of where they shop.”

By Nicholas Cicale

Nick was born in Long Island, New York and grew up in South Florida. He graduated from Florida State University in 2012 with a bachelor's degree in writing and a minor in music. Nick was a journalist for three years at the St. James Plaindealer in Minnesota before moving to Austin to join Community Impact Newspaper in 2016.


Andrew Clark and Andrea Willott are directors on Bee Cave's Economic Development Board. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
City leaders in Bee Cave working on additional assistance plan for local businesses

Economic leaders in Bee Cave are working on plans to help small businesses as much as possible amid fiscal pitfalls created by the COVID-19 crisis.

The city of Austin issued a stay-at-home order March 24. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Coronavirus update: Second death confirmed in Austin, Travis County as local cases rise to 206

Keep up with updates from Travis County and Austin for the week of March 30 here.

Precision Regenerative and Functional Medicine is run by Dr. Mihnea Dumitrescu. (Courtesy Precision Regenerative and Functional Medicine)
Precision Regenerative and Functional Medicine relocates clinic in West Lake Hills

The clinic relocated within the Westlake Oaks Office Park.

Dr. Liam Fry speaks about two nursing home isolation facilities that will be coming to the Austin and Travis County areas on March 30 at the city of Austin's Combined Transportation, Emergency, and Communications Center. (Courtesy ATXN)
Facilities to isolate nursing home residents who test positive for coronavirus will be set up in Travis, Williamson counties

The facilities will be for individuals living at nursing homes who do not need hospitalization or have already been discharged from the hospital.

Austin Regional Clinic Cedar Park
Austin Regional Clinic launches 5 drive-up coronavirus testing locations

Austin Regional Clinic will open drive-up COVID-19 testing sites across five sites.

Bee Cave City Council Member Bill Goodwin has resigned from his positions on the board of the West Travis County Public Utility Agency and the Bee Cave Economic Development Board. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Bill Goodwin resigns positions on economic board and West Travis County Public Utility Agency

Bee Cave City Council Member Bill Goodwin has resigned from his positions on the board of the West Travis County Public Utility Agency and the Bee Cave Economic Development Board.

NBISD workers deliver meals to students at the Veramendi Elementary School meal pickup location March 17. (Courtesy New Braunfels ISD)
Elections, closures, instruction: See what Austin-area schools are doing in wake of coronavirus

During the coronavirus situation, schools have had to make changes in how they deliver instruction, meals, elections and more. Below is a roundup of what local schools are doing to serve students and families.

Capital Metro station
All Capital Metro fares will be free throughout April

Beginning April 1, riders will not have to pay Capital Metro operators or use the farebox.

Mayor Pro Tem Bill Goodwin, center, and Council Member Jon Cobb, left, resigned their posts during a March 28 City Council meeting. Council Member Kara King, right, is now mayor elect of Bee Cave. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Bee Cave Mayor Bill Goodwin and Council Member Jon Cobb resign during special meeting

A special called meeting that initially appeared focused on the removal of a key Bee Cave official due to perceived missteps and lackluster response to crisis ended in the abrupt resignation of both the mayor and a council member.

The Lake Travis ISD board of trustees met virtually March 25 for its regular board meeting. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)
Vail Divide progress, drug testing updates, COVID-19 news, and more from Lake Travis ISD’s first digital meeting March 25

All district facilities are closed until April 13 to mitigate the spread of COVID-19, however, the meeting’s agenda included a variety of subjects from a drug testing program to construction progress.

The district delivered iPads to Dell Seton Medical Center March 27. (Courtesy Eanes ISD)
Eanes ISD donates 70 iPads to Dell Seton Medical Center

The district quickly gathered 70 previously retired iPads to aid those working during the COVID-19 outbreak.

An action item to potentially postpone the May 2 trustee election is listed on the Eanes ISD March 31 meeting agenda. (Taylor Jackson Buchanan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Eanes ISD to discuss whether to postpone its May 2 election in light of COVID-19

The Eanes ISD board of trustees will take action on the May 2 election during its scheduled board meeting

Back to top