Institutional investors move in on Austin housing market

Average portion of homes purchased by investors in Central Austin* in 2018, nearly double the rate of the Austin-Round Rock metronn* Data only available for ZIP codes 78703, 78704, 78723, 78731, 78751 and 78757nSOURCE: CoreLogic/Community Impact Newspaper n

Average portion of homes purchased by investors in Central Austin* in 2018, nearly double the rate of the Austin-Round Rock metronn* Data only available for ZIP codes 78703, 78704, 78723, 78731, 78751 and 78757nSOURCE: CoreLogic/Community Impact Newspaper n

Image description
A Central Austin snapshot*
Image description
20-year highs
Image description
The austin equation
Image description
The Investor Next Door
The letter arrives in the mail designed to look like notebook paper, with type designed to look like handwriting.

“I am a local home buyer and real estate agent looking to purchase more property in your neighborhood and would like the opportunity to present you an offer,” it reads. “I am not interested in listing your property for sale, just purchasing.”

Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza, who represents District 2 in Southeast Austin, said she has received similar letters. Some of her constituents get several a month.

“It seems like they’re trying to personalize it that way, but it’s not really the case,” she said. “They are a big investor.”

Local home-flippers have been around for decades. More recently, data shows institutional investors—such as hedge funds, endowment funds and commercial banks—have moved into the single-family market.

In 2018, the portion of homes bought by investors in the U.S. hit a 20-year high, according to the financial services company CoreLogic. Nationally, more than 20% of low-priced homes were bought by investors.

In the six Central Austin ZIP codes for which data is available, 11.55%—on average—of homes were purchased by investors in 2018, nearly double the rate of the Austin-Round Rock metro.

Austin homes valued in the $200,000-$400,000 range appreciate much faster than money in the bank, providing investors with a strong return, said Steve Crorey, past president of the Austin Board of Realtors.

Locally, investor activity varies from year to year and across ZIP codes. But the numbers can be significant.

In 2017, 38.6% of mid-priced homes in 78757—in North Central Austin—and one-third of low-priced single-family homes in 78703—in West Austin—were bought by investors, per the CoreLogic data. The year before nearly 60% of low-priced homes in 78723—in East Austin—were investor-purchased.

CoreLogic defines low-priced homes based on the distribution of home sales in a given market in a given year. “The cheapest third are starter homes,” a spokesperson said.

This activity impacts the Austin market, where the median home value has increased by more than $100,000 since 2014, according to the Travis Central Appraisal District.

“[Investors] have disrupted the entry-level market … simply because they have created competition and buying potential that the average homeowner or prospective homebuyer can’t compete with” said James Gaines, chief economist at the Texas A&M Real Estate Center.

A new class of asset

Institutional investors—defined as those who own more than 2,000 properties by Freddie Mac Multifamily, a governmental entity that provides loans to acquire or refinance multifamily properties—became involved in the residential real estate market following the Great Recession in 2008.

“Anytime there’s a recession, big institutional investors come in and buy portfolios ... and rent them,” said Dan Castro, a real estate attorney, broker and founder of the local group Investors Underground, which counts more than 15,000 members.

The logic, Gaines said, is that investors purchase foreclosed homes for pennies on the dollar and rent them until their values stabilize, bringing in profit until they can be sold for more money.

Some investors correctly predicted that “tight mortgage financing conditions and greater economic uncertainty” would buoy the single-family rental market, according to a 2015 working paper by staff at the Federal Reserve System Board of Governors.

In fact, the fastest-growing sector of the U.S. housing market since the recession has been single-family rentals, according to the Texas A&M Real Estate Center. Between 2009-17, the number of single-family rentals increased 14.6% nationally and 18.9% in Texas.

While the housing market has since stabilized, demographic factors ensure the single-family rental market continues to thrive.

Millennials—who tend to marry and start families later, have more student debt and possess different attitudes toward homeownership than previous generations—help drive demand, according to research by the Texas A&M Real Estate Center and Freddie Mac Multifamily.

Portfolios of single-family homes have become “a new class of real estate asset,” per the Federal Reserve paper.

“Now we have, literally, across the country, billions of dollars being formed into investment companies … targeting certain markets and going in and buying homes and renting them,” Gaines said.

Economies of scale

Institutional investors make up about 1% of the single-family rental market nationally, according to data from the real estate analytics firm HouseCanary.

But those investors have an outsized impact in the metropolitan areas where their activity is concentrated, such as Dallas and Atlanta.

“Austin wasn’t really a big enough market in the beginning,” Gaines said. “[Investors] needed to go into major markets where they could pick up a couple of thousand properties a year.”

Lately, however, investors have become interested in Austin, despite the city’s rising property values and low supply.

“It’s having an impact in the short term,” Castro said. “But in the long term those big companies are not going to be able to compete.”

Unlike individual investors, Castro said, institutional investors accumulate large expenses, which lead to large fees for sellers in distress, and take a formulaic approach—with mass-marketing materials—that pales in comparison to a home visit from a local flipper.

“You can’t duplicate that human compassion, that human touch, that hand-written letter, over a thousand doors,” Castro said. “You can’t scale it the way institutional buyers want to do it.”

Resident protections

Increased investor activity makes a competitive market such as Austin’s even more so.

“They have a right to buy property just like anyone else,” Crorey said. “It does affect the shortage of inventory that potential homebuyers are able to choose from.”

Because institutional investors seek to purchase a high volume of lower-priced homes, they are often competing with prospective homeowners.

But unlike first-time buyers, who typically need mortgage financing to afford a home, institutional investors have access to other forms of capital, such as private equity, lines of bank credit and public bonds, according to the Federal Reserve paper.

“The investors obviously have been competing with the people who would like to buy the home to live in it,” Gaines said. “Generally, they can outbid you … mainly because [the investor] can say to the seller, ‘I can come in and pay all cash and close tomorrow.’”

For homeowners who may be elderly, low-income or behind on their mortgage or property tax payments, such an offer may be appealing.

“When you’re given a cash offer, closing in three days, I can see why that would be very enticing for someone who is in a vulnerable position,” Garza said.

After hearing that constituents were receiving fliers from prospective homebuyers and getting those fliers in the mail herself, Garza sponsored a resolution called Families Not Flippers. Passed in April 2018, it directed city staff to implement an education campaign to help protect homeowners from predatory flippers.

“I’m not trying to control whether a family sells or not,” Garza said. “But if they can sell at a higher price point, which is likely the case if they put their home on the market [rather than sell directly to an investor] ... I want them to get the absolute best value.”


Navarro Early College High School, pictured here, is one of over 30 Austin ISD schools frozen to transfer students for the coming 2020-21 school year. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin ISD announces 31 schools frozen to transfers for 2020-21 school year

Austin ISD released its list of schools that will not be accepting in-district transfer students for the 2020-21 school year.

Austin Regional Clinic has administered more than 84,000 flu vaccinations to date in 2019.
DATA: Austin Regional Clinic gave thousands of flu tests after Thanksgiving; second spike possible during holidays

Austin Regional Clinic gave more than 4,500 flu tests leading up to Thanksgiving.

Austin Mayor Steve Adler (center), flanked by Assistant City Manager Christopher Shorter and City Attorney Ann Morgan, listen to public testimony on the land development code rewrite Dec. 7. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Property owners objecting to Austin’s land development code rewrite sue city for rejecting their protest rights

The lawsuit could hold up the city's approval of its land development code overhaul.

The city of Austin will begin charging a $0.15 per trip regulatory fee on shared mobility vehicles in early 2020. Community Impact Staff
City of Austin will implement a $0.15 regulatory fee on shared mobility rides

The city of Austin will begin charging a $0.15 per trip regulatory fee on shared mobility vehicles, which include electric bikes and scooters, Austin Transportation Director Robert Spillar wrote in a Dec. 10 memo to City Council.

The proposed bridge design is in a wishbone shape and includes a plaza space at the center. (Rendering courtesy city of Austin)
City of Austin reveals wishbone design for new bridge over Longhorn Dam

The city of Austin debuted a design proposal for a new bridge over the Longhorn Dam connecting the Ann and Roy Butler Hike and Bike Trail at a Dec. 10 open house.

Travis County commissioners voted to allow staff to begin contract negotiations for a new women's jail facility at a Dec. 10 meeting. (Courtesy Travis County Sheriff's Office)
Travis County begins contract negotiations for women’s jail facility as overall jail population continues to decline

The county has planned to build a new, separate women’s facility for years, despite some pushback from local activists.

The Microtel Inn and Suites is located in Southeast Austin, only a 4.5-mile drive from the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. (Courtesy Google Maps)
Zoning concern prevents Austin from moving forward with second conversion of hotel to homeless shelter

Officials have already indicated they are eyeing other hotels and motels for purchase and conversion into homeless shelters.

Block 21 will change ownership. The mixed-use development includes ACL Live at the Moody Theater and the W Austin hotel.
W Austin and ACL Live development will sell for $275 million

The transaction is expected to close in 2020.

When Austin voters approved a $250 million affordable housing bond in 2018, they signed off on using part of that funding to expand a home repair program for low-income residents. Many beneficiaries are seniors.
Affordable housing bond funding helps seniors 'age in place' through home repair program

When Austin voters approved a historic $250 million affordable housing bond in 2018, they signed off on a $28 million investment in home repairs for low-income residents.

Common winter allergies in Texas are caused by pollen from the Ashe juniper—also known as a mountain cedar. The tree is native to the area. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
As pollen counts rise in Central Texas, learn about cedar fever and allergy prevention

As temperatures cool heading into the winter season in Central Texas, pollen counts from Ashe juniper trees begin to climb, causing seasonal allergies referred to locally by residents as “cedar fever.”

Back to top