Has a doctor shortage come to Central Texas? Experts say the area has a different problem

Texas' health care industry is struggling to keep up with the number of primary care doctors needed to accommodate its growing population, experts say.

Texas' health care industry is struggling to keep up with the number of primary care doctors needed to accommodate its growing population, experts say.

Health care advocates have for years worried about a shortage of doctors serving rural and low-income Texas communities.

But in Austin and the surrounding areas, which have one of the highest doctor-to-patient ratios in the state, there is a different challenge, according to Dr. Jonathan MacClements, assistant dean of graduate medical education at The University of Texas Dell Medical School.

Central Texans have ample access to specialty care“We really don’t have a physician shortage,” MacClements said. “What we have is a physician distribution issue.”

With the late May opening of the Dell Seton Medical Center at The University of Texas, which serves as a teaching hospital for The University of Texas Dell Medical School, health care educators said they hope new technology and a collaborative, multidisciplinary approach to medical training will offer solutions to address a perceived need for more primary care options statewide.

“We’re really interested in trainingsmith the next generation of physicians to focus on overall health,” said Christann Vasquez, the new teaching hospital’s president.

Faster rise in specialists

Texas ranked 41st among U.S. states in 2015 for its ratio of physicians per 100,000 residents, requiring roughly 13,000 more physicians to reach the national average, according to a study from physician consulting firm Merritt Hawkins.

As the state population has grown during the past 20 years, so has the number of doctors holding licenses to practice in the state, according to data from the Texas Medical Board.

However, the statewide growth rate for licensed specialist physicians has risen by 72.55 percent over the past two decades compared to 42.54 percent for primary care physicians, according to the data.

Travis County had a 154.66 percent increase in specialists holding licenses between 1997 and 2017 compared to an 81.96 percent increase in primary care doctors during the same time period. As of January the board counted 2,348 doctors licensed as specialists in Travis County and 1,261 licensed in primary care.

Williamson County had a 650 percent increase in specialists holding licenses from 1997-2017 compared with a 303.23 percent increase in primary care doctors in the same time period. In January, Williamson County had 375 primary care physicians and 450 specialists.

Not every licensed doctor may actually be practicing, and some may only work part-time.

Higher pay attracts doctors to pursue specialties, although they require longer training and oftentimes a greater student-debt load, said Dr. Norman Chenven, the founding CEO of Austin Regional Clinic, a multispecialty medical group serving Central Texas.

Specialists also tend to receive better payment for care due to more patients having health insurance, he added.

Chenven said doctor distribution issues are more apparent in areas with high numbers of low-income patients who generally lack adequate health insurance, known as the safety-net population.   

“For the most part, primary care has been a challenge over the last decade or two,” he said.

Doctors who work within the safety-net population often treat patients with more complex and chronic health care issues as well as other cultural challenges and language barriers, said Dr. Alan Schalscha, chief medical officer for CommUnityCare, which operates federally qualified health centers in Travis County to serve low-income residents who often lack insurance coverage.

“If providers don’t have a true passion for the mission, they burn out of the safety-net population really quickly,” Schalscha said.

In terms of physician numbers, Chenven said Travis, Williamson and Hays counties do not face the types of shortages seen elsewhere in Texas and around the country. But without better distribution, the counties will continue to have issues with people of lower income levels not having the ability to access care, he said.

“If you took all the doctors in these three counties, organized them into an efficient delivery system, you have plenty of physician power,” Chenven said. “Plus, you add to that the nurse practitioners and physician assistants, and you’ve got a lot of medical care that can be delivered.”

In addition, large health networks are constantly adding locations to better serve the population.

Jay Fox, president of Baylor Scott & White in the Austin, Round Rock Region said the company evaluates where patient need is on a regular basis.

“At the region’s steadily growing rate, we are continuing to conduct extensive research to evaluate what makes the most sense to best serve the community,” he said. “For example, we recently announced plans to build the first hospital in Pflugerville, which will open its doors in mid-2018.”

He said this study of regional needs also includes specific health care needs that might not be the same area to area depending on the demographics of residents.

“While all locations require numerous clinical professionals, including physicians, advanced practice providers, nurses and administrative staff, others are now offering services you may not expect—such as integrative medicine or [healthy] living resources that keep you out of the hospital.”

Fox said many of Baylor Scott & White’s services develop over time, and facilities often offer additional services months or years after opening.

Improving care

One strategy Dell Medical School is using to improve distribution of care is to decentralize the residency training the school does with Seton Healthcare Family, MacClements said.

Dell Medical School recently moved its internal medicine program from the former University Medical Center Brackenridge in downtown Austin to Central Health’s Southeast Health and Wellness Center on Montopolis Drive in Southeast Austin, he said.

With its technological capabilities and collaborative design, the new Dell Seton Medical Center is also meant to transform the landscape of medical training and health care delivery in Central Texas, said Greg Hartman, chief of external and academic affairs for Seton Healthcare Family.

MacClements said Dell Medical School’s focus is not just looking at increasing the size of its training programs but also changing its overall approach to health care.

“We literally are rethinking everything,” MacClements said.

Central Texans have ample access to specialty careNurses seek greater role

For many years, Texas nurse practitioners have sought to expand their role in primary care, arguing that doing so could help alleviate doctor shortages or distribution issues, particularly in low-income or rural communities.

And in Round Rock, there has been no shortage of nurses, due in part to a steady flow of new employees from nursing school.

A spokesperson with the Seton Medical Center Williamson said there has been plenty of new talent.

“We are fortunate to have three nursing schools within walking distance to our hospital here in Round Rock,” spokesperson Melanie Fox said. “We do not have a shortage exactly, but it is harder to find experienced nurses to fill our openings.”

A statement from St. David's HealthCare said the provider experiences similar challenges. The email said the location of St. David's HealthCare in Central Texas offers an attractive place to live and appealing benefit for recruitment, but doesn't always help in recruiting experienced nurses or staff.

"As is the case across the country, though, there are challenges recruiting the most experienced nurses and staff with specific specialties," the statement read.

Two bills filed in the 85th Texas Legislature this year—House Bill 1415, filed by state Rep. Stephanie Klick, R-Fort Worth, and Senate Bill 681, filed by state Sen. Kelly Hancock, R-North Richland Hills—proposed to remove state regulations that allow nurse practitioners to treat and write prescriptions for patients but only if nurse practitioners first sign contracts with doctors.

Groups backing the bills, such as the Texas Nurse Practitioners, the Texas Nurses Association, the AARP and the Texas Association of Business, argue that doing away with contracts would encourage nurse practitioners to stay in Texas. They argue Texas-based nurse practitioners have a competitive disadvantage with their counterparts in other states due to the cost of maintaining such contracts.

Opponents of the effort, including the Texas Medical Association, argue that nurse practitioners play important roles in health care, but the lengthier training and deeper expertise required of doctors make contracts necessary in order to keep patients safe.

Both bills were left pending in committee at the end of the Legislature’s regular session in May, meaning the effort to loosen statewide regulations will have to wait until at least 2019.

Updated 2:23 p.m. June 6 to credit St. David's HealthCare comments to an emailed statement.

By Olivia Lueckemeyer
Olivia Lueckemeyer graduated in 2013 from Loyola University New Orleans with a degree in journalism. She joined Community Impact Newspaper in October 2016 as reporter for the Southwest Austin edition before her promotion to editor in March 2017. In July 2018 she returned home to the Dallas area and became editor of the Richardson edition.


Tacodeli co-owners Roberto Espinosa and Eric Wilkerson opened their first location in 1999. The seventh location for the local chain in Austin will open this summer in Circle C. (Courtesy Tacodeli)
Tacodeli to open a Circle C location this summer

The new location will be the seventh in Austin for the locally based chain, which first opened in 1999.

The city of Austin's Smart Mobility Office has partnered with Ford on self-driving vehicle initiatives. (Courtesy Ford Motor Company)
Austin's transportation department paving the way for rise in autonomous vehicle traffic

Several private companies are working on autonomous vehicle initiatives in Austin in addition to the city's own smart infrastructure planning.

Goodfolks plans to open in late July to early August. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
New restaurant coming to Georgetown; new Hutto community to have nearly 1K lots and more top Central Texas news

Read the top business and community news from the past week from Central Texas.

COVID-19 precautions such as a masking requirement remain in place at Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. (Courtesy Austin-Bergstrom International Airport)
'Signs of hope' on the horizon at Austin-Bergstrom International Airport after year-plus dip in air travel

Rising passenger counts, new airline operations and an increase in vaccinations could all support the airport's recovery in 2021.

Capital Metro bus
Capital Metro announces increased transit services for Austin FC games this season

Capital Metro has increased the frequency of several bus routes for Austin FC game days at Q2 Stadium.

CDC ends all mask requirements for fully vaccinated people

The guidance states fully vaccinated people do not need to wear masks indoors or outdoors.

Students at Norman-Sims Elementary School and Austin ISD's 124 other schools across the district will now be allowed to remove masks during outdoor physical activities with the permission of a parent or guardian. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin ISD makes outdoor masking optional, eases other health, safety restrictions

Students engaging in outdoor physical activity will now have the option to remove masks.

House Bill 1024, signed into law May 12, allows restaurants and bars to permanently sell alcoholic beverages to-go. (Courtesy Pexels)
Cocktails to-go are here to stay in Texas: Gov. Greg Abbott signs change into law May 12

Supporters say the change will help restaurants continue to recover from the economic effects of the coronavirus pandemic.

Austin's phased process for moving people experiencing homelessness out of unregulated encampments will roll out through the summer. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
City officials detail homeless education and enforcement plan with Proposition B ordinances now in effect

The process that will eventually remove the city's homeless encampment begins this month with outreach and warnings and will stretch until late summer with full enforcement.