Travis County submits public defender’s office grant application after last-minute changes

Nicolas Sawyer, a student at The University of Texas School of Law, speaks during a press conference in support of the public defender's office held by local nonprofit Grassroots Leadership on the steps of the Travis County Administration Building in Austin on May 7.

Nicolas Sawyer, a student at The University of Texas School of Law, speaks during a press conference in support of the public defender's office held by local nonprofit Grassroots Leadership on the steps of the Travis County Administration Building in Austin on May 7.

Updated May 9 at 12:30 p.m. to reflect that county criminal court judges have signed off on the TIDC grant application 

Since October, a work group appointed by Travis County Commissioners has been crafting a proposal to create the vision of what a public defender’s office would look like for the county. Austin is the largest city in the country without a general public defender’s office to represent indigent clients, or those who cannot afford an attorney––which local political leaders hope to change.

The county passed a substantial milestone on May 7 as it continues through the process to create the new office. County Commissioners voted 4-1 to approve a grant application for $27.3 million in state funds over the course of four years that would enable the county to establish the public defenders office. Precinct 3 Commissioner Gerald Daugherty was the lone vote against.

The grant application will be submitted to the Texas Indigent Defense Commission––a state agency that provides start-up support for counties that want to establish a public defender’s office––ahead of a May 10 deadline. The TIDC will announce awardees in June.

However, the commissioners’ May 7 vote came with some late changes in the proposal. On May 2, Brenda Kennedy, presiding judge for Travis County Criminal Courts, submitted amendments to the Indigent Legal Services work group’s proposal on behalf of a majority of the Criminal Court Judges of Travis County.

“The judges agree to most of the ILS proposal, however, there are a few critical components of the proposal that we, as judges, have concerns about, based on our many years of experience in our system of criminal justice,” Kennedy wrote.

However, members of the county-appointed work group saw the changes from the judges in a different light.

“It undermines the work we have done to create a public defender office to serve community. It reeks of insider politics and is not based in principles and research, the foundation of the work done by the ILS work group,” members of the work group wrote in a May 3 email to commissioners.

A Third Way 


Judges and members of the work group came to an impasse on issues including how oversight would work for the office as well as the amount of funding for the Capital Area Private Defender Service, or CAPDS, which appoints private lawyers to represent indigent clients. With those two groups at odds, County Judge Sarah Eckhardt proposed a third option in an amendment she submitted on May 3. The proposal as amended by Eckhardt was the one ultimately approved by commissioners May 7.

Eckhardt described her amendment as “punting” decisions regarding membership of the oversight committee down the road in order to submit the grant application on time. According to the text of her amendment, the oversight committee would include at least seven members, with representation from community advocates, criminal defense attorneys and jurists retired from the criminal justice system.

The judges' proposal split oversight into two phases––one committee overseeing the creation of the office during the four-year grant period, and another to oversee the office once it was up and running.

Amanda Woog, executive director of the Texas Fair Defense Project, a nonprofit that advocates for the rights of low-income Texans within the criminal justice system, and chairperson of the work group, said groups such as directly impacted individuals and family members should be represented in overseeing the new office at every stage of its creation.

"I’m disappointed because it should have been a no-brainer. Because of politics around it, it became more controversial than it should have been," Woog said.


Under the terms of each of the three proposals commissioners were considering on May 7––from the work group, local judges and Eckhardt’s amendment––the new public defender’s office would represent 30% of clients who cannot afford representation, while the remaining 70% would remain represented by attorneys appointed through CAPDS.

Debra Hale, criminal court administrator for Travis County, said the increases in CAPDS funding ensure that there will be equity between the 70% of indigent clients represented by private attorneys and the 30% of clients represented by the public defender’s office.

Initial projections for the total cost of this plan over four years was $40.2 million, according to an analysis by the county’s planning and budget office. The proposal commissioners approved on May 7, with more money allocated for lawyers in the CAPDS system, is expected to cost $54.3 million over four years, with $26.9 million funded by the county and $27.3 million funded by the TIDC grant.

“[The judges] believe the whole system has to be fair, and they are responsible for the whole system. They are not in favor of any proposal that only takes care of a portion of clients,” Hale said.

According to the amended proposal approved by commissioners, the county would spend about $16 million in fiscal year 2023-24 when the TIDC grant runs out. According to county staff, that is $4.2 million more than the current spending level of $11.8 million.

The TIDC requires local judicial support as a prerequisite to approve the grant application.

“If the judges aren’t going to sign it, the grant is not going to move forward,” Daugherty said.

Two days after the commissioners' vote, a majority of Travis County's criminal court judges signed off on the amended proposal.

"[U]pon approval and assurance that CAPDS will also be funded in accordance with the provisions outlines in the Eckhardt proposal, we will support the implementation of a [public defender's office] as ... outlined," Kennedy wrote in a May 9 letter to the TIDC.

Eckhardt said the grant application is not the end of the process, but rather an option to get over the hurdle of the impending TIDC deadline.

"I’m super pumped up. This is a huge institutional change," Eckhardt said. "If this was easy, we would have done it already."



A 50-50 Split


Commissioners also made a decision on May 7 on how the funding for the new office would be split between the state grant money and local county funds. In other areas of the state, the TIDC has decreased its grant funding each year, starting by funding 80% of the office, then moving down to 20% by year four.

Rather than adapting that structure, county staff recommended a 50-50 split between grant funding and local funds each year because over the total four-year period the county would receive about $2.4 million in additional funding.

Some commissioners reiterated concerns voiced at their April 30 meeting about potential property tax revenue caps coming from the Texas Legislature and how those would affect new programs like the public defender’s office.

“I continue to be very, very nervous about the financial implications of moving forward on this thing,” Daugherty said. “I just am as nervous as I’ve ever been about our budget.”

Eckhardt said she recognizes and shares those concerns, but she still believes the public defender’s office is a worthwhile endeavor.

“It’s a huge risk. I think it’s a risk worth taking because we are talking about people’s liberty,” she said.

Geoffrey Burkhart, executive director of the TIDC, said the new funding split would likely not present any issues for the commission.

"That's certainly something we could entertain," Burkhart said.


MOST RECENT

Overall in Travis County there has been a total of 10,695 cases since mid-March.. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Travis County adds 571 COVID-19 cases; new restriction put in place ahead of holiday weekend

Overall in Travis County there has been a total of 10,695 cases since mid-March.

The First Street Foundation's dataset includes an interactive Flood Factor dashboard that anyone can use to assess the risk of flooding over a 30-year period for any address. (Screenshot via floodfactor.com)
Analysis: FEMA may be undercounting national total flood risk by as much as 70%

The new dataset includes an interactive Flood Factor dashboard that anyone can use to assess the risk of flooding over a 30-year period for any address.

A photo of a person wearing a medical mask
Travis County Judge supports state masking order, says county will enforce

After Gov. Greg Abbot's statewise mandate to wear masks that cover mouth and nose, Travis County Judge Sam Biscoe voiced his support.

A statue of Willie Nelson sits in front of ACL Live at the Moody Theater at the corner of Lavaca and Second streets.
Austin police will no longer arrest for low-level marijuana possession

Austin police will no longer arrest or issue citations for most marijuana possession offenses under 4 ounces.

Gov. Greg Abbott
Gov. Greg Abbott: Texans must wear masks in public starting July 3

"COVID-19 is not going away," Gov. Abbott said. "In fact, it is getting worse."

Episcopal Health Foundation
Survey: Texans support emphasis on improving economy, safety, pollution to address overall health

“COVID-19 is clearly showing what Texans already know: the state needs to address underlying, non-medical conditions that have a dramatic impact on their health,” Episcopal Health Foundation President and CEO Elena Marks said.

In the course of a month, the number of patients admitted to the hospital due to COVID-19 has increased more than fivefold, according to Austin Public Health data. (Design by Shelby Savage/Community Impact Newspaper)
Deluge of new COVID-19 cases forces Austin-area health officials to limit testing, shift tracing strategy

Fighting antiquated fax machines and a sharp rise in the demand for testing, officials said contact tracers are not able to get in touch with residents quickly enough to prevent the spread of the virus.

A photo of a group of community members at a public hearing discussion
Construction begins on new fire and EMS station in Southwest Austin

As one of five new stations geared at improving citywide response times, the new station will serve the Sunset Valley and Travis Country communities.

CommunityCare Health Centers drive-up coronavirus testing site
CommUnityCare will no longer test asymptomatic people for COVID-19 as testing demand swells

CommUnityCare Health Centers is now only testing individuals who show symptoms, those who have a known exposure to the coronavirus or those with other existing health conditions.

The H-E-B Austin Symphony July 4th Concert & Fireworks will not take place this year due to concerns about the spread of the coronavirus. (Courtesy Ricardo Brazziel)
Read the latest on 4th of July celebrations in Central Texas

Area cities have canceled or modified their Independence Day events.

City officials are working to contain a recent surge in the spread of the coronavirus. (John Cox/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin shuts down main greenbelts, all programs and amenities through July; parks, trails will remain open

City officials are working to contain a recent surge in the spread of the coronavirus.

A photo of fireworks exploding
Celebrate Independence Day in Southwest Austin and Dripping Springs with these events

Many Fourth of July events are canceled due to COVID-19 concerns, but some outdoor and virtual events are still on.