Short-term rental restrictions remain in crosshairs after legislative session ends

Austin's restrictions on short-term rentals remain under fire because of a pending lauwsuit filed in 2016 claiming several parts of the city's ordinance violate the U.S. Constitution.

Austin's restrictions on short-term rentals remain under fire because of a pending lauwsuit filed in 2016 claiming several parts of the city's ordinance violate the U.S. Constitution.

The city of Austin’s short-term rental, or STR, ordinance, which regulates the existence of non-owner-occupied vacation units in residential neighborhoods, survived a potential blow during the Texas Legislature’s recent session.

Although a bill that would have stripped localities of STR regulating power and given it to the state did not pass, Austin’s restrictions on STRs remain under fire because of a pending lawsuit filed in 2016 that claims several parts of the city’s ordinance violate the U.S. Constitution.

What follows is an explanation of how the city arrived at its existing policies and the subsequent legal backlash against its regulations: City Council passed an ordinance in 2012 allowing for the regulation and licensing of STRs. Mayor Pro Tem Kathie Tovo said it was understood that the program was only a pilot and would likely need to be adjusted.

The council defined an STR as a property that is leased for less than 30 consecutive days and created three types: Type 1, or owner-occupied, multifamily, single-family or duplex units; Type 2, or non-owner-occupied single-family or duplex units;  and Type 3, or non-owner-occupied multifamily units.

In response to residents' concerns in 2015 about Type 2 units that had been brought into residential neighborhoods, Tovo said discussion focused on the once-single-family properties becoming hotels and “party houses.”

Tovo said she and her colleagues saw another issue taking shape: Type 2 STRs were set up to become investor-owned commercial properties, which did not belong in single-family neighborhoods.

“We have a situation where we’re talking all the time about how to create more housing opportunities throughout the city, but we have a policy that allows some of our housing stock to be converted into commercial services,” Tovo said.

Council voted in February 2016 to end the issuance of new Type 2 licenses, phase them out of neighborhoods by 2022 and place tight regulations on how they are operated. Employees from vacation rental company HomeAway’s Austin headquarters marched on City Hall in protest.

The Texas Public Policy Foundation, a research institute, sued the city claiming the STR ordinance violated several constitutional rights, from property rights to the freedom of movement, privacy and assembly.

“It’s not constitutional for you to tell me how many people I can have come over and watch a football game just because I am staying in a short-term rental,” said Robert Henneke, general counsel and litigation director at the foundation.

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton joined the lawsuit against Austin, claiming the ordinance violates the Constitution by stripping away a revenue stream from property owners without providing just compensation.

Tovo said the city would prevail against unmerited claims raised in the lawsuits.

“Most cities ... separate commercial and residential zoning, and that’s what we’re doing here,” she said. “An attack on that ... would really be an attack on our ability to zone.”

Henneke said he expects to present evidence and receive a decision on the case this fall.

By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following two years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Su


Bikers ride up Shoal Creek Boulevard in February. A bond proposal from Austin would fund additional bike lanes, sidewalk reconstruction, capital improvements and more. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin will send $460 million transportation bond to voters in November

The bond would fund include capital improvements to a number of projects, including the Longhorn Dam Bridge over Lady Bird Lake. The cost to the median Austin taxpayer would be about $77-$80 per year.

The future location on South Congress Avenue would be the third located in the South Austin area. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
P. Terry's plans for S. Congress drive-thru and more Austin-area news

Read the latest Austin-area business and community news.

Tesla announced its decision to bring its next gigafactory to Travis County on July 22. (Jay Jones/Community Impact Newspaper)
Tesla posts first gigafactory jobs as construction gets underway in Travis County

The company has 49 active listings for Austin-area jobs related to the gigafactory and other operations.

A police officer rides past protesters during the June 7 Justice for Them All March. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Police transformation begins in Austin as City Council approves millions in budget cuts, reinvestments, commitments

The move comes in response to a national and local reckoning over police brutality and the future of public safety.

Capital Metro's plan to build rail lines and expand its public transportation network, Project Connect, will head to voters in the city of Austin on Nov. 3. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Project Connect officially in the hands of Austin voters Nov. 3

Austin City Council took its final vote Aug. 13 on a plan to ask voters for approximately $3.85 billion in local revenue to expand the city's public transportation network.

Austin Regional Clinic location
Austin Regional Clinic now recruiting for coronavirus vaccine trial

Local health care provider Austin Regional Clinic will recruit 250 patients from the Austin area to participate in a late-phase clinical trial for a coronavirus vaccine.

The future location on South Congress Avenue would be the third located in the South Austin area. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
P. Terry's submits plans for new S. Congress drive-thru

The future location would be the third located in the South Austin area.

(Courtesy AMC Theatres)
AMC Theatres to reopen Aug. 20 with 15-cent tickets

AMC Theatres—which has multiple locations in the Austin, Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston areas—will begin reopening its movie screens Aug. 20.

Austin bars scrap for survival during monthslong shutdown

Bars are fighting through red tape to reclassify as restaurants, offering takeout orders and finding new uses for their spaces. Local business owners said they are finding every avenue possible to survive.

According to the report, 380,174 total COVID-19 cases have been reported in children nationwide as of Aug. 6, which accounts for approximately 9.1% of all confirmed COVID-19 cases in the U.S. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
REPORT: COVID-19 cases in children increase by 90% nationwide in 1 month

As school district officials across the U.S. prepare for the start of the 2020-21 school year, 179,990 new COVID-19 cases were reported in children nationwide between July 9 and Aug. 6—an increase of 90%, according to a report compiled by The American Academy of Pediatrics and the Children's Hospital Association.

Austin City Council is considering moving the forensics lab services and internal affairs department out from under the Austin Police Department and into civilian roles. (John Cox/Community Impact Newspaper)
Police cuts, community reinvestment, reimagining public safety on table as Austin City Council looks to adopt budget

City Council is considering a cut of more than a $150 million to the police budget.