Short-term rental restrictions remain in crosshairs after legislative session ends

Austin's restrictions on short-term rentals remain under fire because of a pending lauwsuit filed in 2016 claiming several parts of the city's ordinance violate the U.S. Constitution.

Austin's restrictions on short-term rentals remain under fire because of a pending lauwsuit filed in 2016 claiming several parts of the city's ordinance violate the U.S. Constitution.

The city of Austin’s short-term rental, or STR, ordinance, which regulates the existence of non-owner-occupied vacation units in residential neighborhoods, survived a potential blow during the Texas Legislature’s recent session.


Although a bill that would have stripped localities of STR regulating power and given it to the state did not pass, Austin’s restrictions on STRs remain under fire because of a pending lawsuit filed in 2016 that claims several parts of the city’s ordinance violate the U.S. Constitution.


What follows is an explanation of how the city arrived at its existing policies and the subsequent legal backlash against its regulations: City Council passed an ordinance in 2012 allowing for the regulation and licensing of STRs. Mayor Pro Tem Kathie Tovo said it was understood that the program was only a pilot and would likely need to be adjusted.


The council defined an STR as a property that is leased for less than 30 consecutive days and created three types: Type 1, or owner-occupied, multifamily, single-family or duplex units; Type 2, or non-owner-occupied single-family or duplex units;  and Type 3, or non-owner-occupied multifamily units.


In response to residents' concerns in 2015 about Type 2 units that had been brought into residential neighborhoods, Tovo said discussion focused on the once-single-family properties becoming hotels and “party houses.”


Tovo said she and her colleagues saw another issue taking shape: Type 2 STRs were set up to become investor-owned commercial properties, which did not belong in single-family neighborhoods.


“We have a situation where we’re talking all the time about how to create more housing opportunities throughout the city, but we have a policy that allows some of our housing stock to be converted into commercial services,” Tovo said.


Council voted in February 2016 to end the issuance of new Type 2 licenses, phase them out of neighborhoods by 2022 and place tight regulations on how they are operated. Employees from vacation rental company HomeAway’s Austin headquarters marched on City Hall in protest.


The Texas Public Policy Foundation, a research institute, sued the city claiming the STR ordinance violated several constitutional rights, from property rights to the freedom of movement, privacy and assembly.


“It’s not constitutional for you to tell me how many people I can have come over and watch a football game just because I am staying in a short-term rental,” said Robert Henneke, general counsel and litigation director at the foundation.


Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton joined the lawsuit against Austin, claiming the ordinance violates the Constitution by stripping away a revenue stream from property owners without providing just compensation.


Tovo said the city would prevail against unmerited claims raised in the lawsuits.


“Most cities ... separate commercial and residential zoning, and that’s what we’re doing here,” she said. “An attack on that ... would really be an attack on our ability to zone.”


Henneke said he expects to present evidence and receive a decision on the case this fall.

By


MOST RECENT

Traffic moves along the upper decks of I-35 near downtown Austin on Dec. 1. The Texas Department of Transportation is seeking public feedback on a $4.9 billion project to improve the 8-mile stretch of I-35 through downtown. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
TxDOT is spending billions to fix I-35 through downtown Austin, but some community members say the state is wrong in its approach

A report from the Texas A&M Transportation Institute released Dec. 1 said the 8-mile stretch of I-35 from Hwy. 290 to SH 71 is the most congested roadway in the state.

Pravo Construction opened a new headquarters at Two Barton Skyway, 1601 MoPac, Austin, on Nov. 1. (Courtesy CBRE)
Now open in Austin: New coffee shop, offices and medical clinics arrive south of river

New businesses operating in Austin include MilkRun, which delivers dairy, meat, produce and other products from local farmers to customers at home.

Graphic of a coronavirus unit
COVID-19 rates after Thanksgiving have yet to climb, but experts say spike could still be coming

As Austin awaits a vaccine whose first doses could arrive by the end of 2020, health officials say the impact of Thanksgiving gatherings on the spread of the virus could take time to show up.

The Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board has launched a campaign to address declining college enrollment numbers across the state since the pandemic started. (Courtesy Pexels)
Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board launches campaign to boost college enrollment

The decline in college enrollment across the state of Texas has prompted several agencies to partner up and create online resources for students and counselors.

Photo of a hand dropping a ballot in a box
Candidates for Austin City Council District 10 face off ahead of Dec. 15 runoff

Incumbent Alison Alter and challenger Jennifer Virden are vying for the seat.

Austin City Hall (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Public safety, homelessness in Austin take center stage in final forum before District 6 runoff vote

Three days ahead of the first day of early voting for the Austin City Council District 6 runoff election, a final public debate was mostly focused on issues of public safety.

This is a view of the new William Cannon Drive bridge from I-35 in South Austin. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
South Austin motorists should brace for lane closures, delays on I-35 this week

Roadwork in the area overall is expected to continue until the middle of 2021.

Campuses in Austin ISD will be closes to in-person learning the week after Thanksgiving break. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
All Austin ISD classes to be held online through Dec. 4

The district will also be providing free COVID-19 tests to staff and families Dec. 2-4.

Bicycles for public use are docked at a MetroBike station on Lake Austin Boulevard. Austin's $460 million Proposition B will include funding for additional bicycle lanes through the city. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Breaking down Austin's $460 million bond for bike lanes, trails, sidewalks and more

The bond will fun a bridge over Pleasant Valley Road connecting two ends of the Ann and Roy Butler Hike and Bike trail, among other improvements.

Local health leaders are urging caution ahead of Thanksgiving. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Ahead of Thanksgiving, Travis County health officials urge caution

Austin Public Health leaders say gatherings with people outside one's household held indoors and without masks pose the greatest risk.

Harini Logan, 10, won the 66th annual Express-News Spelling Bee at the University of Texas at San Antonio downtown campus on March 17, 2019. For 2021, the event is slated to be held in March at the Brauntex Performing Arts Theatre in New Braunfels. (Photo by Jerry Lara, courtesy the San Antonio Express News)
New Braunfels to host regional spelling bee and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from Central Texas.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced a COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan for the state Nov. 23 for a vaccine he said could be available as soon as December. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announces COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan

The vaccine could start being distributed "as early as next month," according to a Nov. 23 news release.