Report: APD used force against, racially profiled African-Americans more than any group

Austin police officers in 2015 stopped African-Americans more and used force against them more frequently than any other ethnic group, a new report shows.

The full annual report was released Tuesday by the Office of the Austin Police Monitor, which accepts and files public complaints as well as internal Austin Police Department complaints against the department's 1,752 officers. The report shows statistics on the number, type and frequency of complaints filed against APD officers and offers recommendations for improving compliance.

The major findings show African-Americans had a 1-in-7 chance of being searched if stopped by police, compared to the 1-in-9 chance for Hispanic or Latino individuals and a 1-in-21 chance for Caucasians in 2015.

"Simply put, blacks/African-Americans had force used [against them] more while Caucasians had force used less than their percentage of arrests," the report said.

As a possible solution, the office recommended making publicly available the data that stems from vehicle and pedestrian stops, even if they don't result in a citation or arrest. It also recommended regularly performing routine audits on traffic stops and on reports filed to ensure there is no racial profiling.

Austin Police Department responds 


Interim Police Chief Brian Manley said those findings were consistent with what the Center for Policing Equity/Urban Institute found when it studied APD's 2015 vehicle stops and 2014 use-of-force incidents.

"They did a very thorough review of us, and they found some discrepancies," he said, pointing to the fact that APD officers police more heavily in lower-income neighborhoods where there are higher crime rates and an overrepresentation of the minority population.

He pointed out the statistics aren't just shaped by the officers' actions; a judge also has to sign probable cause affidavits brought forth by the police.

"There's a system of checks and balances," Manley said.

He said de-escalation was a central theme in the police monitor's report, but that practice is nothing new to APD.

"[De-escalation] is woven into all of our training," he said. He added the department was in agreement with the police monitor's recommendation to emphasize de-escalation.

Use of force


Separate from the statistics on race as it relates to complaints, the police monitor found thousands of use-of-force incidents are recorded by APD each year in the department's annual Response to Resistance report—3,273 reports involving 1,888 people in 2015—yet less than 50 incidents are resulting in complaints and catching the eye of the police monitor's office.

"Given the number of incidents in which the APD uses force, the number of external allegations seems low," Police Monitor Margo Frasier wrote in the report.

Manley responded to that statement with a question: "What number would you expect, and what is the basis for you expecting that number?"

He said it wasn't fair that the police monitor's office was implying there was something wrong with the system because the use-of-force numbers are lower than the police monitor's office thinks they should be.

The police monitor recommended addressing the use-of-force discrepancies by routinely auditing the use of force reports.

"The [police monitor's office] cannot know how many people who had force used on them even know about the complaint process," Frasier wrote. "Nor can we know how many people simply chose not to make a complaint."

If deficiencies are discovered, training, policy development and/or discipline should be considered, the report recommended.

Classifications


When a formal complaint is filed, it is sent to the Internal Affairs Department with a recommendation for classification. A formal complaint can have one of the following classifications:

  • Administrative inquiry—a critical incident, ordered by the chief

  • A—allegations of a serious nature that include criminal conduct and/or objectively unreasonable force resulting in an injury that needs emergency medical treatment at a medical facility

  • B—allegations of a less serious nature; less serious violations of APD policy and objectively unreasonable force resulting in minor injuries

  • C—allegations that don’t fit into class A or B and don’t rise to the level of a policy violation

  • D—not a policy violation, or the allegation is not true. The case is considered "administratively closed."


The OPM found 53 percent of external formal complaints received a "D" classification in 2015, down slightly from 2014's 57 percent.

Frasier said caution should be taken when using the "D" classification because it "essentially predicts the result of the investigation or precludes actually conducting an investigation."

She said a "D" classification "seems to infer from the beginning that IAD has recommended to the chain of command that the allegation has no merit."

She recommended ADP take greater care in classifying cases as "D" and said if it's not clear whether the complaint has merit, it should be classified as "A" or "B." If it turns out the officer didn't commit a violation, the complaint should be classified as "unfounded" instead of "administratively closed."

Accountability, changes to reporting


To Manley, the fact that 216 of the 280 formal complaints filed in 2015 were internal shows the police department's supervisors are willing to hold the officers accountable for their actions.

"Obviously, you don't want to have complaints against the department," he said. "We're the 11th-largest city in the country, so to think we should go without complaints is unreasonable."

Manley said one big change coming out of the police monitor's recommendations is the reporting of all vehicle and pedestrian stops, not just those that result in a citation or arrest, which is required by law to report.

Reporting on stops that don't result in an arrest or citation was implemented Jan. 1, and Manley said right now, a lot of manual work is being done to keep track of these while the department works to create an automated solution.

More statistics


Here are some other statistics from the report:

  • In 2015, 1,134 people contacted the police monitor's office or the APD's Internal Affairs Department to file a complaint against someone in APD, yet only 552 were filed as complaints. The police monitor's report said oftentimes that was because the person who called to file a complaint was not directly involved in the incident. Only someone directly involved may file a complaint with the police monitor.

  • Caucasians—who make up the majority of the voting age population within city limits—filed the most complaints overall.

  • Caucasians were stopped 4 percent less than their representation of the voting age population, while African Americans were stopped at a rate 5 percent above their representation.

  • Fifty-six percent of the time, nothing was found in a probable cause search.

  • Allegations of bias-based profiling were recorded 18 times.

  • The downtown area recorded the highest number of allegations, followed by Central East Austin, Southwest Austin and Southeast Austin.

  • As in years past, male officers received more complaints against them than their representation on the police force.

  • 63 percent of officers with a complaint in 2015 had at least one previous complaint between 2011 and 2014.

  • 53 percent of males and 47 percent of females filed complaints.

  • Code-of-conduct allegations, which include compliance, instances of dishonesty, accountability and relationships with coworkers, made up the most complaints filed.

  • For the past five years, the majority of the police force—68 percent to 74 percent of all officers—have not had a complaint lodged against them.

SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

Byron Smith, left, and Tim Manson are planning to break ground on their new storage business called XSpace in late January. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Australian businessmen betting on success of innovative storage model in western Travis County

A primary difference between their model and more traditional storage models, they say, is the fact that their units are for sale and not for rent. But there are other differences.

The Microtel Inn and Suites is located in Southeast Austin, only a 4.5-mile drive from the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. (COURTESY GOOGLE MAPS)
City Council eyes $6.8 million purchase of 71-room hotel in Southeast Austin for second homeless shelter conversion

The Microtel Inn and Suites is a 4.5 mile drive from the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport

Following allegations that an assistant chief used racist and homophobic language, the Austin Police Department may have to suspend future cadet classes. Austin City Council supported an investigation into the department at a Dec. 5 meeting. (Courtesy Austin Police Department)
Austin City Council supports expansive investigation into police department culture and training, likely suspends one future cadet class

The move follows allegations that a former high-ranking officers regularly used racial slurs throughout his career with no recourse from department leaders.

Residents in District 10 look over proposed zoning map during a meeting in October. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
City Council will hear thoughts from residents on comprehensive revision to land use rules at weekend hearing

City Council will take its first of three votes on the land development code revision Dec. 9.

A photo of the exterior of the Moxie Gymnastics and Cheer facility, taken from the parking lot.
Moxie Gymnastics and Cheer celebrates move to new facility

Moxie Gymnastics and Cheer has moved to a new location in Dripping Springs.

Sarah House, a Wells Fargo Securities senior economist and director, speaks at the Austin Chamber of Commerce's annual economic outlook, held Dec. 5 at the Hyatt Regency hotel in Austin. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Economic analyst: Austin economy still strong, but growth has tapered off heading into 2020

At the Austin Chamber of Commerce's annual economic outlook, Sarah House of Wells Fargo said Austin faces challenges of affordability and a tight labor market.

Courtesy Fotolia
City Council wants to know whether some public drinking prohibitions are equitable

The city of Austin allows the public consumption of alcohol except in six designated areas.

Travis County Commissioner Gerald Daugherty in May addressed constituents in Bee Cave regarding the $23 million Bee Creek Sports Complex. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Longtime Travis County Commissioner Gerald Daugherty will not seek re-election following end of current term

Daugherty has served western Travis County for the last 14 years, with terms from 2002-2008 and 2013 to the present.

The 8,800 square-foot space includes a dining room, bar, outdoor patio and butcher room. (Courtesy Carve American Grille)
Carve American Grille opening in Southwest Austin's Lantana Place later this month

Carve American Grille will open in Southwest Austin in mid December

The city of Austin authorized the purchase of a Rodeway Inn at 2711 S. I-35 on Nov. 14. The city plans to convert the property into a homeless shelter. (Olivia Aldridge/Community Impact Newspaper)
City staff must be more transparent as city moves toward motel shelter strategy, Austin City Council says

Austin City Council is preparing to purchase another motel for conversion into a homeless shelter, but urged staff to be more transparent as motels are chosen.

A photo of a ribbon cutting in front of a tiny home.
Infinity Ranch brings tiny-home rentals to Dripping Springs

Infinity Ranch is offering bed and breakfast-style nightly rentals in the Hill Country.

Following allegations that an assistant chief used racist and homophobic language, the Austin Police Department may have to suspend future cadet classes. Austin City Council will consider the delay, and an investigation into the department, at a Dec. 5 meeting. Courtesy Austin Police Department
Austin City Council authorizes APD investigation after assistant chief accused of racist and homophobic slurs

In a unanimous vote Dec. 5, Austin City Council directed city manager Spencer Cronk to initiate a widespread, independent investigation into the culture and practices of the Austin Police Department following an anonymous whistleblower complaint that an assistant chief had regularly used racist and homophobic language throughout his career at the department.

Back to top