West Lake Hills short-term rental committee to take second look at survey draft

Council members Darin Walker and Beth South discuss the draft of the short-term rental citizen survey.

Council members Darin Walker and Beth South discuss the draft of the short-term rental citizen survey.

A citywide survey drafted to gain insight into how West Lake Hills citizens feel about short-term rentals in their community is being sent back to the drawing board.

The five-page online survey, created by a subcommittee after months of discussions, was presented at city council’s March 23 meeting. Residents commented both in favor and in opposition to the survey as well as the idea of codifying an ordinance.

The questions ranged from asking if the citizen has any experience with STRs to what kind of regulations citizens would like, including special-use permits and limitations on capacity and length of stay.

Mayor Linda Anthony said the draft survey questions were “seemingly biased,” and several citizens said the draft survey survey targeted only the negative aspects of STRs.

“Going into this survey with the presupposition that we absolutely need new regulations and new ways to pay for those regulations, that’s my concern,” West Lake Hills resident Scott Griffin said.

The questions implied there was already a problem and that these STRs needed to be regulated, he said.

Anthony said since last summer, the city council received multiple complaints from various neighborhoods including Black Acre, leading council members to believe STRs needed to be regulated in some way. The council formed a subcommittee—including council members Stan Graham and Darin Walker—in November to address these concerns.

Graham said after reviewing the concerns, he felt “pretty strongly” about regulating STRs in some manner.

“There are problems,” he said. “We discovered our city code doesn’t necessarily address those problems. It may not be a large problem, but there’s certainly a potential for a much bigger one.”

In neighboring Rollingwood, short-term rentals have been banned since 2010. In December, Lakeway passed an ordinance limiting the number of special-use permits allowed for short-term rentals to 43, and Bee Cave currently does not regulate STRs.

STR owner Gretchen Lara-Shartle said her rental is located about 70-80 feet from her own home. She said she did not want city council to “punish” everyone for the actions of those STRs that are causing complaints.

“I don’t personally see a problem with licensing,” Lara-Shartle said. “You can just take away someone’s license if they are doing something that is wrong, like making noise.”

Anthony said after hearing residents’ comments at the meeting, she would like to see the draft survey reviewed.

“To be quite honest, we don’t have a good handle of what the public perception of short-term rentals is,” she said.

David Garza, who lives on Wildcat Hollow, said he would like the survey to be drafted by a professional survey writer. Graham said the subcommittee would consider the idea.

Council members unanimously approved postponing possible action on the draft survey to April 13 following a review by the STR subcommittee. 


MOST RECENT

Screen shot of Dr. Desmar Walkes speaking
Austin ICUs remain crowded with COVID-19 patients, delaying some critical care

Within the past week, there was a waiting list of patients to be transferred into Austin-area ICUs, Austin Public Health leaders said.

The city of Austin this summer cleared four unregulated homeless encampments and shifted dozens of residents into shelters. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Plan to house thousands of Austin's homeless people taking shape, but outlook for local success, project funding still unclear

The strategy's first housing benchmark fell short in June, and updates on how the estimated $515 million needed for housing and services will be spent are overdue.

graphic
DATA: How population changed in Texas counties between census counts in 2010, 2020

Texas added nearly four million people between 2010 and 2020, according to the latest Census data.

BoxLunch opened Aug. 27 in Barton Creek Square at 2901 S. Capital of Texas Hwy., Austin. (Greg Perliski/Community Impact Newspaper)
New dining, clothing retailers now open or coming soon to the Lake Travis-Westlake area

Along with new retailers, area residents now have new health care providers from which to choose.

The widening project is on track to finish this fall and the bypass project by early next year. (Courtesy Texas Department of Transportation)
TxDOT projects near RM 2222 and RM 620 intersection approaching completion after delay

The southbound bypass lane connecting the two roads is on track to be complete later this fall, weather permitting. The northbound bypass lane opened over the summer.

Owners Billy-Joe and Suzanne Hunt opened The Gramercy in October 2020. (Photos by Greg Perliski/Community Impact Newspaper)
The Gramercy: Lakeway restaurant brings style of the big-city lounge to the Hill Country

Diners can choose from a variety of classic cocktails and entrees.

The Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission considered a finalized draft of an updated map for Austin's 10 City Council districts Sept. 15. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
UPDATED: Draft map of Austin's redrawn City Council boundaries ready for community review

Volunteer city redistricting commissioners have unanimously passed an initial outline to update all 10 City Council districts set to go into effect next year.

Bee Cave City Council adopted a $10.92 million budget Sept 14. (Greg Perliski/Community Impact Newspaper)
Bee Cave City Council adopts FY 2021-22 budget

Sales taxes represent the largest revenue source for the city of Bee Cave.

The low-water crossing at Great Divide Drive was flooded by Little Barton Creek in May 2019. Following council action Sept. 14, city staff will now work with an engineering firm to finalize a bridge design. (Courtesy James Cooke)
Bee Cave City Council votes to hire engineering firm to design Great Divide Drive bridge crossing

Bridge construction would not begin until after public input and completed design.

The city Music Commission met Sept. 13 to consider final outlines for the Live Music Fund Event Program and Austin Music Disaster Relief Fund 3.0.
Austin moving closer to sending out millions for live music events, musician recovery

Two upcoming city funding opportunities are being designed to support music industry events and provide emergency stabilization for those in the music sector.

Photo of county commissioners and community nonprofit leaders at a press conference
Travis County commits $110 million in federal funding to combat homelessness

The allocation will fund 2,000 supportive housing units.