Amid objections, Austin’s east side council members to push overhaul of policies experts say target the homeless

The Austin Resource Center for the Homeless is the lone city-operated homeless shelter in Austin.

The Austin Resource Center for the Homeless is the lone city-operated homeless shelter in Austin.

Following years filled with questioning, testimonies, audit reports and campaigns, Austin’s four City Council members representing the east side are leading a push to amend or repeal three ordinances that experts say directly target the growing homeless population.

The no-sit, no-lie ordinance prohibits sitting or lying down on public sidewalks and sleeping outdoors in the homeless-heavy downtown area; the no-camping rule outlaws camping in a public area not specifically designated for the act; the no-solicitation law forbids panhandling and asking people for money.

Critics of the existing ordinances, which include legal experts, advocates and city representatives, said the laws not only present barriers to exiting homelessness, but also potential constitutional violations on behalf of the city.

“We won’t be able to arrest away our city’s homelessness problem,” Council Member Greg Casar said in a press release.

Casar joined fellow eastern crescent Council Members Natasha Harper-Madison, Pio Renteria and Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza in calling for the change.

“Asking for money, sitting or lying down in public, and sleeping in tents are basic requirements of survival, especially while homeless," Casar said. "Criminalizing this behavior is unjust and unconstitutional, and can prevent people from getting into housing or support services – the very thing they need to get off the streets,”

Creating barriers and constitutional violations


Although city leaders have been hearing from homeless service providers, housing advocates, legal experts and city staff about the dangers the laws pose for years, a heavy push began following a 2017 report from the city auditor’s office that condemned the ordinances as regressive, ineffective and inefficient in the city’s efforts to address homelessness. The audit reported out of 18,000 citations issued between 2014-16, people frequently did not appear in court, often leading to arrest warrants, which could hurt a person’s prospects for an apartment or job.

The audit also highlighted constitutional violations embedded in the ordinances, such as the freedom of speech breach by the no-solicitation law. Austin has also long been criticized by community members for lacking shelter beds to accommodate its homeless population—the city has roughly 490 beds for a homeless population that ranges from 2,000 to 7,000 per night. Other cities have faced lawsuits against camping ordinances on this basis.

“The basic premise of the lawsuits [is] that when homeless shelters are full, people experiencing homelessness have no way to comply with the ordinance and it violates their constitutional rights,” the audit read.

A step in the right direction?


The ordinance to go in front of City Council on June 6 aims to repeal the no-solicitation ordinance. It would also narrow the no-camping and no-sit, no-lie prohibitions to cite only those who are “materially endangering” the health and safety of other people or themselves and whose use of the public property is “unreasonably inconvenient.”

As local advocacy group Grassroots Leadership’s campaign coordinator, Chris Harris has been at the forefront of the campaign to repeal the ordinances. Outside of City Council’s final meeting in December 2018, Harris led a group of advocates, outside in sub-freezing evening temperatures, calling for some City Council members to make good on campaign promises to address the laws.

Harris said May 29 that although he and his coalition are happy to see the “significant effort” to reduce homelessness criminalization, he still thinks there is work to do.

“The [current] ordinances are just a failure,” Harris said. “We think [the proposed changes] will reduce criminalization significantly, but it’s still clear the ordinances target people experiencing homelessness.”

Representatives from Austin Police Department have defended the ordinances in the past, saying they not only help maintain order but offer a buffer that allows officers to cite individuals instead of charging them with heavier misdemeanors.

No one from the Austin Police Department was immediately available for comment.

The Downtown Austin Alliance, a cohort of business owners and downtown stakeholders, released a statement May 29 strongly opposing the council members’ proposal, saying the city should instead focus on increasing homelessness services.

“Changing the ordinances … doesn’t solve Austin’s worsening issue of homelessness and, in fact, creates a multitude of serious health concerns for those who are living unsheltered and for the community as a whole,” said Dewitt Peart, the president and CEO of the DAA, in an emailed statement. “Austin needs to ensure people experiencing homelessness can be safe during the day and at night, so they no longer need to live on the streets. The [DAA] implores Austin City Council to put shelter and housing solutions in place and slow down to allow for community input on this very serious matter that will affect our entire community.”

In 2018, the Downtown Commission, members of which are appointed by City Council to advise on policies that impact downtown, unanimously recommended City Council back off from loosening or changing the three ordinances. The Downtown Commission last met May 15 and will not meet again until June 19. Vice Chairperson Jennifer Bristol said the commission was unaware City Council members planned to push the ordinance changes at their June 6 meeting.

Alan Graham, the CEO and founder of Mobile Loaves and Fishes, a faith-based group focused on feeding and providing permanent housing for the homeless, said homelessness is directly tied to a “catastrophic disconnection” from the larger community.

“Criminalizing behaviors associated with homelessness further that disconnection,” Graham said. “Changing these ordinances is one step in the direction of reconnection and palliative relief for our brothers and sisters on the streets of Austin.”

City Council is scheduled to vote on the ordinances Thursday, June 6.
By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following two years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Su


MOST RECENT

A photo of a man making a curbside purchase at Bikealot
South Austin bike shops connect with new cyclists during “no ordinary bike month”

Local bike shops have seen a swell of Austinites dusting off old bikes to get moving during the coronavirus pandemic.

A map of the Jester King Brewery property
Jester King Brewery to reopen with new, park-style amenities May 29

Following Gov. Greg Abbott's go-ahead for bars and breweries to reopen last week, Jester King is opening its property to guests.

Austin Public Health planning response in case of coronavirus hospitalization spike

As local health authorities monitor an upward trend in COVID-19 cases, they are bracing for a possible uptick in hospitalizations.

There have been 1,084 total coronavirus recoveries in Travis County as of May 27. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Travis County reports 73 new coronavirus cases May 27

There have been 1,084 total coronavirus recoveries in Travis County as well.

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar spoke to members of the Clear Lake Area Chamber of Commerce on May 27 about what the state's post-pandemic economic turnaround might look like. (Screenshot of May 27 virtual luncheon)
Texas comptroller predicts slow, steady economic turnaround post-pandemic

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar said the state entered the era of the coronavirus in a healthy financial situation, which bodes well for the future as reopening continues, but that Texans are not out of the woods yet.

Traffic on toll roads operated by the Central Texas Regional Mobility Authority has steadily climbed over the last two months after nosediving in March. (Amy Denney/Community Impact Newspaper)
As economic restrictions loosen, some Central Texas toll roads are beginning to fill up with traffic

Traffic counts on roads operated by the Central Texas Regional Mobility Authority have consistently climbed since early April.

Nursing facilities across Texas will be able to apply for federal funds to purchase devices to connect residents to friends and family. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Gov. Greg Abbott announces $3.6 million project to connect nursing home residents to families

Gov. Greg Abbott announced May 27 that $3.6 million will be provided to nursing facilities to purchase tablets, webcams and headphones to connect residents with family members.

Amie Gonser will open 620 Art Gallery & Studio in June as a fine art gallery and space for art education classes. (Courtesy Amie Gonser)
IMPACTS ROUNDUP: News on 20 Central Texas businesses and nonprofits

Read about Central Texas business news from Community Impact Newspaper's coverage this week.

Southwest Austin roads have been less trafficked as the coronavirus pandemic his impacted work situations for area residents. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
DATA: Southwest Austin area has seen 18,432 unemployment claims since mid-March

The number represents about 7.1% of the population in Southwest Austin's nine ZIP codes.

A new executive has been brought in to fill leadership roles at the University of Texas at Austin Dell Medical School and Dell Children’s Medical Center. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Dell Children’s Medical Center, Dell Medical School announce new addition to executive team

A new medical executive has been brought in to fill leadership roles at Dell Medical School and Dell Children’s Medical Center.

Voters are encouraged to bring their own equipment in order to prevent catching or spreading coronavirus.(Graphic by Matthew T. Mills /Community Impact Newspaper)
State of Texas releases voter health checklist for polling stations in June and July

Texas Secretary of State Ruth Hughs released a checklist May 26 for voters to follow to help prevent the spread of coronavirus at polls.

The Townlake YMCA is one of the local facilities reopening June 1. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
YMCA of Austin to reopen area facilities June 1

Townlake YMCA, Southwest Family YMCA, Northwest Family YMCA, Springs Family YMCA, Bastrop YMCA and Hay Communities YMCA facilities will be reopening June 1.