Judge: Decision on CodeNEXT petition will come 'as soon as possible'

Attorney Fred Lewis, who represents the CodeNEXT petitioners, answers questions from media following the CodeNEXT lawsuit hearing on July 2.

Attorney Fred Lewis, who represents the CodeNEXT petitioners, answers questions from media following the CodeNEXT lawsuit hearing on July 2.

After hearing the city and petitioners argue whether the question of a public vote on CodeNEXT should be on November’s ballot, Travis County District Judge Orlinda Naranjo said she understood the question’s “short fuse” and will decide “as soon as possible.”

Austin is undergoing a five-year, $8.5 million rewrite of its land development code—known as CodeNEXT—in response to the pressures caused by rapid population growth. Proposed zoning changes that would add housing density in central city neighborhoods have dominated much of the debate, and in March, the city clerk received a valid petition signed by more than 31,000 Austinites demanding CodeNEXT’s fate depend on a public, not City Council, vote.

City Council’s rejection of the public vote notion resulted in a lawsuit—heard Monday—between the petitioners and city leaders. Should Naranjo side with the petitioners the city would have to ask voters whether they think they have the right to vote on a land development code rewrite. The city has until Aug. 20 to put that question on the November ballot. Otherwise, City Council is expected to vote on CodeNEXT this fall.

Can citizens vote on zoning matters?


Monday’s hearing featured many of the same arguments the sides have publicly made. The petitioners, represented by local attorneys Bill Bunch and Fred Lewis, say City Council should not stand in the way of a people’s right to vote on an issue that impacts them. The city, represented by Jane Webre of Scott, Douglas & McConnico, said when it comes to zoning, state law limits the use of public elections—a law the city has no choice but to follow.

However, Lewis and Bunch argued the question proposed for November’s ballot has nothing to do with zoning, or CodeNEXT, but rather with City Council's duties. Residents petitioned City Council to create an ordinance requiring land development code rewrites to be approved by a public vote. Since council voted against creating the ordinance, law mandates the question be placed on the ballot and voters decide.

Lewis said the petitioned ordinance deals with land development code rewrites and argued not all land development codes involve zoning. He said the question of voting rights on zoning cases is only relevant after voters approve the ordinance, the city adopts it and then CodeNEXT is placed on the ballot. Until then, Lewis said, it is impossible to know what CodeNEXT might be; however, he maintained that people should have the right to vote on it.

“People should have a say; it will affect their property, their home, their neighborhood, their community and their city,” Lewis said. “Council is interfering with people’s right to vote. We don’t do that in a democracy.”

Although council made the decision to reject to the petition, said Webre, its actions were only a reflection of state statute, which has withdrawn questions of zoning from public elections.

“The election itself would violate the law because the subject matter is withdrawn from the field [of possibilities],” Webre said.

Webre said zoning makes up roughly 44 percent of CodeNEXT's pages and that its "tentacles" reach even further. Zoning is "inextricable" from CodeNEXT, she said, and "mayhem" would ensue if only the zoning portion of the code remained following a public vote.
SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

The Atlas 14 rainfall study found Austin to be at a much higher flood risk than previously understood.
Acknowledging expanded risk, Austin moves to prohibit additional density in city’s flood-prone areas

A recent federal flood risk study found Austin's flood risk to be significantly higher than previously understood.

The Dove Springs Recreation Center could be named after current Travis County Constable George Morales III. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Dove Springs Recreation Center could be renamed after Constable George Morales

The Dove Springs Recreation Center could be renamed after Constable George Morales, although some residents oppose changing the park's name at all.

The city of Austin authorized the purchase of a Rodeway Inn at 2711 S. I-35 on Nov. 14. The city plans to convert the property into a homeless shelter. (Olivia Aldridge/Community Impact Newspaper)
City Council green lights $8 million Rodeway Inn plan for homeless shelter transition, vows to address crime in the area

South Austin neighbors raised concerns that criminal activity in the area will put homeless individuals who enter the shelter at risk.

New Brightway insurance office opens in South Austin

Brightway, The Trusted Agency opened a new office in late October.

Marucci Clubhouse baseball facility opens in Southwest Austin

Marucci Clubhouse opened its new Southwest Austin location in October.

Lady Bird Lake at Congress Avenue in Austin. Since late July, parts of the lake have been off limits due to high concentrations of toxic "blue-green" algae. (Courtesy Miguel Gutierrez Jr./The Texas Tribune)
Toxic algae blooms are becoming more common, scientists say

Months have passed, but the capital city still has signs up warning of ongoing dangerous conditions in Lady Bird Lake.

Community members examine updated zoning maps at land development code town hall in October.
Land development code rewrite heads to City Council for final approval, marking home stretch of nearly 7-year process

Austin's long-awaited land development code rewrite is heading to City Council for final approval.

Crews work on updating a section of I-35 in Central Texas (Courtesy TxDOT)
Central Texas transportation agencies investing millions in I-35 for new lanes, intersection improvements aimed at aiding mobility

About 20 miles of I-35 through Central Texas will see an infusion of $400 million in state and federal funding to add one to two additional lanes in an effort to improve mobility.

Sage Blossom Massage's new Oak Hill location features a salt room. Courtesy Sage Blossom Massage
Sage Blossom Massage now open in Oak Hill

Sage Blossom Massage's new Oak Hill location at 6705 W. Hwy. 290, Austin, opened in early October. Sage …

A photo of the Dripping Springs City Council.
Dripping Springs City Council opts for partial refund to Mark Black in wedding venue fee dispute

Dripping Springs City Council voted Nov. 12 to refund $2,121 of Mark Black's $12,800 request.

Delia Garza speaks to her constituents at a town hall meeting in 2017.
Austin Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza says she will not seek re-election as Travis County attorney rumors heat up

Austin's mayor pro tem will not seek reelection to her Southeast Austin district seat in 2020.

Deece Eckstein at the Nov. 12 Travis County Commissioners Court meeting
Travis County intergovernmental relations officer announces retirement, triggers "aggressive" hiring schedule

Deece Eckstein, Travis County's inaugural intergovernmental relations officer, will retire at the end of the year.

Back to top