Judge: Decision on CodeNEXT petition will come 'as soon as possible'

Attorney Fred Lewis, who represents the CodeNEXT petitioners, answers questions from media following the CodeNEXT lawsuit hearing on July 2.

Attorney Fred Lewis, who represents the CodeNEXT petitioners, answers questions from media following the CodeNEXT lawsuit hearing on July 2.

After hearing the city and petitioners argue whether the question of a public vote on CodeNEXT should be on November’s ballot, Travis County District Judge Orlinda Naranjo said she understood the question’s “short fuse” and will decide “as soon as possible.”

Austin is undergoing a five-year, $8.5 million rewrite of its land development code—known as CodeNEXT—in response to the pressures caused by rapid population growth. Proposed zoning changes that would add housing density in central city neighborhoods have dominated much of the debate, and in March, the city clerk received a valid petition signed by more than 31,000 Austinites demanding CodeNEXT’s fate depend on a public, not City Council, vote.

City Council’s rejection of the public vote notion resulted in a lawsuit—heard Monday—between the petitioners and city leaders. Should Naranjo side with the petitioners the city would have to ask voters whether they think they have the right to vote on a land development code rewrite. The city has until Aug. 20 to put that question on the November ballot. Otherwise, City Council is expected to vote on CodeNEXT this fall.

Can citizens vote on zoning matters?


Monday’s hearing featured many of the same arguments the sides have publicly made. The petitioners, represented by local attorneys Bill Bunch and Fred Lewis, say City Council should not stand in the way of a people’s right to vote on an issue that impacts them. The city, represented by Jane Webre of Scott, Douglas & McConnico, said when it comes to zoning, state law limits the use of public elections—a law the city has no choice but to follow.

However, Lewis and Bunch argued the question proposed for November’s ballot has nothing to do with zoning, or CodeNEXT, but rather with City Council's duties. Residents petitioned City Council to create an ordinance requiring land development code rewrites to be approved by a public vote. Since council voted against creating the ordinance, law mandates the question be placed on the ballot and voters decide.

Lewis said the petitioned ordinance deals with land development code rewrites and argued not all land development codes involve zoning. He said the question of voting rights on zoning cases is only relevant after voters approve the ordinance, the city adopts it and then CodeNEXT is placed on the ballot. Until then, Lewis said, it is impossible to know what CodeNEXT might be; however, he maintained that people should have the right to vote on it.

“People should have a say; it will affect their property, their home, their neighborhood, their community and their city,” Lewis said. “Council is interfering with people’s right to vote. We don’t do that in a democracy.”

Although council made the decision to reject to the petition, said Webre, its actions were only a reflection of state statute, which has withdrawn questions of zoning from public elections.

“The election itself would violate the law because the subject matter is withdrawn from the field [of possibilities],” Webre said.

Webre said zoning makes up roughly 44 percent of CodeNEXT's pages and that its "tentacles" reach even further. Zoning is "inextricable" from CodeNEXT, she said, and "mayhem" would ensue if only the zoning portion of the code remained following a public vote.
By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following two years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Su


MOST RECENT

Total Wine & More has been open for 5 years in Sunset Valley

The Sunset Valley location was the first to open in the Austin area.

COVID-19 hospitalizations also increased to 97 in the Austin metro. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
88 new coronavirus cases in Travis County on June 1 set single-day high

COVID-19 hospitalizations also increased to 97 in the Austin metro.

Director of Elementary Schools Monica Gonzalez said June 1 that the district is looking into training teachers this summer to prepare for partial or full-time virtual learning. (Courtesy Austin ISD)
Austin ISD planning for blended teaching approach for school year beginning Aug. 18

A blended approach would allow the district to switch from in-person learning to virtual learning when needed.

Protesters and Texas Rangers stood face to face during demonstrations at the Texas Capitol on May 31. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
National, state, local officials continue to blame outside agitators for turning protests violent over the weekend

As violence erupted in Austin and cities across the country over the weekend, leaders from all ranks said outside groups usurped the demonstrations and turned them chaotic.

A photo of SH 45 SW
SH 45 SW toll has been open in South Austin for a year

A long-planned toll road connected southwest Travis County and north Hays county clebrates its first anniversary.

Richard Rhodes, the president and CEO of Austin Community College, said June 1 that the district is prioritizing the hiring of a new chief equity, diversity and inclusion officer. (Courtesy Austin Community College)
Austin Community College prioritizing hiring equity officer despite ongoing hiring freeze

The district brought up the hiring during a discussion about protests and demonstrations that have taken place over the past weekend.

Businesses shuttering their doors due to coronavirus restrictions lowered the sales tax revenue collected by cities in May compared to May 2019. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas comptroller reports 13.2% year-over-year state sales tax revenue drop in May

Tax collection revenue fell significantly in several sectors from May 2019 to May 2020, according to the comptroller's office.

Demonstrators gathered at the Texas Capitol on May 31 to protest police brutality. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas officials respond to demonstrations, unrest in wake of George Floyd killing

Gov. Greg Abbott issued a state of disaster in Texas on May 31, while various city officials and law enforcment responded to protests and violence over the weekend.

A group of 16 mayors from municipalities within Travis County have signed a letter to County Judge Sam Biscoe requesting a per capita approach to the issue of COVID-19 relief funding. (Screenshot courtesy Kara King)
Group of 16 Travis County mayors signs letter requesting $23M in county COVID-19 relief funds

City leaders in Travis County, from Bee Cave to manor, have signed a letter to County Judge Sam Biscoe requesting more than $23 million in federal coronavirus relief funds be released to 21 municipalities as soon as possible.

Austin City Hall was one of several downtown buildings to be vandalized during this past weekend's protests. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin leaders, representatives react to weekend protests

Local, state and federal representatives took to social media throughout the weekend to voice their opinions.

Blazier Elementary School students break ground on a new relief campus in Southeast Austin in June 2019. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin ISD accepting names for new Blazier Elementary relief campus through June 5

The new relief campus for Blazier Elementary School will open this August.

Protesters march toward the Texas Capitol. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
PHOTOS: Demonstrators gathered in front of the Texas Capitol as protests against police brutality continued nationwide

Protests against the killings of Goerge Floyd and Michael Ramos took place throughout the weekend in Austin.